Pollution-induced community tolerance

Community tolerance

Community tolerance can be used as an indicator for determining if a toxicant has a disturbance on an exposed community for multiple types of organisms. Tolerance of a toxicant can increase in three ways: physiological adaptation, also known as the phenotypic plasticity of an individual; tolerant genotypes selected within a population over time; and the replacement of species with more tolerant ones within a community. Physiological adaptation, or phenotypic plasticity, is the ability of an individual organism to change its phenotype in response to changes in the environment. This can occur with huge variance between the type of organism and the type of the disturbance they experience. Natural selection that occurs over several generations causes an entire population to exhibit specific selection of genotypes. Over time, tolerant genotypes can be selected over non-tolerant ones and can cause a shift in a population's genome. Natural selection can also cause a replacement of less tolerant species with more tolerant species. whereas there are rare works that use the PICT tool on organisms other than microorganisms.

There are two types of tolerances that can occur: multiple and co-tolerance. Multiple tolerances can elevate an individual's ability to tolerate several toxicants present at once. This type of approach is still preliminary, there is a need for further in situ studies combining PICT with chemical monitoring of environments, experimental work under controlled laboratory conditions, and integration of PICT into modeling approaches to precise these patterns of co-tolerance. A complementary approach derived from Pesce et al. (2011) and Foulquier et al. (2015) was recently applied by Tlili et al. (2020), combining passive sampling systems with PICT bioassays on river biofilms collected upstream and downstream of wastewater treatment plants at two-year intervals (before and after a change in effluent treatment). Their results demonstrate the value of combining the PICT approach with the use of passive sampler extracts to establish causality between in situ exposure to complex mixtures of micropollutants and ecotoxic effects on autotrophic and heterotrophic microbial communities.

Field studies

Assessing pollution-induced community tolerance can be done utilizing in situ techniques, many of which involve the use of known or created chemical exposure gradients. One example is the use of a known concentration gradient of Tri-n-butylin to assess PICT in periphyton. Tolerance patterns showed that tolerance was highest closest to the marina that was the source of contamination. The use of reference sites in addition to contaminated sites is also commonly used for translocation assessments of PICT. A study in Germany cultured periphyton on glass discs in two river systems north of Leipzig, Germany. One system was the contaminated area of study and the other was 10 km upstream and uncontaminated, intended to be used as a reference. After the colonization period, 6 of the 10 racks of glass discs were trans-located to the other river system. During the experiment the community structure present on the glass discs from the reference site, when translocated to the contaminated site changed to mirror that of the control discs that were left in the contaminated sites. and which has also been used for many PICT experiments in the laboratory (see for example ). Of particular note at this site is the study conducted by Pesce et al. (2016) during three consecutive years (2009–2011): The authors monitored the decrease in tolerance of periphyton to diuron (herbicide applied in vineyards and banned since 2008) downstream of the river crossing this wine-growing watershed. Their results showed a direct link between the evolution of an agricultural practice (here the banning of diuron) and ecological changes in the river (through the loss of tolerance measured by the PICT). Lake Geneva is one of the subalpine lakes studied for a long time by the International Commission for the Protection of Lake Geneva (CIPEL). A PICT study carried out 12 years apart showed the restoration of the lake's phytoplankton with a concomitant decrease in the tolerance of the communities towards atrazine and copper and in the concentrations of these two contaminants (following legislation limiting the use of atrazine in agriculture and framing the management of industrial waste). In another study in Denmark, enclosure experiments were done allowing for an assessment of PICT utilizing the lake water from Lake Bure as a baseline. By using this water from the lake potentially confounding variables would be nullified by comparing results to the control. Concentrations of atrazine and copper were added to these enclosures in varying concentrations. As in other experiments previously discussed periphyton communities were used in this experiment and were cultured using glass discs. Photosynthetic activity was measured and used as a measurement of PICT throughout the experiment. The experiment showed that elevated levels of Cu lead to community tolerance of the phytoplankton community as well as co-tolerance of zinc. Total Biomass decreased at the outset of the trials involving high concentrations of Cu indicating that Community Tolerance was increased due to direct mortality of the sensitive species. The in situ study of Bérard & Benninghoff, (2001) in enclosures repeated over several years in the lake of Geneva, showed that the tolerance of phytoplankton to the herbicide atrazine (photosynthesis inhibitor) varied according to the seasons during which the experiment was carried out. These changes in tolerance for the same toxicant and at the same concentration (10 μg/L) were probably linked to the initial compositions of the algal and cyanobacterial communities and to environmental factors associated with seasonal parameters (temperature, light, nutrients, etc.). PICT studies on large spatial scales are rare and difficult to conduct, note this European study by Blanck et al. (2003) on zinc tolerance in river periphyton.

The use of PICT in an in situ fashion is not limited to aquatic systems. Studies on soil microbial communities have been conducted in industrial and agricultural contexts (see the review of Boivin et al., 2002). Thus, for examples in the context of industrial contamination a study involving 2,4,6-Trinitrotoluene utilized respirometric techniques to measure Pollution-Induced Community Tolerance in soil microbial communities in response to the presence of TNT. The results of this study further corroborate the PICT Theory, in that treatments with long-term exposure to TNT had a larger proportion of TNT-resistant bacteria than soils with low levels of TNT. This PICT caused by TNT was also present in another study. Microrespirometry measurements carried out on soil samples taken along three transects have highlighted the tolerance to Pb in a site bordering a lead smelter with long-term polymetallic contamination dominated by Pb. The PICT established causal relationships between Pb and its effect on microbial communities by considering the history of environmental contamination at the community level. Furthermore, a positive correlation between community metabolic quotient and PICT suggested that the acquisition of Pb stress-induced tolerance would have resulted in a higher energetic cost for microbial communities to cope with metal toxicity. Other studies have highlighted in various contexts, this cost of contaminant-induced tolerance. In the context of agricultural contamination, Bérard et al. (2004) validated the PICT tool (by measuring photosynthetic activity) for atrazine tolerance on edaphic microalgae, comparing soils of conventionally and organically farmed corn fields. Changes in taxonomic structure of diatom communities sampled from soils under both types of farming practices, as well as nanocosm experiments, confirmed the selective effect of atrazine. In terrestrial environment, the PICT method is widely applied to metal contamination and since 2010, to antibiotic tolerance in interaction with metal contamination.

Ideally, pollution-induced community tolerance can be assessed in the field by using a representative sample of the natural community in response to environmental contamination. However, this is not always the case, which is why laboratory studies are necessary supplements to properly assess PICT.

Experimental studies

Experimental investigation of PICT is performed to eliminate factors other than pollution that may affect community structure and ecophysiology, Much work has been done in controlled systems (see reviews by Blanck, 2002 and Tlili et al. 2016). They can be conducted in conjunction with field work, as in the study by Blanck and Dahl (1996). In this study, the results from laboratory acute toxicity tests of TBT on periphyton corroborated the results from the field study, supporting the conclusion that toxicity to periphyton resulted from TBT pollution at the site under investigation. used experimental systems of increasing complexity associated with monitoring of sites in Lake Geneva more or less contaminated by Irgarol (antifouling inhibitor of photosynthesis), and crossed the results of ecotoxicity of strains isolated from these sites and from non-contaminated control sites with experiments in nanocosms and PICT measurements. This work highlighted the high toxicity of Irgarol (compared to atrazine having the same site of action, and presenting a co-tolerance) on periphyton and phytoplankton and its potential for selection pressure at existing concentrations in the lake.

The PICT methodology

There are a variety of methods for laboratory testing PICT, but a general format includes sampling, a bioassay, and an analysis of community structure.

Samples can be collected on artificial or natural substrata, either in situ or in the laboratory. There must be a series of samples exposed to different concentrations of contaminant and a control sample. In situ sampling involves setting up a sampling device in an aquatic ecosystem and allowing it to colonize for some time (e.g. a couple of weeks). One example is the diatometer, a device that is deployed in the water that becomes colonized by diatoms, and then is removed for analysis. In situ sampling devices are set up at increasing distances from the pollution source in the case of point source pollution. The samples thus represent a gradient in contaminant concentration, assuming that the contaminant becomes more dilute with increasing distance from the point source. An example of laboratory sampling was used in a study by Schmitt-Jansen and Altenburger (2005). For 14 days communities were allowed to establish on discs set up in laboratory aquariums which were continuously mixed and inoculated with algae from a pond. The aquariums were dosed with different concentrations of herbicide to get a gradient of long-term (14-day) contaminant exposures. Once a week the aquarium water was completely replaced and re-dosed with herbicide. Terrestrial studies pose other difficulties because it is difficult to use colonization systems by the communities investigated. Generally one samples the soil with its intrinsic heterogeneity and components other than microorganisms (minerals, organics ..), which increases measurement difficulties and biases related to contaminant bioavailability.

A bioassay is conducted on the samples to test for correlation between tolerance and long-term contaminant exposure. First, samples are exposed to different concentrations of contaminant. Then an endpoint is measured to determine the toxic effect on the sample organisms. The results from these measurements are used to produce a dose-response curve and an EC50. PAM fluorimetry, leucine incorporation and eco-plates, microbial respiration, enzyme activities, potential ammonium oxidation assay... In order to use the PICT method in biomonitoring and environmental risk assessment, it is necessary to advance in the standardization of these bioassays, both for the sampling of the tested communities, but also for the bioassays themselves.

Community structure of the samples is analyzed to check for a correlation between species prevalence and long-term contaminant exposure. Samples are taxonomically classified to determine the composition and species diversity of the communities that established over the long term exposures. The results are compared to the concentration of contaminant in the long-term exposure to conclude if a relationship was found in the study. Recent developments in microbial ecology using molecular biology and "omics" methods, chemotaxonomy methods, functional diversity measurements, biological trait and biological interaction network approaches, are varied, complementary and promising ecological tools to address PICT selection pressure.

References

References

1. (2011). "Active Bio-monitoring of Contamination in Aquatic Systems—An in Situ Translocation Experiment Applying the PICT Concept". Aquatic Toxicology.
2. (1988). "Functional Testing of Aquatic Biota for Estimating Hazards of Chemicals".
3. Miner, Benjamin G., Sonia E. Sultan, Steven G. Morgan, Dianna K. Padilla, and Rick A. Relyea. 12 December 2005. "Ecological Consequences of Phenotypic Plasticity." Elsevier. Trends in Ecology and Evolution. 20 (12): 685–692). http://bama.ua.edu/~rlearley/Miner_2005.pdf.
4. Darwin, Charles. 1859. "Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life." London: John Murray. 1st Edition. http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/images/nytint/docs/charles-darwin-on-the-origin-of-species/original.pdf
5. Blanck, Hans. 22 September 2010. "A Critical Review of Procedures and Approaches Used for Assessing Pollution-Induced Community Tolerance (PICT) in Biotic Communities, Human and Ecological Risk Assessment." Human and Ecological Risk Assessment. 8 (5): 1003–1034. http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/1080-700291905792.
6. (2017). "Changes in copper toxicity towards diatom communities with experimental warming". Journal of Hazardous Materials.
7. (2016). "The Use of Biofilms to Assess the Effects of Chemicals on Freshwater Ecosystems". Caister Academic Press.
8. (2016). "Pollution-induced community tolerance (PICT): towards an ecologically relevant risk assessment of chemicals in aquatic systems". Freshwater Biology.
9. (2017). "Pollution-induced community tolerance in benthic macroinvertebrates of a mildly lead-contaminated lake". Environmental Science and Pollution Research.
10. (1995). "Assessing the impact of copper on nematode communities from a chronically metal-enriched estuary using pollution-induced community tolerance". Marine Pollution Bulletin.
11. (2002-07-01). "A Hypothetical Application of the Pollution-Induced Community Tolerance Concept in Megafaunal Communities Found at Contaminated Sites". Human and Ecological Risk Assessment.
12. (2011). "Enhanced co-tolerance and co-sensitivity from long-term metal exposures of heterotrophic and autotrophic components of fluvial biofilms". Science of the Total Environment.
13. (2010). "Co-tolerance of phytoplankton communities to photosynthesis II inhibitors". Aquatic Toxicology.
14. (2006). "On the Limits of Toxicant-Induced Tolerance Testing: Cotolerance and Response Variation of Antibiotic Effects". Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry.
15. Blanck, Hans. (2002). "A Critical Review of Procedures and Approaches Used for Assessing Pollution-Induced Community Tolerance (PICT) in Biotic Communities". Human and Ecological Risk Assessment.
16. (2017-12-02). "Clustering pesticides according to their molecular properties, fate, and effects by considering additional ecotoxicological parameters in the TyPol method". Environmental Science and Pollution Research.
17. Campillo-Cora, Claudia. (2021-04-01). "Bacterial community tolerance to Cu in soils with geochemical baseline concentrations (GBCs) of heavy metals: Importance for pollution induced community tolerance (PICT) determinations using the leucine incorporation method". Soil Biology and Biochemistry.
18. (2011). "Combining polar organic chemical integrative samplers (POCIS) with toxicity testing to evaluate pesticide mixture effects on natural phototrophic biofilms". Environmental Pollution.
19. (2015). "Effects of mixtures of dissolved and particulate contaminants on phototrophic biofilms: new insights from a PICT approach combining toxicity tests with passive samplers and model substances". Environmental Science and Pollution Research.
20. (2020-09-01). "Tolerance Patterns in Stream Biofilms Link Complex Chemical Pollution to Ecological Impacts". Environmental Science & Technology.
21. (1996). "Pollution-induced Community Tolerance (PICT) in Marineperiphyton in Agradient of Tri-n-butyltin (TBT) Contamination". Aquatic Toxicology.
22. (2007). "Lotic biofilm community structure and pesticide tolerance along a contamination gradient in a vineyard area". Aquatic Microbial Ecology.
23. (2010). "The periphyton as a multimetric bioindicator for assessing the impact of land use on rivers: an overview of the Ardières-Morcille experimental watershed (France)". Hydrobiologia.
24. (2010). "In situ relationships between spatio-temporal variations in diuron concentrations and phototrophic biofilm tolerance in a contaminated river". Water Research.
25. (2010). "In situ assessment of periphyton recovery in a river contaminated by pesticides". Aquatic Toxicology.
26. (2010). "Evaluation of single and joint toxic effects of diuron and its main metabolites on natural phototrophic biofilms using a pollution-induced community tolerance (PICT) approach". Aquatic Toxicology.
27. (2008). "Responses of chronically contaminated biofilms to short pulses of diuronAn experimental study simulating flooding events in a small river". Aquatic Toxicology.
28. Pesce, Stephane. (2016-04-01). "Pollution-induced community tolerance for in situ assessment of recovery in river microbial communities following the ban of the herbicide diuron". Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment.
29. (2016). "Pollution-induced community tolerance (PICT) as a tool for monitoring Lake Geneva long-term in situ ecotoxic restoration from herbicide contamination". Environmental Science and Pollution Research.
30. (1995). "Toleranceinduction and Succession in Microalgae Communities Exposed to Copper and Atrazine". Aquatic Toxicology.
31. (2001). "Pollution-induced community tolerance (PICT) and seasonal variations in the sensitivity of phytoplankton to atrazine in nanocosms". Chemosphere.
32. (2003-01-01). "Variability in Zinc Tolerance, Measured as Incorporation of Radio-Labeled Carbon Dioxide and Thymidine, in Periphyton Communities Sampled from 15 European River Stretches". Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology.
33. (2010). "Assessment of the impact of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) on indigenous herbicide-degrading bacteria and microbial community function in an agricultural soil". Applied Soil Ecology.
34. Boivin MEY, Breure AM, Posthuma L, ''et al.'' 2002. Determination of field effects of contaminants Significance of pollution-induced community tolerance. Human Ecol Risk Assess 8
35. (2000). "An in Situ Respirometric Technique to Measure Pollution-Induced Microbial Community Tolerance in Soils Contaminated with 2,4,6-Trinitrotoluene". Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety.
36. (2000). "Assessment of 2,4,6-Trinitrotoluene Toxicity in Field Soils by Pollution-Induced Community Tolerance, Denaturing Gradient Gel Electrophoresis, and Seed Germination Assay". Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry.
37. (2016). "Soil microbial respiration and PICT responses to an industrial and historic lead pollution: a field study". Environmental Science and Pollution Research.
38. (2014). "Use of the MicroResp™ method to assess Pollution-Induced Community Tolerance in the context of metal soil contamination". Ecological Indicators.
39. (2014). "Mechanisms of pollution induced community tolerance in a soil microbial community exposed to Cu". Environmental Pollution.
40. (2004). "Procedures for Determining the Pesticide Sensitivity of Indigenous Soil Algae: A Possible Bioindicator of Soil Contamination?". Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology.
41. (2010-11-15). "Cu Exposure under Field Conditions Coselects for Antibiotic Resistance as Determined by a Novel Cultivation-Independent Bacterial Community Tolerance Assay". Environmental Science & Technology.
42. (2017). "Influence of temperature in pollution-induced community tolerance approaches used to assess effects of copper on freshwater phototrophic periphyton". Science of the Total Environment.
43. (2012). "Structural and functional recovery of microbial biofilms after a decrease in copper exposure: Influence of the presence of pristine communities". Aquatic Toxicology.
44. (2018-07-02). "Experimental Warming Differentially Influences the Vulnerability of Phototrophic and Heterotrophic Periphytic Communities to Copper Toxicity". Frontiers in Microbiology.
45. (2003). "Comparison of the ecotoxicological impact of the triazines Irgarol 1051 and atrazine on microalgal cultures and natural microalgal communities in Lake Geneva". Chemosphere.
46. Blanck, Hans. 1985. "A simple, community level, ecotoxicological test system using samples of periphyton". Hydrobiologia. 124: 251–261.
47. "Tools of a Scientist". Urban Rivers Awareness. 2004.
48. (2005). "Predicting and observing responses of algal communities to photosystem II-herbicide exposure using pollution-induced community tolerance and species-sensitivity distributions". Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry.
49. (1980). "An implanted slide technique for examining the effects of the herbicide diuron on soil algae". Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology.
50. (2014). "Evaluation of the leucine incorporation technique for detection of pollution-induced community tolerance to copper in a long-term agricultural field trial with urban waste fertilizers". Environmental Pollution.
51. (2002). "A risk assessment of pollution: induction of atrazine tolerance in phytoplankton communities in freshwater outdoor mesocosms, using chlorophyll fluorescence as an endpoint". Water Research.
52. Dorigo U,Leboulanger C. A PAM fluorescence-based method for assessing the effects of photosystem II herbicides on freshwater periphyton.J Appl Phycol 2001;13:463–534.
53. (2008). "Community-level microalgal toxicity assessment by multiwavelength-excitation PAM fluorometry". Aquatic Toxicology.
54. (2009). "Effects of sulfamethoxazole on soil microbial communities after adding substrate". Soil Biology and Biochemistry.
55. (1999). "Risk Assessment, Microbial Communities, and Pollution-Induced Community Tolerance". Human and Ecological Risk Assessment.
56. (2011). "Use of the MicroResp™ method to assess pollution-induced community tolerance to metals for lotic biofilms". Environmental Pollution.
57. wakelin, Steven. (2014). "Mechanisms of pollution induced community tolerance in a soil microbial community exposed to Cu". Environmental Pollution.
58. (2012). "Pollution-induced community tolerance of freshwater biofilms: measuring heterotrophic tolerance to Pb using an enzymatic toxicity test". Ecotoxicology.
59. (2013). "The use of antioxidant enzymes in freshwater biofilms: Temporal variability vs. toxicological responses". Aquatic Toxicology.
60. (2002). "Assessment of Pollution-Induced Microbial Community Tolerance to Heavy Metals in Soil Using Ammonia-Oxidizing Bacteria and Biolog Assay". Human and Ecological Risk Assessment.
61. (2015). "Improved short-term toxicity test protocol to assess metal tolerance in phototrophic periphyton: toward standardization of PICT approaches". Environmental Science and Pollution Research.
62. (2021). "Comparing the effect of Cu-based fungicides and pure Cu salts on microbial biomass, microbial community structure and bacterial community tolerance to Cu". Journal of Hazardous Materials.
63. (2017). "High-throughput amplicon sequencing and stream benthic bacteria: identifying the best taxonomic level for multiple-stressor research". Scientific Reports.
64. (2020). "Changes in sediment microbial diversity following chronic copper-exposure induce community copper-tolerance without increasing sensitivity to arsenic". Journal of Hazardous Materials.
65. (2012). "An Attempt to Quantify Cu-Resistant Microorganisms in a Paddy Soil from Jiaxing, China". Pedosphere.
66. (2018). "Copper affects composition and functions of microbial communities in marine biofilms at environmentally relevant concentrations".
67. (2015-08-25). "Functional diversity and functional traits of periphytic algae during a short-term successional process in a Neotropical floodplain lake". Brazilian Journal of Biology.