Pioneer factor

Active rearrangement

Pioneer factors can also actively affect transcription by directly opening up condensed chromatin in an ATP-independent process. This is a common trait of fork head box factors (which contain a winged helix DNA-binding domain that mimics the DNA-binding domain of the linker H1 histone), and NF-Y (whose NF-YB and NF-YC subunits contain histone-fold domains similar to those of the core histones H2A/H2B).

Fork head box factors

The similarity to histone H1 explains how fork head factors are able to bind chromatin by interacting with the major groove of only the one available side of DNA wrapped around a nucleosome. Fork head domains also have a helix that confers sequence specificity unlike linker histone. The C terminus is associated with higher mobility around the nucleosome than linker histone, displacing it and rearranging nucleosomal landscapes effectively. This active re-arrangement of the nucleosomes allows for other transcription factors to bind the available DNA. In thyroid cell differentiation FoxE binds to compacted chromatin of the thyroid peroxidase promoter and opens it for NF1 binding.

NF-Y

NF-Y is a heterotrimeric complex composed of NF-YA, NF-YB, and NF-YC subunits. The key structural feature of the NF-Y/DNA complex is the minor-groove interaction of its DNA binding domain-containing subunit NF-YA, which induces an ~80° bend in the DNA. NF-YB and NF-YC interact with DNA through non-specific histone-fold domain-DNA contacts. NF-YA's unique DNA-binding mode and NF-YB/NF-YC's nucleosome-like properties of non-specific DNA binding impose sufficient spatial constraints to induce flanking nucleosomes to slide outward, making nearby recognition sites for other transcription factors accessible.

Passive factors

Pioneer factors can function passively, by acting as a bookmark for the cell to recruit other transcription factors to specific genes in condensed chromatin. This can be important for priming the cell for a rapid response as the enhancer is already bound by a pioneer transcription factor giving it a head start towards assembling the transcription preinitiation complex. Hormone responses are often quickly induced in the cell using this priming method such as with the estrogen receptor. Another form of priming is when an enhancer is simultaneously bound by activating and repressing pioneer factors. This balance can be tipped by dissociation of one of the factors. In hepatic cell differentiation the activating pioneer factor FOXA1 recruits a repressor, grg3, that prevents transcription until the repressor is down-regulated later on in the differentiation process. In a direct role pioneer factors can bind an enhancer and recruit activation complex that will modify the chromatin directly. The change in the chromatin changes the affinity, decreasing the affinity of the pioneer factor such that it is replaced by a transcription factor that has a higher affinity. This is a mechanism for the cell to switch a gene on was observed with glucocorticoid receptor recruiting modification factors that then modify the site to bind activated estrogen receptor which was coined as a “bait and switch” mechanism.

Epigenetic effects

Pioneer factors can exhibit their greatest range of effects on transcription through the modulation of epigenetic factors by recruiting activating or repressing histone modification enzymes and controlling CpG methylation by protecting specific cysteine residues. This has effects on controlling the timing of transcription during cell differentiation processes.

Histone modification

Histone modification is a well-studied mechanism to transiently adjust chromatin density. Pioneer factors can play a role in this by binding specific enhancers and flagging histone modification enzymes to that specific gene. Repressive pioneer factors can inhibit transcription by recruiting factors that modify histones that further tighten the chromatin. This is important to limit gene expression to specific cell types and has to be removed only when cell differentiation begins. FoxD3 has been associated as a repressor of both B-cell and melanocytic cell differentiation pathways, maintaining repressive histone modifications where bound, that have to be overcome to start differentiation. Pioneer factors can also be associated with recruiting transcription-activating histone modifications. Enzymes that modify H3K4 with mono and di-methylation are associated with increasing transcription and have been shown to bind pioneer factors. FoxA1 binding induces HSK4me2 during neuronal differentiation of pluripotent stem cells as well as the loss of DNA methylation. SOX9 recruits histone modification enzymes MLL3 and MLL4 to deposit H3K4me1 prior to the opening of enhancers in developing hair follicle and basal cell carcinoma.

DNA methylation

Pioneer factors can also affect transcription and differentiation through the control of DNA methylation. Pioneer factors that bind to CpG islands and cytosine residues block access to methyltransferases. Many eukaryotic cells have CpG islands in their promoters that can be modified by methylation having adverse effects on their ability to control transcription. This phenomenon is also present in promoters without CpG islands where single cytosine residues are protected from methylation until further cell differentiation. An example is FoxD3 preventing methylation of a cytosine residue in Alb1 enhancer, acting as a place holder for FoxA1 later in hepatic as well as in CpG islands of genes in chronic lymphocytic leukemia. For stable control of methylation state the cytosine residues are covered during mitosis, unlike most other transcription factors, to prevent methylation. Studies have shown that during mitosis 15% of all interphase FoxA1 binding sites were bound. The protection of cytosine methylation can be quickly removed allowing for rapid induction when a signal is present.

Other pioneer factors

A well studied pioneer factor family is the Groucho-related (Gro/TLE/Grg) transcription factors that often have a negative effect on transcription. These chromatin binding domains can span up to 3-4 nucleosomes. These large domains are scaffolds for further protein interactions and also modify the chromatin for other pioneer factors such as FoxA1 which has been shown to bind to Grg3. Transcription factors with zinc finger DNA binding domains, such as the GATA family and glucocorticoid receptor. The zinc finger domains do not appear to bind nucleosomes well and can be displaced by FOX factors.

In the skin epidermis, SOX family transcription factor, SOX9, also behaves as a pioneer factor that governs hair follicle cell fate and can reprogram epidermal stem cells to a hair follicle fate.

Role in cancer

The ability of pioneer factors to respond to extracellular signals to differentiate cell type has been studied as a potential component of hormone-dependent cancers. Hormones such as estrogen and IGFI are shown to increase pioneer factor concentration leading to a change in transcription. Known pioneer factors such as FoxA1, PBX1, TLE, AP2, GATA factors 2/3/4, and PU.1 have been associated with hormone-dependent cancer . FoxA1 is necessary for estrogen and androgen mediated hepatocarcinogenesis and is a defining gene for ER+ luminal breast cancer, as is another pioneer factor GATA3. In the breast cancer cell line, MCF-7, it was found that FoxA1 was bound to 50% of estrogen receptor binding sites independent of estrogen presence. High expression of pioneer factors is associated with poor prognosis with the exception of breast cancer where FoxA1 is associated with a stronger outcome. The correlation between pioneer factors and cancer has led to prospective therapeutic targeting. In knockdown studies in the MCF-7 breast cancer cell line it was found that decreasing pioneer factors FoxA1 and AP2 decreased ER signalling. Drugs such as Paclitaxel, Imatinib, and doxorubicin which activate FoxO3a or its targets are being used. Modification to modulate related factors with pioneer activity is a topic of interest in the early stages as knocking down pioneer factors may have toxic effects through alteration of the lineage pathways of healthy cells.

References

References

1. (February 2002). "Opening of compacted chromatin by early developmental transcription factors HNF3 (FoxA) and GATA-4". Molecular Cell.
2. (2011-11-01). "Pioneer transcription factors: establishing competence for gene expression". Genes & Development.
3. (2014-09-04). "Histone-fold domain protein NF-Y promotes chromatin accessibility for cell type-specific master transcription factors". Molecular Cell.
4. (November 2011). "Pioneer factors: directing transcriptional regulators within the chromatin environment". Trends in Genetics.
5. (July 1993). "Co-crystal structure of the HNF-3/fork head DNA-recognition motif resembles histone H5". Nature.
6. (2013-01-17). "Sequence-specific transcription factor NF-Y displays histone-like DNA binding and H2B-like ubiquitination". Cell.
7. (2010). "Nuclear mobility and mitotic chromosome binding: similarities between pioneer transcription factor FoxA and linker histone H1". Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology.
8. (April 2009). "Nucleosome-binding affinity as a primary determinant of the nuclear mobility of the pioneer transcription factor FoxA". Genes & Development.
9. (October 2007). "The forkhead factor FoxE1 binds to the thyroperoxidase promoter during thyroid cell differentiation and modifies compacted chromatin structure". Molecular and Cellular Biology.
10. (November 2011). "Pioneer transcription factors: establishing competence for gene expression". Genes & Development.
11. (May 2011). "Chromatin "prepattern" and histone modifiers in a fate choice for liver and pancreas". Science.
12. (August 2011). "Dynamic exchange at regulatory elements during chromatin remodeling underlies assisted loading mechanism". Cell.
13. (July 2010). "Epigenetic priming of a pre-B cell-specific enhancer through binding of Sox2 and Foxd3 at the ESC stage". Cell Stem Cell.
14. (May 2011). "FOXD3 regulates migration properties and Rnd3 expression in melanoma cells". Molecular Cancer Research.
15. (May 2010). "Simple combinations of lineage-determining transcription factors prime cis-regulatory elements required for macrophage and B cell identities". Molecular Cell.
16. (April 2011). "Epigenetic switch involved in activation of pioneer factor FOXA1-dependent enhancers". Genome Research.
17. (May 2010). "Foxa1 functions as a pioneer transcription factor at transposable elements to activate Afp during differentiation of embryonic stem cells". The Journal of Biological Chemistry.
18. (2023-07-24). "The pioneer factor SOX9 competes for epigenetic factors to switch stem cell fates". Nature Cell Biology.
19. (October 2010). "Pioneer factors in embryonic stem cells and differentiation". Current Opinion in Genetics & Development.
20. (December 2009). "Transcriptional competence and the active marking of tissue-specific enhancers by defined transcription factors in embryonic and induced pluripotent stem cells". Genes & Development.
21. (August 2009). "Epigenetic changes during disease progression in a murine model of human chronic lymphocytic leukemia". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.
22. (February 2013). "Bookmarking by specific and nonspecific binding of FoxA1 pioneer factor to mitotic chromosomes". Genes & Development.
23. (October 2007). "Repression by Groucho/TLE/Grg proteins: genomic site recruitment generates compacted chromatin in vitro and impairs activator binding in vivo". Molecular Cell.
24. (2023-07-24). "The pioneer factor SOX9 competes for epigenetic factors to switch stem cell fates". Nature Cell Biology.
25. (May 2012). "Pioneer factors in hormone-dependent cancers". Nature Reviews. Cancer.
26. (February 2009). "A new fork for clinical application: targeting forkhead transcription factors in cancer". Clinical Cancer Research.