Thermobaric weapon

Terminology

The term thermobaric is derived from the Greek words for 'heat' and 'pressure': thermobarikos (θερμοβαρικός), from thermos (θερμός) 'hot' + baros (βάρος) 'weight, pressure' + suffix -ikos (-ικός) '-ic'.

Other terms used for the family of weapons are high-impulse thermobaric weapons, heat and pressure weapons, vacuum bombs, and fuel-air explosives (FAE).

Mechanism

File:Dust explosion 00.jpg|Experimental setup File:Dust explosion 01.jpg|Finely-ground flour is dispersed File:Dust explosion 02.jpg|Cloud of flour is ignited File:Dust explosion 03.jpg|Fireball spreads rapidly File:Dust explosion 04.jpg|Intense radiant heat has nothing to ignite here File:Dust explosion 05.jpg|Fireball and superheated gases rise File:Dust explosion 06.jpg|Aftermath of explosion, with unburned flour on the ground

Most conventional explosives consist of a fuel–oxidiser premix, but thermobaric weapons consist only of fuel and as a result are significantly more energetic than conventional explosives of equal weight. Their reliance on atmospheric oxygen makes them unsuitable for use under water, at high altitude, and in adverse weather. They are, however, considerably more effective when used in enclosed spaces such as tunnels, buildings, and non-hermetically sealed field fortifications (foxholes, bunkers).

The initial explosive charge detonates as it hits its target, opening the container and dispersing the fuel mixture as a cloud. The typical blast wave of a thermobaric weapon lasts significantly longer than that of a conventional explosive.

In contrast to an explosive that uses oxidation in a confined region to produce a blast front emanating from a single source, a thermobaric flame front accelerates to a large volume, which produces pressure fronts within the mixture of fuel and oxidant and then also in the surrounding air.

Thermobaric explosives apply the principles underlying accidental unconfined vapor cloud explosions, which include those from dispersions of flammable dusts and droplets. Such dust explosions happened most often in flour mills and their storage containers, grain bins (corn silos etc.), and earlier in coal mines, prior to the 20th century. Accidental unconfined vapor cloud explosions now happen most often in partially or completely empty oil tankers, refinery tanks, and vessels, such as the Buncefield fire in the United Kingdom in 2005, where the blast wave woke people 150 km from its centre.

A typical weapon consists of a container packed with a fuel substance, the centre of which has a small conventional-explosive "scatter charge". Fuels are chosen on the basis of the exothermicity of their oxidation, ranging from powdered metals, such as aluminium or magnesium, to organic materials, possibly with a self-contained partial oxidant. The most recent development involves the use of nanofuels.

A thermobaric bomb's effective yield depends on a combination of a number of factors such as how well the fuel is dispersed, how rapidly it mixes with the surrounding atmosphere and the initiation of the igniter and its position relative to the container of fuel. In some designs, strong munitions cases allow the blast pressure to be contained long enough for the fuel to be heated well above its autoignition temperature so that once the container bursts, the superheated fuel autoignites progressively as it comes into contact with atmospheric oxygen. Conventional upper and lower limits of flammability apply to such weapons. Close in, blast from the dispersal charge, compressing and heating the surrounding atmosphere, has some influence on the lower limit. The upper limit has been demonstrated to influence the ignition of fogs above pools of oil strongly. That weakness may be eliminated by designs in which the fuel is preheated well above its ignition temperature so that its cooling during its dispersion still results in a minimal ignition delay on mixing. The continual combustion of the outer layer of fuel molecules, as they come into contact with the air, generates added heat which maintains the temperature of the interior of the fireball, and thus sustains the detonation.

In confinement, a series of reflective shock waves is generated, which maintain the fireball and can extend its duration to between 10 and 50 ms as exothermic recombination reactions occur. Further damage can result as the gases cool and pressure drops sharply, leading to a partial vacuum. This rarefaction effect has given rise to the misnomer "vacuum bomb". Piston-type afterburning is also believed to occur in such structures, as flame-fronts accelerate through it.

Fuel–air explosive

A fuel–air explosive (FAE) device consists of a container of fuel and two separate explosive charges. After the munition is dropped or fired, the first explosive charge bursts open the container at a predetermined height and disperses the fuel in a cloud that mixes with atmospheric oxygen (the size of the cloud varies with the size of the munition). The cloud of fuel flows around objects and into structures. The second charge then detonates the cloud and creates a massive blast wave. The blast wave can destroy reinforced buildings, equipment, and kill or injure people. The blast wave's antipersonnel effect is magnified in confined spaces, such as foxholes, tunnels, bunkers and caves.

Effects

Conventional countermeasures such as barriers (sandbags) and personnel armour are not effective against thermobaric weapons. A Human Rights Watch report of 1 February 2000 quotes a study made by the US Defense Intelligence Agency:

According to a US Central Intelligence Agency study,

Another Defense Intelligence Agency document speculates that, because the "shock and pressure waves cause minimal damage to brain tissue... it is possible that victims of FAEs are not rendered unconscious by the blast, but instead suffer for several seconds or minutes while they suffocate".

Development

German

The first attempts occurred during the First World War when incendiary shells (in German 'Brandgranate') used a slow but intense burning material, such as tar impregnated tissue and gunpowder dust. These shells burned for approximately 2 minutes after the shell exploded and spread the burning elements in every direction. In World War II, the German Wehrmacht attempted to develop a thermobaric weapon,

The weapon was claimed by a weapons specialist (K.L. Bergmann) to have been tested on the Eastern front under the code-name "Taifun B" and was ready for deployment during the Normandy invasion in June, 1944. Apparently, canisters of a charcoal, aluminium and aviation fuel would have been launched, followed with a secondary launch of incendiary rockets. It was destroyed by a Western artillery barrage minutes before being fired just before Operation Cobra.

United States

FAEs were developed by the United States for use in the Vietnam War. The CBU-55 FAE fuel-air cluster bomb was mostly developed by the US Naval Weapons Center at China Lake, California.

Current American FAE munitions include the following:

• BLU-73 FAE I
• BLU-95 500 lb (FAE-II)
• BLU-96 2,000 lb (FAE-II)
• CBU-72 FAE I
• AGM-114 Hellfire missile (AGM-114N MAC)
• XM1060 grenade
• SMAW-NE round for rocket launcher

The XM1060 40-mm grenade is a small-arms thermobaric device, which was fielded by US forces in Afghanistan in 2002, and proved to be popular against targets in enclosed spaces, such as caves. Since the 2003 invasion of Iraq, the US Marine Corps has introduced a thermobaric "Novel Explosive" (SMAW-NE) round for the Mk 153 SMAW rocket launcher. One team of Marines reported that they had destroyed a large one-story masonry type building with one round from 100 yd. The AGM-114N Hellfire II, uses a Metal Augmented Charge (MAC) warhead, which contains a thermobaric explosive fill that uses aluminium powder coated or mixed with PTFE layered between the charge casing and a PBXN-112 explosive mixture. When the PBXN-112 detonates, the aluminium mixture is dispersed and rapidly burns. The result is a sustained high pressure that is extremely effective against people and structures.

Soviet, later Russian

Following FAEs developed by the United States for use in the Vietnam War, Soviet Union scientists quickly developed their own FAE weapons. Since Afghanistan, research and development has continued, and Russian forces now field a wide array of third-generation FAE warheads, such as the RPO-A. The Russian armed forces have developed thermobaric ammunition variants for several of their weapons, such as the TBG-7V thermobaric grenade with a lethality radius of 10 m, which can be launched from a rocket propelled grenade (RPG) RPG-7. The GM-94 is a 43 mm pump-action grenade launcher designed mainly to fire thermobaric grenades for close combat. The grenade weighed 250 g and contained 160 g of explosive, its lethality radius is 3 m, but due to the deliberate "fragmentation-free" design of the grenade, a distance of 4 m is considered safe.

The RPO-A and upgraded RPO-M are infantry-portable rocket propelled grenades designed to fire thermobaric rockets. The RPO-M, for instance, has a thermobaric warhead with a TNT equivalence of 5.5 kg and destructive capabilities similar to a 152 mm high-explosive fragmentation artillery shell. The RShG-1 and the RShG-2 are thermobaric variants of the RPG-27 and RPG-26 respectively. The RShG-1 is the more powerful variant, with its warhead having a 10 m lethality radius and producing about the same effect as 6 kg of TNT. The RMG is a further derivative of the RPG-26 that uses a tandem-charge warhead, with the precursor high-explosive anti-tank (HEAT) warhead blasting an opening for the main thermobaric charge to enter and detonate inside. The RMG's precursor HEAT warhead can penetrate 300 mm of reinforced concrete or over 100 mm of rolled homogeneous armour, thus allowing the 105 mm-diameter thermobaric warhead to detonate inside.

Other examples include the semi-automatic command to line of sight (SACLOS) or millimeter-wave active radar homing guided thermobaric variants of the 9M123 Khrizantema, the 9M133F-1 thermobaric warhead variant of the 9M133 Kornet, and the 9M131F thermobaric warhead variant of the 9K115-2 Metis-M, all of which are anti-tank missiles. The Kornet has since been upgraded to the Kornet-EM, and its thermobaric variant has a maximum range of 10 km and has a TNT equivalence of 7 kg. The 300 mm 9M55S thermobaric cluster warhead rocket was built to be fired from the BM-30 Smerch MLRS. A dedicated carrier of thermobaric weapons is the purpose-built TOS-1, a 24-tube MLRS designed to fire 220 mm thermobaric rockets. A full salvo from the TOS-1 will cover a rectangle 200 by. The Iskander-M theatre ballistic missile can also carry a 700 kg thermobaric warhead.

Many Russian Air Force munitions have thermobaric variants. The 80 mm S-8 rocket has the S-8DM and S-8DF thermobaric variants. The S-8's 122 mm brother, the S-13, has the S-13D and S-13DF thermobaric variants. The S-13DF's warhead weighs only 32 kg, but its power is equivalent to 40 kg of TNT. The KAB-500-OD variant of the KAB-500KR has a 250 kg thermobaric warhead. The ODAB-500PM and ODAB-500PMV unguided bombs carry a 190 kg fuel–air explosive each. ODAB-1500 is a larger version of the bomb. The KAB-1500S GLONASS/GPS guided 1500 kg bomb also has a thermobaric variant. Its fireball will cover a 150 m radius and its lethal zone is a 500 m radius. The 9M120 Ataka-V and the 9K114 Shturm ATGMs both have thermobaric variants.

In September 2007, Russia exploded the largest thermobaric weapon ever made, and claimed that its yield was equivalent to that of a nuclear weapon. Russia named this particular ordnance the "Father of All Bombs" in response to the American-developed Massive Ordnance Air Blast (MOAB) bomb, which has the backronym "Mother of All Bombs" and once held the title of the most powerful non-nuclear weapon in history.

Iraq

Iraq was alleged to possess the technology as early as 1990.

Israel

Israel was alleged to possess thermobaric technology as early as 1990, according to Pentagon sources.

Spain

A first possible thermobaric weapon, the tóspiro, was invented and tested in 1905 by Spanish inventor Antonio Meulener, who reportedly ordered the project to be closed "for the danger it posed to humanity". In 1983, a program of military research was launched with collaboration between the Spanish Ministry of Defence (Directorate General of Armament and Material, DGAM) and Explosivos Alaveses (EXPAL) which was a subsidiary of Unión Explosivos Río Tinto (ERT). The goal of the programme was to develop a thermobaric bomb, the BEAC (Bomba Explosiva de Aire-Combustible). A prototype was tested successfully in a foreign location out of safety and confidentiality concerns. The Spanish Air and Space Force has an undetermined number of BEACs in its inventory.

China

In 1996, the People's Liberation Army (PLA) began development of the PF-97, a portable thermobaric rocket launcher, based on the Soviet RPO-A Shmel. Introduced in 2000 it is reported to weigh 3.5 kg and contains 2.1 kg of thermobaric filler. An improved version called the PF-97A was introduced in 2008.

China is reported to have other thermobaric weapons, including bombs, grenades and rockets. Research continues on thermobaric weapons capable of reaching 2,500 degrees.

Brazil

In 2004, under the request of the Estado Maior da Aeronáutica (Military Staff of Aeronautics) and the Diretoria de Material Aeronáutico e Bélico (Board of Aeronautical and Military Equipment) the Instituto de Aeronautica e Espaço (Institute of Aeronautics and Space) started developing a thermobaric bomb called **Trocano **.

Trocano is a thermobaric weapon similar in design to the United States' MOAB weapon or Russia's FOAB. Like the US weapon, the Trocano was designed to be pallet-loaded into a C-130 Hercules aircraft, and deployed using a parachute to drag it from the C-130's cargo bay and separate the bomb from its pallet.

United Kingdom

In 2009, the British Ministry of Defence (MoD) acknowledged that Army Air Corps (AAC) AgustaWestland Apaches had used AGM-114 Hellfire missiles purchased from the United States against Taliban forces in Afghanistan. The MoD stated that 20 missiles, described as "blast fragmentation warheads", were used in 2008 and a further 20 in 2009. MoD officials told Guardian journalist Richard Norton-Taylor that the missiles were "particularly designed to take down structures and kill everyone in the buildings", as AAC AgustaWestland Apaches were previously equipped with weapon systems deemed ineffective to combat the Taliban. The MoD also stated that "British pilots' rules of engagement were strict and everything a pilot sees from the cockpit is recorded."

In 2018, the MoD accidentally divulged the details of General Atomics MQ-9 Reapers utilised by the Royal Air Force (RAF) during the Syrian civil war, which revealed that the drones were equipped with AGM-114 Hellfire missiles. The MoD had sent a report to a British publication, Drone Wars, in response to a freedom of information request. In the report, it was stated that AGM-114N Hellfire missiles which contained a thermobaric warhead were used by RAF attack drones in Syria.

India

Based on the high-explosive squash head (HESH) round, a 120 mm thermobaric round was developed in the 2010s by the Indian Ministry of Defence. This HESH round packs thermobaric explosives into the tank shells to increase the effectiveness against enemy bunkers and light armoured vehicles.

The design and the development of the round was taken up by Armament Research and Development Establishment (ARDE). The rounds were designed for the Arjun MBT. The TB rounds contains fuel rich explosive composition called thermobaric explosive. As the name implies, the shells, when they hit a target, produce blast overpressure and heat energy for hundreds of milliseconds. The overpressure and heat causes damage to enemy fortified structures like bunkers and buildings and for soft targets like enemy personnel and light armoured vehicles.

Serbia

The company Balkan Novoteh, formed in 2011, provides the Thermobaric hand grenade TG-1 to the market.

Military Technical Institute in Belgrade has developed a technology for producing cast-cured thermobaric PBX explosives. Since recently, the Factory of Explosives and Pyrotechnics TRAYAL Corporation has been producing cast-cured thermobaric PBX formulations.

Ukraine

In 2017 Ukroboronprom's Scientific Research Institute for Chemical Products in conjunction with (aka Artem Holding Company) announced to the market its new product, the . These can be combined with the grenade launcher, a demonstration of which was witnessed by Oleksandr Turchynov. The grenades, of approximately 600 grams, "create a two second fire cloud with a volume of not less than 13 m³, inside of which the temperature reaches 2,500 degrees. This temperature allows not only for the destruction of the enemy, but are also able to disable lightly armored vehicles." The firm showed them at the Azerbaijan International Defense Exhibition in 2018.

In 2024, Ukraine started using drones rigged with thermobaric explosives to strike Russian positions in the Russo-Ukrainian War.

History

Attempted prohibitions

Mexico, Switzerland and Sweden presented in 1980 a joint motion to the United Nations to prohibit the use of thermobaric weapons, to no avail.

United Nations Institute for Disarmament Research categorises these weapons as "enhanced blast weapons" and there was pressure to regulate these around 2010, again to no avail.

Military use

United States

FAEs such as first-generation CBU-55 fuel–air weapons saw extensive use in the Vietnam War. A second generation of FAE weapons were based on those, and were used by the United States in Iraq during Operation Desert Storm. A total of 254 CBU-72s were dropped by the United States Marine Corps, mostly from A-6Es. They were targeted against mine fields and personnel in foxholes, but were more useful as a psychological weapon.

The US military used thermobaric weapons in Afghanistan. On 3 March 2002, a single 2000 lb laser guided thermobaric bomb was used by the United States Air Force against cave complexes in which Al-Qaeda and Taliban fighters had taken refuge in the Gardez region of Afghanistan. The SMAW-NE was used by the US Marines during the First Battle of Fallujah and the Second Battle of Fallujah. The AGM-114N Hellfire II was first used by US forces in 2003 in Iraq.

Soviet Union

FAEs were reportedly used against China in the 1969 Sino-Soviet border conflict.

The TOS-1 system was test fired in Panjshir Valley during the Soviet–Afghan War in the late 1980s. MiG-27 attack aircraft of the 134th APIB used ODAB-500S/P fuel–air bombs against Mujahideen forces in Afghanistan, but they were found to be unreliable and dangerous to ground crew.

Russia

Russian military forces reportedly used ground-delivered thermobaric weapons during the Battle for Grozny (first and second Chechen Wars) to attack dug-in Chechen fighters. The use of TOS-1 heavy MLRS and "RPO-A Shmel" shoulder-fired rocket system during the Chechen Wars is reported to have occurred. Russia used the RPO-A Shmel in the First Battle of Grozny, whereupon it was designated as a very useful round.

It was thought that, during the September 2004 Beslan school hostage crisis, a multitude of handheld thermobaric weapons were used by the Russian Armed Forces in their efforts to retake the school. The RPO-A and either the TGB-7V thermobaric rocket from the RPG-7 or rockets from either the RShG-1 or the RShG-2 is claimed to have been used by the Spetsnaz during the initial storming of the school. At least three and as many as nine RPO-A casings were later found at the positions of the Spetsnaz. In July 2005 the Russian government admitted to the use of the RPO-A during the crisis.

During the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine, CNN reported that Russian forces were moving thermobaric weapons into Ukraine. On 28 February 2022, Ukraine's ambassador to the United States accused Russia of deploying a thermobaric bomb. Russia has claimed to have used the weapon in March 2024 against Ukrainian soldiers in an unspecified location (denied by Ukraine), and during the August 2024 Ukrainian incursion into Kursk Oblast.

United Kingdom

During the War in Afghanistan, British forces, including the Army Air Corps and Royal Air Force, used thermobaric AGM-114N Hellfire missiles against the Taliban. In the Syrian civil war, British military drones used AGM-114N Hellfire missiles; in the first three months of 2018, British drones fired 92 Hellfire missiles in Syria.

Israel

A report by Human Rights Watch claimed Israel has used thermobaric weaponry in the past including the 2008–2009 conflict in Gaza. Moreover, Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor states that Israel appears to be using thermobaric weaponry in the current Gaza war. Both organizations claim that the use of this weaponry in densely populated neighborhoods violates international humanitarian law due to its damaging affects on civilians and civilian structures.** The Eurasian Times reported that an Israeli AH-64D Apache attack helicopter was photographed with a 'mystery' warhead with a red band that was speculated to be a thermobaric warhead capable of destroying Hamas tunnels and multi-story buildings.

Syria

Reports by the rebel fighters of the Free Syrian Army claim the Syrian Air Force used such weapons against residential area targets occupied by the rebel fighters, such as during the Battle of Aleppo and in Kafar Batna. Others contend that in 2012 the Syrian government used an bomb in Azaz.

The Russia and Syrian governments have used thermobaric bombs and other thermobaric munitions during the Syrian civil war against insurgents and insurgent-held civilian areas.

Ukraine

Mikhail Tolstykh, a top rank pro-Russian officer in the war in Donbas was killed on 8 February 2017 at his office in Donetsk by an RPO-A rocket fired by members of the Security Service of Ukraine. In March 2023 soldiers from the 59th Motorised Brigade of Ukraine showed off the destruction of a derelict Russian infantry fighting vehicle by a thermobaric RGT-27S2 hand grenade delivered by Mavic 3 drone.

Non-state actor use

Thermobaric and fuel–air explosives have been used in guerrilla warfare since the 1983 Beirut barracks bombing in Lebanon, which used a gas-enhanced explosive mechanism that was probably propane, butane, or acetylene. The explosive used by the bombers in the US 1993 World Trade Center bombing incorporated the FAE principle by using three tanks of bottled hydrogen gas to enhance the blast.

Jemaah Islamiyah bombers used a shock-dispersed solid fuel charge, based on the thermobaric principle, to attack the Sari nightclub during the 2002 Bali bombings in Indonesia.

International law

International law does not prohibit the use of thermobaric munitions, fuel-air explosive devices, or vacuum bombs against military targets. , all past attempts to regulate or restrict thermobaric weapons have failed.

According to some scholars , thermobaric weapons are not intrinsically indiscriminate by nature, as they are often engineered for precision targeting capabilities . This precision aspect serves to provide humanitarian advantages by potentially minimizing collateral damage and also lessens the amount of munitions needed to effectively engage with the chosen military goals. Nonetheless, authors holding this view recommend that the use of thermobaric weapons in populated areas should be minimised due to their wide-area impact and multiple harm mechanisms.

References

References

1. Harrison, Virginia. (2022-03-01). "What are thermobaric weapons and how do they work?".
2. (2016). "Thermobaric and enhanced blast explosives (TBX and EBX)". Defence Technology.
3. (2022). "Chemistry of High-Energy Materials".
4. (2012). "Reactive Metals in Explosives". Propellants, Explosives, Pyrotechnics.
5. (2015). "Thermobaric and Enhanced Blast Explosives - Properties and Testing Methods". Propellants, Explosives, Pyrotechnics.
6. (18 October 2011). "Libye – l'Otan utilise une bombe FAE | Politique, Algérie". Algeria ISP.
7. Parsons, Jeff. (2 March 2022). "What is a thermobaric weapon? Putin accused of using devastating 'vacuum bomb' in Ukraine". Metro.
8. Türker, Lemi. (2016-12-01). "Thermobaric and enhanced blast explosives (TBX and EBX)". Defence Technology.
9. Lester W. Grau and Timothy Smith, [https://community.apan.org/cfs-file/__key/docpreview-s/00-00-08-52-45/2000_2D00_08_2D00_01-A-Crushing-Victory_2D00_Fuel_2D00_Air-Explosives-and-Grozny-2000-2800_Grau-and-Smith_2900.pdf A 'Crushing' Victory: Fuel-Air Explosives and Grozny 2000], August 2000
10. (2 March 2022). "Ukraine conflict: What is a vacuum or thermobaric bomb?". BBC News.
11. Nettleton, ''J. Occ. Accidents'', 1, 149 (1976).
12. Strehlow, 14th. Symp. (Int.) Comb. 1189, Comb. Inst. (1973).
13. Health and Safety Environmental Agency, 5th and final report, 2008.
14. (2002). "Nanometric Aluminum in Explosives". Propellants, Explosives, Pyrotechnics.
15. (June 2024)
16. Slavica Terzić, Mirjana Dakić Kolundžija, Milovan Azdejković and Gorgi Minov (2004) [http://www.vti.mod.gov.rs/ntp/rad2004/34-04/terz/terz.pdf Compatibility Of Thermobaric Mixtures Based On Isopropyl Nitrate And Metal Powders] {{Webarchive. link. (2012-03-02.)
17. Meyer, Rudolf. (2007). "Explosives". Wiley-VCH.
18. Nettleton, arch. combust. 1,131, (1981).
19. Stephen B. Murray [http://www.galcit.caltech.edu/~jeshep/icders/cd-rom/EXTABS/259_20TH.PDF Fundamental and Applied Studies of Fuel-Air Detonation] {{Webarchive. link. (2010-01-19.)
20. Nettleton, Comb. and Flame, 24,65 (1975).
21. Fire Prev. Sci. and Tech. No. 19,4 (1976)
22. May L. Chan (2001) [https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/a4/27/2c/cdc026cb46e404/US6955732.pdf Advanced Thermobaric Explosive Compositions].
23. Rozanski, Anthony J.. "New Thermobaric Materials and Weapon Concepts".
24. Anna E. Wildegger-Gaissmaier. (April 2003). "Aspects of thermobaric weaponry". ADF Health.
25. (1 February 2000). "Backgrounder on Russian Fuel Air Explosives ("Vacuum Bombs") | Human Rights Watch". Hrw.org.
26. Defense Intelligence Agency, "Future Threat to the Soldier System, Volume I; Dismounted Soldier – Middle East Threat", September 1993, p. 73.
27. "Main Types of Artillery Ammunition in 1914-1918".
28. Karlsch, Rainer. (24 September 2007). "Massenvernichtungswaffe: Großvaters Vakuumbombe". Faz.net.
29. Eckhertz, Holger. "D Day through German Eyes".
30. (1 May 2003). "Munitions – Thermobaric Munitions and their Medical Effects!". Australian Military Medicine.
31. "Thermobaric Grenade Brings Down the House? (Updated)".
32. David Hambling (2005) {{usurped
33. (2022). "HELLFIRE Thermobaric Warhead Approved for Production".
34. (10 November 2022). "Thermobarics – Developments and Deployments". European Security & Defence.
35. (27 December 2008). "Backgrounder on Russian Fuel Air Explosives ('Vacuum Bombs')". Human Rights Watch.
36. (2022). "Aluminized Enhanced Blast Explosive Based on Polysiloxane Binder". Propellants, Explosives, Pyrotechnics.
37. Lester W. Grau and Timothy L. Thomas (Marine Corps Gazette, April 2000) "[https://web.archive.org/web/20051113123217/http://fmso.leavenworth.army.mil/documents/Rusn_leslrn.htm Russian Lessons Learned From the Battles For Grozny]"
38. (24 January 2011). "Modern Firearms – GM-94". World Guns.
39. (19 July 2006). "New RPO Shmel-M Infantry Rocket Flamethrower Man-Packable Thermobaric Weapon". defensereview.com.
40. "Shmel-M: Infantry Rocket-assisted Flamethrower of Enhanced Range and Lethality". Kbptula.ru.
41. (24 January 2011). "Modern Firearms – RShG-1". World Guns.
42. (24 January 2011). "Modern Firearms – RMG". World Guns.
43. (9 November 2008). "RMG – A new Multi-Purpose Assault Weapon from Bazalt". defense-update.com.
44. "Kornet-EM: Multi-purpose Long-range Missile System". Kbptula.
45. "TOS-1 - Heavy flamethrower system".
46. "SS-26". Missilethreat.csis.org.
47. "ODAB-500PMV Fuel-Air-Explosive bomb".
48. (2024-03-16). "Russian forces destroy 300 Ukrainian troops in pinpoint air strike".
49. Air Power Australia. (4 July 2007). "How to Destroy the Australian Defence Force". Ausairpower.net.
50. (2007). "Russia unveils devastating vacuum bomb". ABC News.
51. (2007). "Video of test explosion". BBC News.
52. Harding, Luke. (12 September 2007). "Russia unveils the father of all bombs". The Guardian.
53. Torremocha Silva, A. (2024). "Antonio Meulener. Militar e inventor algecireño (1861-1912)". Almoraima: revista de estudios campogibraltareños, ISSN 1133-5319, Nº. 61, 2024, págs. 97-105
54. (11 October 1990). "Serra no descarta que España tenga bombas de aire-combustible". EDICIONES EL PAÍS.
55. (22 October 1990). "Pilotos españoles probaron la Superbomba Aire-Combustible en un país extranjero, p. 23 – ABC.es".
56. Aguilar, Juan. (9 February 2014). "¿Dispone España de armas estratégicas?".
57. "PF-97 - Thermobaric rocket launcher".
58. (8 August 2018). "Will Thermobaric Weapons Overwhelm the Military Health System?".
59. (May 2024). "Better than laser?China's thermobaric bomb reaches 2500 degrees high temperature, once exported, the United States will be miserable?".
60. (September 2023). "Relatorio{{Dead link". Instituto de Aeronáutica e Espaço [Brazilian Aeronautics and Space Institute].
61. Norton-Taylor, Richard. (28 May 2009). "MoD admits use of controversial 'enhanced blast' weapons in Afghanistan". [[The Guardian]].
62. Kay, Linda. (3 May 2018). "UK Troops Using Deadly 'Thermobaric' Weapons In Syrian Civil War: Report". Defense World.
63. Cole, Chris. (3 May 2018). "MoD accidentally reveals British drones firing thermobaric missiles in Syria". Defense World.
64. Kay, Linda. (2 May 2018). "UK Troops Using Deadly 'Thermobaric' Weapons In Syrian Civil War: Report". Drone Wars.
65. "120 mm Thermobaric (TB) Ammunition For MBT Arjun | Defence Research and Development Organisation – DRDO, Ministry of Defence, Government of India".
66. "120 mm Penetration Cum Blast (PCB) and Thermobaric (TB) Ammunition For MBT Arjun | Defence Research and Development Organisation - DRDO, Ministry of Defence, Government of India".
67. "Fire-power of DRDO's Arjun Tank takes quantum jump with new ammunition: MoD". The Economic Times.
68. "Thermobaric Hand Grenade TG-1". Balkan Novoteh.
69. "Ubojna sredstva".
70. (29 July 2017). "Ukraine developed a new thermobaric weapon". UAWire.
71. (October–December 2017). "Ukrainian Defense Review". Defense Express.
72. (December 2018). "ADEX-2018 cz. 2". Zespół Badán I Analiz Militarnych Sp. Z O.O..
73. (May 2024). "Thermobaric Drones Blast Russian Positions". Forbes.
74. (2010). "Protecting Civilians from the Effects of Explosive Weapons An Analysis of International Legal and Policy Standards". United Nations Institute for Disarmament Research.
75. (1 July 2013). "Fuel Air Explosive (FAE) systems". TNMA.
76. [http://www.fas.org/man/dod-101/sys/dumb/cbu-72.htm CBU-72 / BLU-73/B Fuel/Air Explosive (FAE) - Dumb Bombs]
77. (3 March 2002). "US Uses Bunker-Busting 'Thermobaric' Bomb for First Time". Commondreams.org.
78. (22 December 2003). "China starts on thermobaric bomb". Flight Global.
79. (14 May 2003). "New Missiles Floored Enemy In Iraq - CBS News". www.cbsnews.com.
80. (March 2022). "Fact Sheet: Russia's Use of Thermobaric Weapons in Ukraine".
81. Swearingen, Jake. (14 September 2015). "This Russian Tank-Mounted Rocket Launcher Can Incinerate 8 City Blocks". Popular Mechanics.
82. (2019). "Mikoyan MiG-23 and MiG-27". Crecy.
83. "Foreign Military Studies Office Publications – A 'Crushing' Victory: Fuel-Air Explosives and Grozny 2000". Fmso.leavenworth.army.mil.
84. (1 September 2006). "Russian forces faulted in Beslan school tragedy". [[Christian Science Monitor]].
85. [http://www.rferl.org/featuresarticle/2006/8/B841BF15-DB81-4D65-96F5-9B10F3EC9D9A.html Russia: Independent Beslan Investigation Sparks Controversy] {{Webarchive. link. (2006-08-29, [[The Jamestown Foundation]], 29 August 2006)
86. [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/5302448.stm Beslan still a raw nerve for Russia] {{Webarchive. link. (2012-05-20, [[BBC News]], 1 September 2006)
87. [https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2005-aug-27-fg-beslan27-story.html Aching to Know], ''[[Los Angeles Times]]'', 27 August 2005
88. [http://www.kommersant.com/p607710/r_1/Searching_for_Traces_of_%E2%80%9CShmel%E2%80%9D_in_Beslan_School/ Searching for Traces of "Shmel" in Beslan School] {{webarchive. link. (2009-01-03, ''[[Kommersant]]'', 12 September 2005)
89. [http://www.themoscowtimes.com/news/article/a-reversal-over-beslan-only-fuels-speculation/211124.html A Reversal Over Beslan Only Fuels Speculation] {{Webarchive. link. (2011-09-03, ''[[The Moscow Times]]'', 21 July 2005)
90. "Russian army deploys its TOS-1 heavy flamethrower capable of vaporizing human bodies near Ukrainian border, footage shows". Business Insider Africa.
91. (2022-02-27). "What are thermobaric weapons?". ABC News.
92. (2022-02-28). "Oil depot burns after artillery shelling in Okhtyrka, Sumy Oblast.". Kyiv Independent.
93. Zengerle, Patricia. (2022-03-01). "Ukraine envoy to U.S. says Russia used a vacuum bomb in its invasion". Reuters.
94. (18 March 2024). "Russia Claims Use of 'Vacuum Bomb' in Ukraine". The Defense Post.
95. (11 August 2024). "Russia tightens security where Ukraine launched an incursion as fighting persists". CBS News.
96. Kay, Linda. (3 May 2018). "UK Troops Using Deadly 'Thermobaric' Weapons In Syrian Civil War: Report". Defense World.
97. (21 October 2023). "Unleashing the Unprecedented: The Controversial Use of Thermobaric Bombs in Recent Conflicts". Financial Express.
98. (9 October 2023). "Israel takes revenge on Palestinian armed factions by mass killing civilians in Gaza". Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor.
99. Satam, Parth. (2023-11-08). "Israel 'Blows-Up' Hamas Bunkers With 'Secretive' Hellfire Missiles Loaded On AH-64D Choppers - Reports".
100. (10 October 2012). "Syria rebels say Assad using 'mass-killing weapons' in Aleppo". Ynetnews.
101. (11 November 2012). "Dropping Thermobaric Bombs on Residential Areas in Syria_ Nov. 5. 2012".
102. Cumming-Bruce, Nick. (4 June 2013). "U.N. Panel Reports Increasing Brutality by Both Sides in Syria". The New York Times.
103. Ullah, Areeb. (22 February 2018). "Eastern Ghouta home of 'Noor and Alaa' destroyed by Syrian bombs".
104. DeGhett, Torie Rose. (28 August 2015). "A New Kind of Bomb Is Being Used in Syria and It's a Humanitarian Nightmare".
105. (18 March 2019). "Thermobaric Bombs And Other Nightmare Weapons Of The Syrian Civil War". Popular Science.
106. (10 February 2022). "Наказ про ліквідацію терориста "Гіві" віддав Порошенко – Юрій Бутусов".
107. (2024-02-25). "The Spy War: How the C.I.A. Secretly Helps Ukraine Fight Putin". [[The New York Times]].
108. (7 March 2023 }}{{Dead link). "The latest military situation of the Russia-Ukraine conflict: Ukraine is open, a grenade blows up a Russian infantry fighting vehicle". IMedia.
109. Richard J. Grunawalt. [https://www.usnwc.edu/getattachment/7d21c1a4-769a-45a9-90fd-d4852265430c/Hospital-Ships-in-the-War-on-Terror--Sanctuaries-o.aspx ''Hospital Ships In The War On Terror: Sanctuaries or Targets?''] {{Webarchive. link. (2013-04-01 (PDF), ''Naval War College Review'', Winter 2005, pp. 110–11.)
110. Paul Rogers (2000) [https://bradscholars.brad.ac.uk/handle/10454/2325 "Politics in the Next 50 Years: The Changing Nature of International Conflict"] {{Webarchive. link. (2019-10-19)
111. (24 February 1998). "Senate Judiciary Committee, Subcommittee on Technology, Terrorism, and Government Information hearing on "Foreign Terrorists in America: Five Years After the World Trade Center"". Fas.
112. (2003). "Shock-Dispersed-Fuel Charges-Combustion in Chambers and Tunnels".
113. David Eshel. (2006). "Is the world facing Thermobaric Terrorism?".
114. Wayne Turnbull. (2003). "Bali:Preparations".
115. . (1 March 2022). ["Ukraine's ambassador to US says Russia used a vacuum bomb, international groups say banned cluster munitions used to strike shelter"](https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-03-01/ukraine-ambassador-us-russia-used-vacuum-bomb-cluster-munitions/100870638). *Australian Broadcasting Corporation*.
116. Hanson, Marianne. (2 March 2022). "What are thermobaric weapons? And why should they be banned?".
117. Seidel, Jamie. (27 February 2022). "Father of all bombs': Russia's brutal weapon". news.com.au.
118. van Coller, Arthur. (June 2023). "Detonating the air: The legality of the use of thermobaric weapons under international humanitarian law". International Review of the Red Cross.