Loyalty program

Single-company vs. coalition programs

Loyalty programs may be either:

• Single-brand programs, which may be for all stores owned by a company, such as Target, or branded stores which may be corporate-owned and franchised to independent business owners, such as McDonalds.
• Single-corporation programs, such as the joint Gap Inc. program, work at the stores and digital channels of Gap, Banana Republic, Old Navy, and Athleta, which are all owned by Gap Inc.
• Coalition loyalty programs, provide benefits to customers of multiple otherwise-unrelated businesses. Examples include Rakuten Rewards which, in the U.S. offers cashback at more than 3,500 stores and Air Miles which awards points for purchases from multiple merchants in each market it serves (Canada, The Netherlands, Bahrain, Qatar, and the UAE).
  • Shopping center programs may also be based on a single or chain of shopping centers, such as the Tanger Outlets loyalty programs that can be used at merchants located at its outlet malls.
  • Downtown Olympia, Washington, launched a coalition loyalty program in 2021 for merchants in its downtown shopping district.

In 2020, McKinsey spoke of loyalty program "ecosystems".

Features

How customers provide their account numbers

Physical loyalty cards

A loyalty program typically involves the operator of a particular program setting up an account for a customer of a business associated with the scheme, and then issue to the customer a loyalty card (variously called rewards card, points card, advantage card, club card, or some other name) which may be a plastic or paper card, visually similar to a credit card, that identifies the cardholder as a participant in the program. Cards may have a barcode or magstripe to more easily allow for scanning, although some are chip cards or proximity cards. U.S. supermarkets often issue two copies of the card: one credit-card sized and one that fits on a keychain, in addition to providing access to the card via a mobile app, website.

Digital loyalty cards

As of 2024, most programs in the United States offer a digital version of the loyalty card, accessed via a mobile app, and often customers can scan a QR or bar code from the app at the physical point of sale. Some programs now offer digital cards only or only exceptionally, such as Marks and Spencer's "Sparks" program in the UK launched in 2020 which no longer issues physical cards except upon special request. American Airlines no longer sends membership kits to new members of its frequent flyer program.

Encouraging or forcing customers to use a mobile app to present their loyalty account number, although criticized for being unfriendly to people without smartphones including many elderly people,

Similar developments have been observed in European markets {{cite web | access-date = 2025-11-27 | access-date = 2025-11-27

Phone number and other methods

At a physical point of sale, presenting a physical or digital card is not necessary at many U.S. merchants, if the customer enters the phone number associated with the account on a terminal or tells it to a cashier who enters it into the register. When purchasing online, customers usually must log in to the account on the merchant's website. However, when purchasing airline tickets from online travel agencies, customers can usually enter their airline loyalty number into the agency website and the agency will pass it onto the airline.

Points

Programs that feature points grant customers a certain number of points for each purchase, in the US often per $1 or $10 increment of spend. Once they have enough points, clients can redeem them for either:

• merchandise or services free of charge
• discounts on merchandise or services
• gift cards, credit vouchers, etc. to spend with the merchant
• "cashback", either:
  • money that the program transfers to the customer's account or
  • a paper check that the program mails to the customer

Tiers

Programs with tiers define levels (such as silver, gold, and platinum levels) that customers are upgraded to when they spend enough with the merchant(s), usually over a certain period of time such as a year. For example, Sephora gives 1 point for $1 spent. Once customers earn a specific number of points, they can enter a new level with higher discounts and exclusive products.

Membership fees

In subscription-based programs, customers pay a fee to enjoy the program's benefits, for example Barnes and Noble bookstores charge members about 40 U.S. dollars per year (as of mid-2024) for its "Premium Membership and Rewards" program, which gives members a 10% discount off most merchandise. There is also a free tier which does not offer such discounts but does allow members to collect virtual "stamps" (i.e. loyalty points).

Types of rewards

Depending on the program, rewards may take the form of:

• merchandise or services free of charge
• discounts on merchandise or services
• gift cards, credit vouchers, etc. to spend with the merchant
• cashback

In addition to rewards, loyalty cards may also be used to identify consumers for benefits and other services, e.g.:

• when pharmacies dispense prescriptions
• for access to an airport lounge (using a frequent-flyer card)
• when customers presented checks for payment at a point-of sale

Cashback

Main article: Cashback website

Programs with cashback features give customers a portion of the money that they have spent with a business (usually a defined percent which may be higher than usual during promotions). The "cash back" is rarely actually cash money, but rather takes the form of a transfer of the "cashback" amount to the customer's bank account.

Examples in the U.S. include Rakuten Rewards, a coalition reward program, and many banks that give their clients cash back for using their debit cards to pay for various products and services.

Channels

Depending on the program, ways that consumers may access their loyalty account (account number, promotions, other information) may include:

• Desktop, mobile, and/or responsive versions of the website(s) for the program and/or of participating merchant(s)
• Mobile apps for the program or participating merchant(s)
• At dedicated kiosks, such as in casinos
• Traditional methods such as:
  • Physical membership cards
  • Paper-based mailings of account statements, promotions, and other information

Mobile apps and websites

There has been a move away from traditional magnetic card, stamp, or punchcard based schemes to online and mobile online loyalty programs. While these schemes vary, the common element is a push toward eradication of a traditional card, in favour of an electronic equivalent. The choice of medium is often a QR code. Some prominent examples are Austrian based mobile-pocket established in 2009, the US-based Punchd (discontinued from June 2013,), which became part of Google in 2011. and an Australian-based loyalty card application called Stamp Me which incorporates iBeacon technology. Others, like Loopy Loyalty (HK), Loyalli (UK), Perka (US), and Whisqr Loyalty (CA), have offered similar programs. Passbook by Apple is the first attempt to standardize the format of mobile loyalty cards.

Offline with mobile device

With the introduction of host card emulation (HCE) and near field communication (NFC) technology for mobile applications, traditional contactless smart cards for prepaid and loyalty programs are emulated in a smartphone. Google Wallet adopted these technologies for mobile off-line payment applications.

The major advantage of off-line over the online system is that the user's smartphone does not have to be online, and the transaction is fast. In addition, multiple emulated cards can be stored in a smartphone to support multi-merchant loyalty programs. Consequently, the user does not need to carry many physical cards anymore.{{cite web |url=https://www.cbinsights.com/company/plink

Industries

Today, such loyalty programs cover most types of commerce, each having varying features and rewards schemes, and range from programs of a single-location business to large chains or membership in a coalition loyalty program. Industries include:

• Retail: Supermarkets, department stores, clothing stores, beauty stores and other specialty shops
• Travel and Hospitality: Airlines, passenger railways, hotels, car rental and carshare companies
• Food and Beverage: Restaurants, coffee shops, fast-food chains
• Financial Services: Banks, credit card companies
• Telecommunications: Mobile service providers, internet service providers
• Entertainment: Cinemas, streaming services, theme parks, casinos
• E-commerce sites/apps and online marketplaces
• Fitness and Wellness: Gyms, fitness studios, spas etc.
• Automotive: Car dealerships and service centers

The market approach has shifted from product-centric to a customer-centric one due to a highly competitive market and a wide array of services offered to customers, therefore, it's important that marketing strategies prioritize growing a sustainable business and increasing customer satisfaction.

Casinos

Almost all major U.S. casino chains also have loyalty cards, which offer members tier credits, reward credits, comps, and other perks based on card members' "theo" from gambling, various demographic data, and spend patterns on various purchases at the casino, within the casino network, and with the casino's partners. Examples of such programs include Caesars Rewards (formerly called Total Rewards) and MGM Resorts International's Mlife.

Coffee shops

"Disloyalty" cards

, some independent coffee shops in Boston, Toronto and London has set up experimental "disloyalty card" programs, which rewarded customers for visiting a variety of coffee shops.

Benefits to merchants

Loyalty programs' most important benefit to merchants is that they generate data, which bring more repeat business and therefore increase sales.

Application forms for cards usually entail agreements by the store concerning customer privacy, typically non-disclosure (by the store) of non-aggregate data about customers. The store uses aggregate data internally (and sometimes externally) as part of its marketing research. Over time the data can reveal, for example, a given customer's favorite brand of beer, or whether they are a vegetarian.

As of the mid-2020s, loyalty program trends include:

• the integration of AI and data analytics into loyalty platforms in order to personalize customer experiences,
• focusing on emotional connections, and
• offering personalized rewards that resonate with individual consumer preferences
• omnichannel experience to drive more interaction i.e. access across multiple physical and digital touchpoints such as in-store, via mail, e-mail, mobile apps, push notifications from the app or via SMS, websites, etc.

Loyalty programs are a means of implementing a type of what economists call a two-part tariff.

Asia

• Japan: see :ja:共通ポイント and :ja:ポイントプログラム#日本における歴史. In Japan, non credit card multi-brand points who awarded in addition to each store's own points are becoming more common. Most Japanese people say Big 4 of multi-brand points are V-POINT(ja)(SMCC(affiliated SMBC Group) and CCC)(merged T-POINT(ja)(CCC) on 22th Aplil 2024), Ponta(ja)(affiliated Mitsubishi Corporation), Rakuten point(ja), d Point Club(ja)(NTT Docomo). Other famous point bland are WAON(AEON Group(ja), JRE POINT(ja)(JR East), PayPay point(SoftBank Group's QR code payment), Nanaco.
• Hong Kong: Octopus Rewards, MTR Corporation.MTR Club for regular customers of transport network {{Cite web |access-date=2018-03-13 |archive-date=3 August 2020 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20200803111349/https://www.mtr.com.hk/en/customer/club/index.php |url-status=dead
• India: PAYBACK India is India's largest coalition loyalty program.{{cite news |access-date=28 July 2011 |newspaper=Business Standard
• Iran: The first Iranian loyalty program launched in 1996. East Credit Card Group Kish launched its loyalty program in 2005.
• Malaysia: Genting Highlands Resort loyalty card, WorldCard, is valid in three countries: Malaysia, Singapore and Hong Kong.
• Philippines: SM Supermalls and BDO Unibank offer rewards cards which are accepted by The SM Store, SM Supermarket, SM Hypermarket, ACE Hardware and Watsons Pharmacy. Robinsons Malls also offers a loyalty program through the Go Rewards app (formerly known as the Robinsons Rewards card). Others are Jollibee, (HappyPlus card), Grab Rewards, and Mercury Drug's Suki Card.
• Singapore: Loyalty programs in Singapore include GrabRewards by Grab, SAFRA and Plus! from NTUC.

Europe

• Austria: The two largest loyalty programs in Austria are Payback and mo. JÖ was fully launched in 2019.

• Finland: The two major retail coalitions with loyalty programs are the S-Group with their S-Etukortti card{{cite news |archive-url=https://wayback.archive-it.org/all/20171018170618/https://www.hs.fi/talous/art-2000002764112.html |url-status=dead |archive-date=18 October 2017

• Georgia: Georgia's biggest loyalty card program has been run by Universal Card Corporation since 2010 via UNICARD.

• Germany: The largest loyalty program is Payback, launched in 2000.{{cite web |access-date=2 November 2016 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20161104110632/http://www.payback.net/pl/en/about-payback/facts-figures/|archive-date=4 November 2016|url-status=dead}} and the Shell ClubSmart program are next in size. was launched by Arvato in 2008. HappyDigits was disbanded by 2010.

• Hungary: SuperShop and Multipoint are their main loyalty programs.

• Italy: After the exit of Nectar from the market in 2015, Payback is the most popular loyalty program. Supermarkets Esselunga, Coop and Il Gigante also have loyalty programs.

• Latvia: One of the largest loyalty programs in Latvia which is working as an operator for many merchants is Pins. Another is Walmoo

• Norway: The largest Norwegian loyalty program is Trumf. Trumf is a "brick and mortar" loyalty program owned by NorgesGruppen, a grocery wholesaling group in Norway. KickBack.no is one of the largest online loyalty programs and cashback sites in Norway. KickBack.no is owned by Schibsted Media Group.

• Republic of Ireland: Superquinn introduced its SuperClub loyalty card in 1993, the prototype for Europe. However, loyalty cards did not expand until 1997, when Tesco Ireland introduced its Clubcard scheme, shortly after its purchase of Power Supermarkets. SuperValu introduced their own loyalty club called Real Rewards. Others were:

  • During the late 1990s—Esso petrol program were: Tiger Miles, Maxol, Texaco and Statoil. Increasing oil prices ended these in 2005.
  • Game, a major computer game and hardware retailer, which merged with Electronics Boutique's programme.
  • Rewards From Us To You, a hotel loyalty program

• Romania: Cardora, launched in 2025, provides app-free digital loyalty cards using Apple and Google Wallet and enables cross-business partnerships. {{cite web | title = Cardora lansează platforma de carduri digitale de fidelizare în România | url = https://www.prlog.org/13099248-cardora-lanseaz-platforma-de-carduri-digitale-de-fidelizare-romnia.html

• Russia: MALINA, "the largest multicorporate customer loyalty program in Russia,"{{cite web |access-date=30 August 2020 |archive-date=26 September 2020 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20200926025628/https://jet.su/en/press/news/12732/ |url-status=dead

• Switzerland: Loyalty programs are popular in Switzerland, with the two main supermarket chains, Migros and Coop prominent. The M-Cumulus card can be used at the Migros supermarkets, Ex Libris, SportXX, and other retailers. The Coop Supercard earns points on purchases at Coop and a variety of other associated stores. Other stores such as Interio, a furniture retailer, are also joining the market with loyalty cards and store-based incentivized credit cards. The only coalition loyalty scheme in Switzerland is Bonus Card with a network of over 300 independent retail partners. In recent years, online loyalty programs have also started to target the Swiss. First to make an offering in Switzerland was German-based Webmiles. Claiming to be Switzerland's first online bonus program, Bonuspoints was launched in early 2008 and offers incentives for shopping at 70 different online stores.

• Turkey: Pegasus Airlines has a loyalty program called Pegasus Plus which gives rewards for every flight. Passengers can spend reward points as a discount without waiting to cover a full flight. Turkish Airlines has a loyalty program called Miles&Smiles.

• United Kingdom: Passcard (later renamed Passkey) was in the early 1980s.{{Cite news |access-date=19 July 2020}} Sainsbury's Homebase Spend and Save Card was another early 1980s loyalty card.{{cite news |url=https://www.theguardian.com/money/blog/2012/jul/26/how-loyal-are-you-to-your-reward-cards |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20121213040530/http://www.morrisons.co.uk/Whats-New/Dont-miss-out-on-your-miles |url-status=dead |archive-date=2012-12-13|title=Morrisons Miles – Morrisons}} Many stores have kiosks that, with the cards, print vouchers that can be used at the till. Safeway's ABC Card was discontinued in 2000. Maximiles{{cite web|title=Maximiles acquires ipoints to create Europe's no. 1 online coalition loyalty company |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20061020181600/http://www.e-consultancy.com/news-blog/361397/maximiles-acquires-ipoints-to-create-europe-s-no-1-online-coalition-loyalty-company.html?keywords=loyalty |archive-date=20 October 2006 |url-status=dead}} is an online coalition program. Formerly operated by British Airways, Airmiles was rebranded in 2011 from Airmiles to Avios, with changes that caused members to pay taxes and fees on flights they used for redemption. Co-operative Membership: the Co-op Group offers a 2% (previously 5%) refund to members on Co-op branded products with 2% also going to the cardholder's nominated charity. This is only available in Co-op Group stores. It replaced the dividend benefit previously used. Other Co-op chains continue with the dividend scheme, e.g. Midcounties Co-operative. Many of these accept other Co-operative loyalty cards but generally without the same benefits. For instance Midcounties Co-operative accept Co-operative Group cards but there is no charity donation or cardholder refund.

The Americas

• Brazil
  • Dotz is a coalition loyalty program in Brazil with over 50 million members
• Canada

  • Aeroplan, a coalition program centered on Air Canada with Apple, Sephora, Uber also participating

  • Air Miles is Canada's largest loyalty program.

  • Canadian Tire's Canadian Tire money is the oldest loyalty program in Canada.the company gives out coupons which look like currency {{cite web

  • The food and beverage industry also has several companies with rewards programs such as Tim Hortons' Tim's Rewards

  • Scene+, a coalition program with participants include Cineplex-owned cinemas, Scotiabank (for spending using its cards), Sobeys grocery stores, Home Hardware, Expedia, Recipe restaurants and Rakuten Rewards.

• United States: In the US, loyalty cards have a long history. Some are only online.{{cite web |url=https://www.frugalforless.com/money-making-apps |access-date=7 November 2017}}{{cite web |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20160123073613/http://techcrunch.com/2016/01/22/fivestars-gets-50m-to-help-small-retailers-run-loyalty-programs-like-their-bigger-rivals |url-status=dead |archive-date=23 January 2016 |access-date=22 November 2016}} Frequent-flyer programs and, less commonly SeaMiles co-exist with programs that donate a percentage of sales to a designated charity.{{cite web |access-date=25 July 2007
  • Coalition programs include Plenti
• Mexico:
  • Aeroméxico Rewards, formerly Club Premier, a coalition program with participation of Aeromexico airlines and multiple otherwise unrelated retail chains
  • Monedero Naranja (lit. "Orange Wallet"), in which Comercial Mexicana's various supermarket brands La Comer, Fresko and City Market, participate

Oceania

Flybuys is the largest loyalty program in both Australia{{cite news |access-date=20 May 2013 |newspaper=B & T |access-date=27 February 2011 |newspaper=The Australian |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20100729113827/http://www.colloquy.com/breaking_view.asp?xd=7379|archive-date=29 July 2010}} and New Zealand.Flybuys (New Zealand) {{Cite web

• Australia: Contenders include Woolworths' Everyday Rewards,{{Cite news |access-date=27 August 2010 |newspaper=Australian Food News
• New Zealand: Other programs include the New Zealand Automobile Association AA Smartfuel programme and Countdown supermarket's Onecard. Kachingo was a short-lived "card free" programme.

As virtual currency

Loyalty programs have been described as a form of centralized virtual currency, one with unidirectional cash flow, since reward points can be exchanged into a good or service but not into cash.

Criticism

Evidence for the effectiveness of loyalty programs is controversial. Many companies are unsure whether and how to use customer loyalty programs profitably. Many programs (regardless of location, size, or industry) are run without the appropriate metrics or target parameters.

Some companies complain that loyalty programs discount goods to people who are buying goods anyway. Moreover, the expense of participating in these programs rarely generates a good return on investment. The Forte Consultancy Group regards loyalty programs as bribes. | access-date= 28 April 2019

A 2015 study found that most supermarket loyalty cards in the United States do not offer any real value to their customers.{{cite web |access-date= 3 September 2015

One may view loyalty and credit-card reward-plans as modern-day examples of kickbacks. Compare: | publication-date = 1990 | access-date = 10 January 2021 Employees who need to buy something (such as an airline flight or a hotel room) for a business trip, but who have discretion to decide which airline or hotel chain to use, have an incentive to choose the payment method that provides the most cash-back, | publication-date = 1991 | access-date = 10 January 2021 credit-card rewards or loyalty points instead of minimizing costs for their employer.

References

References

1. "Coalition loyalty programs: how to create an engaging open-loop loyalty program?".
2. "Earn Cash Back".
3. "Air Miles Middle East".
4. (19 August 2021). "Do downtown shopping districts need their own loyalty programs? - RetailWire".
5. (5 March 2020). "Preparing for loyalty's next frontier: Ecosystems {{!}} McKinsey".
6. "What is a Loyalty Program: Benefits, Types".
7. Wood, Zoe. (3 July 2024). "Sparks fly as M&S says no to a plastic loyalty card". The Guardian.
8. Leff, Gary. (24 September 2020). "No More American Airlines Elite Membership Cards, But You Can Still Call For Employee Recognition Certs". View from the Wing}}{{self-published inline.
9. Mottl, Judy. (3 August 2023). "Tanger Outlets takes digital-first strategy in loyalty program revamp".
10. (2025). "Digital Loyalty in Romania: Pioneering Case Study". SeedByte.
11. "Premium Membership and Rewards".
12. (13 March 2019). "Global games and FinTech supplier Everi acquires casino kiosk firm Atrient for US$40 million". IAG.
13. (17 December 2012). "Google Kills Punchd Mobile Loyalty Card App".
14. (12 July 2011). "Google's Punchd acquisition to push mobile wallet uptake". VentureBeat.
15. (26 November 2012). "Stamp Me app replaces loyalty cards".
16. (12 April 2013). "10 Best Money Saving Apps". The Guardian.
17. (25 October 2023). "101 of the best loyalty programs".
18. (June 2021). "Effectiveness of Loyalty Programs in Customer Retention: A Multiple Mediation Analysis". Jindal Journal of Business Research.
19. Dow, Natasha. (26 January 2012). "Issue 2 Crowds and Clouds » THE TOUCH-POINT COLLECTIVE: CROWD CONTOURING ON THE CASINO FLOOR".
20. Long, Emily. (6 December 2018). "How Casinos Use Rewards Programs to Track Everything You Do".
21. "Caesars Rewards".
22. "Total Rewards Card".
23. "Mlife".
24. Annear, Steve. (15 December 2011). "Local coffee shops start 'Disloyalty Card' campaign". Metro.
25. Bain, Jennifer. (12 April 2010). "Disloyalty has its privileges". [[Toronto Star]].
26. (2021). "Leveraging Loyalty Programs Using Competitor Based Targeting". Quantitative Marketing and Economics.
27. (9 May 2024). "The Evolution of Customer Loyalty Programs in the Digital Age". CMSWire.
28. [https://www.tv-tokyo.co.jp/plus/smp/entertainment/entry/2020/021484.html 4大共通ポイントカードは”衝撃の進化”を遂げていた...その特長と賢い使い方...] テレ東プラス（2021年3月11日閲覧）
29. "About Octopus Rewards".
30. (27 June 2017). "MoneyBack Celebrates its 10th Anniversary – A.S. Watson Group {{!}} A member of CK Hutchison Holdings". A.S. Watson Group.
31. (2015-01-22). "The Club rewards HKT Premier customers for their loyalty".
32. "Even More Rewarding Experience for Asia Miles Members".
33. (17 June 2010). "i-mint and PAYBACK team up in India". Colloquy.
34. (15 October 2009). "BPCL celebrates PetroBonus 10th anniversary". [[The Hindu]].
35. "Indian Oil does a hat-trick at the 3rd loyalty summit".
36. "Home – گروه کارتهای اعتباری ایران".
37. "گروه کارتهای اعتباری ایران".
38. "Programme Partners". Genting Malaysia Berhad.
39. "List of Discount and Reward Cards in the Philippines".
40. "FAQs".
41. (28 July 2014). "FAQS: Rewards".
42. "Go Rewards Card".
43. "Robinsons Rewards Is Now GoRewards".
44. "FAQs".
45. "GrabRewards - Grab Loyalty Programme | Grab PH".
46. "FAQs".
47. "GrabRewards – Grab Loyalty Programme".
48. "SAFRA home page".
49. "Plus! home page".
50. "Studien". Loyalty Partner.
51. Focus, Global Convenience Store. (2021-02-01). "Principles, Promises and Challenges of Coalition Loyalty {{!}} Global C Store Focus".
52. Nesset, Erik. "Building chain loyalty in grocery retailing by means of loyalty programs–A study of 'the Norwegian case'.". Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services.
53. [http://www.finaccord.com/uk/tables-of-contents_html/global-coalition-loyalty-programs.htm Finaccord List of Global Loyalty Programs.] {{Webarchive. link. (22 November 2018 Retrieved 1 March 2016)
54. (5 May 2000). "Safeway scraps loyalty card". BBC News.
55. "Brochure". Maximiles Group.
56. O'Reilly, Lara. (2 September 2011). "Avios rebrand causes backlash for AirMiles company".
57. (19 April 2023). "#368: Coalition Loyalty - Dotz Brazil Celebrates 50 Million Members". The Wise Marketer.
58. Tims Rewards: https://www.timhortons.ca/timsrewards
59. (8 September 2023). "Loyalty has its price. More companies partner-up with reward card programs as cash-strapped customers hunt for deals". Toronto Star.
60. (14 July 2008). "Article". [[Los Angeles Times]].
61. (August 2016). "How Coalition Loyalty Programs can Excel". Ad Age.
62. "¿Qué es Monedero Naranja?".
63. Smith, Sean. (2023-06-30). "Wesfarmers Health fast-tracks growth to $40 billion bounty".
64. (25 September 2006). "Brazin's Pulse goes over the 1 million mark". The Wise Marketer.
65. European Central Bank. (October 2012). "Virtual Currency Schemes". European Central Bank.
66. (2022). "Loyalty Program Assessment. KPI-Based Evaluation of Customer Loyalty Programs". HWZ Working Paper Series.
67. (21 March 2018). "How do companies use my loyalty card data?". BBC News.
68. (2021). "Leveraging Loyalty Programs Using Competitor Based Targeting". SMU Cox School of Business Research Paper No. 19-10.
69. Albrecht, Katherine. "Why getting a shopper card under a fake name is not the answer".
70. (2005). "Brand Loyalty Programs: Are They Shams?". Marketing Science.