2008 Glenrothes by-election

Result

Background

Fife is traditionally a stronghold for the Labour Party. MacDougall had held Glenrothes and its forerunner, Central Fife, since 2001, when he succeeded Henry McLeish. Willie Hamilton had previously represented the area, which has elected Labour MPs since Hamilton won West Fife from the Communist Party of Great Britain in 1950.

The poll followed a run of poor by-election results for the Labour Party, which included a loss to the Scottish National Party (SNP) in Glasgow East, formerly the party's twenty-fifth safest seat in Britain. Glenrothes has a considerably smaller Labour majority than Glasgow East had.

According to the Financial Times, Labour privately admitted that they expected to lose Glenrothes to the SNP. The Guardian described the constituency's main town, Glenrothes, as a "core area" for the SNP. The SNP were in second place in the seat in the 2005 general election and won the nearest equivalent seat in the 2007 Scottish Parliament election.

The SNP also ran Fife Council, which covers the constituency, in coalition with the Scottish Liberal Democrats. The Scottish Liberal Democrats won the last by-election to be held in Fife from Labour on a swing of 16%.

Polling date

By tradition, the polling date was decided by Labour, as MacDougall's party, and set for Thursday, 6 November 2008.

Had the writ been moved immediately the by-election could have been held as early as mid-September, although this coincided with the Trades Union Congress annual conference and the following weeks were filled with various party conferences. A Labour loss during this period could have provided a particular boost for their opponents, or for dissident elements within the party. The SNP may have favoured a quick by-election, noting that Labour called the Glasgow East by-election rapidly, when commentators believed it was to Labour's advantage.

Candidates

The Labour party candidate was Kirkcaldy High School rector Lindsay Roy. The SNP selected the leader of Fife Council, Peter Grant. The Conservative Party selected Maurice Golden while the Liberal Democrats chose Harry Wills. The Scottish Socialist Party stood Morag Balfour, their national co-chair, who lived in Glenrothes and had been a candidate in the constituency before. Solidarity stood Louise McLeary, a community activist who lived in the part of Kirkcaldy which lies inside the constituency. The UKIP candidate was Kris Seunarine a specialist in the science of biophotonics at Dundee university, and chairman of the Fife branch of UKIP.

Two of the minor party candidates had disabilities: Balfour was a wheelchair user and McLeary was visually impaired.

2005 UK election result

Marked register

Some months after the election, the marked register (on which the electors who had cast their vote were marked) was discovered to be missing. In law the register ought to have been preserved for a year and a day; the Returning Officer from Fife Council had transmitted the marked register to the Sheriff Court as required by law and obtained a receipt. The SNP Constituency Organiser, Cllr John Beare, had asked for a copy of the marked register on 19 November 2008; after ten weeks, the Scottish Court Service admitted the marked register was lost. An inquiry by the Scottish Court Service identified significant failings in its handling of election documents, which had been placed in a room at the court office in Kirkcaldy to which outside contractors had access.

In October 2009, the Scotland Office agreed a protocol to create a substitute marked register for the election.

References

References

1. (6 October 2008). "Glenrothes by-election date set". BBC News.
2. (2008-08-13). "MP MacDougall dies after illness". BBC News.
3. (6 November 2008). "Labour victorious in Glenrothes". BBC News.
4. (2008-11-07). "Glenrothes result in full". BBC News.
5. Gerri Peev, "[http://thescotsman.scotsman.com/latestnews/New-Scots-vote-gives-Brown.4388537.jp New Scots vote gives Brown three months to save political skin]", ''[[The Scotsman]]'', 14 August 2008
6. George Parker and Jim Pickard, "[https://www.ft.com/content/2565f494-6926-11dd-91bd-0000779fd18c Brown faces new by-election battle]", ''[[Financial Times]]'', 13 August 2008
7. Severin Carrell, "[https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2008/aug/14/gordonbrown.snp1 From working class loyalty to new town aspiration]", ''[[The Guardian]]'', 14 August 2008
8. Nigel Morris, "[https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/brown-loses-a-friend-ndash-and-faces-another-daunting-scottish-byelection-894518.html Brown loses a friend – and faces another daunting Scottish by-election]", ''[[The Independent]]'', 14 August 2008
9. Iain Watson, "[https://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/politics/7558533.stm Don't expect an early by-election]", [[BBC News]], 13 August 2008
10. [https://iaindale.blogspot.com/2008/08/top-40-scottish-blogs.html Top 40 Scottish Blogs], Ian Dale's Diary, 27 August 2008
11. (1 September 2008). "Labour picks by-election hopeful". BBC News.
12. [https://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/edinburgh_and_east/7577955.stm SNP reveals by-election candidate], BBC News, 22 August 2008
13. (2008-08-28). "Tories pick by-election candidate". BBC News.
14. Steve Bargeton, "[http://www.thecourier.co.uk/output/2008/08/14/newsstory11804002t0.asp MP's death leaves battle for Brown] {{webarchive. link. (2 December 2008 ", ''[[The Courier (Dundee)). The Courier]]''
15. Simon Johnson, "[https://web.archive.org/web/20080826094036/http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/politics/scotland/2613957/John-MacDougall-was-suing-Government-over-disease-that-killed-him.html John MacDougall was suing Government over disease that killed him]", ''[[The Daily Telegraph]]'', 24 August 2008
16. (3 February 2009). "By-election registers go missing". BBC News.
17. (6 March 2009). "Glenrothes documents lost due to 'failures in handling'". [[The Herald (Glasgow).
18. [https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200809/cmvote/91019v01.htm Votes and Proceedings] of the House of Commons, 19 October 2009.