The Use of Force

Plot summary

The story is narrated in the first-person confessional point-of-view by a rural physician, who is making a farmhouse call to tend to a sick girl. Concerned she may have diphtheria, the doctor decides to check her throat to confirm his suspicion. However, the girl adamantly refuses to cooperate, and the doctor eventually engages in a virtual assault on the child to restrain her and examine her throat using a spoon. The doctor finds that the girl, who was alerted at school that diphtheria might be fatal, had concealed the symptoms of the infection, and has in fact contracted the deadly pathogen.

Analysis

The story is written without the use of quotation marks, and the dialogue is not distinguished from the narrator's comments. The story is rendered from the subjective point of view of the doctor and explores both his admiration for the child and disgust with the parents, and his guilty enjoyment of forcefully subduing the stubborn child in an attempt to acquire the throat sample. The overall theme of the story revolves around authority and resistance to power, and the doctor's unnerved feeling during the forceful encounter.

Author Robert F. Gish notes the underlying theme of implicit sexual violence in the short story: "Williams utilizes his familiar undertones of violent eroticism in 'The Use of Force'...Neither Williams nor his narrator is naive about the sexual implications of the episode." Gish writes:

Medical doctor and literary critic Richard and Enid Rhodes Peschel cite a key passage from "The Use of Force" in which the doctor's effort to examine the 10-year-old girl Mathilda Olson for diphtheria, descends into a violent struggle of wills, in which he physically subdues her, described here by the doctor/narrator:

Critics Peschel and Peschel discover a thematic element of the story in its denouement:

References

Sources

• Gish, Robert F. 1989. William Carlos Williams: A Study of the Short Fiction. Twayne Publishers, Boston, Massachusetts. Gordon Weaver, General Editor. G. K. Hall & Co.
• Peschel, Richard E. and Peschel, Enid Rhodes. 1984. When a Doctor Hates a Patient: Case Histories, Literary Histories from the Michigan Quarterly Review, 23 no. 3 (Summer 1984) in William Carlos Williams: A Study of the Short Fiction by Robert F. Gish, Twayne Publishers, Boston, Massachusetts. Gordon Weaver, General Editor. pp. 152–158
• Slate, J. E. 1968. William Carlos Williams and the Modern Short Story from The Southern Review 4, no. 3 (July 1968) in William Carlos Williams: A Study of the Short Fiction, by Robert F. Gish. Twayne Publishers, Boston, Massachusetts. Gordon Weaver, General Editor. G. K. Hall & Co. pp. 160–169

References

1. Williams, William Carlos. "The Use of Force".
2. "The Use of Force".
3. Slate, 1968 p. 160: "...needs no defense in academic circles...Endorsed by critics and teachers who print it in anthologies." And p. 161: "...enshrined in college texts" since 1950.
4. Gish, 1989 p. 71
5. Gish, 1989 p. 71-72: Plot summary
6. Gish, 1989 p. 71-72
7. Gish, 1989 p. 71
8. Gish, 1989 p. 72:
9. Peschel and Peschel, 1984 p. 156
10. Perloff, 1980, p.194: Perloff quotes a portion of the same passage.
11. Peschel and Peschel, 1984 p. 157: Ellipsis for brevity, meaning is unaltered.