Ethnic cleansing

Etymology

An antecedent to the term is the Greek word andrapodismos (ἀνδραποδισμός; lit. "enslavement"), which was used in ancient texts. e.g., to describe atrocities that accompanied the Athenian general Chares and his seizure and destruction of Sestos in 353 and Alexander the Great's conquest of Thebes in 335 BCE. The expulsion of the Moriscos from Spain between 1609 and 1614 is considered by some authors to be one of the first episodes of state-sponsored ethnic cleansing in the modern western world. Raphael Lemkin, who coined the term "genocide", considered the displacement of Native Americans by American settlers as a historical example of genocide. Others, like historian Gary Anderson, contend that genocide does not accurately characterize any aspect of American history, suggesting instead that ethnic cleansing is a more appropriate term. The Circassian genocide, also known as "Tsitsekun", is often regarded by various historians as the first large-scale ethnic cleansing campaign launched by a state during the 19th century industrial era. Imperial Russian general Nikolay Yevdakimov, who supervised the operations of Circassian genocide during 1860s, dehumanised Muslim Circassians as "a pestilence" to be expelled from their native lands. Russian objective was the annexation of land; and the Russian military operations that forcibly deported Circassians were designated by Yevdakimov as “ochishchenie” (cleansing).

In the early 1900s, regional variants of the term could be found among the Czechs (očista), the Poles (czystki etniczne), the French (épuration) and the Germans (Säuberung). A 1913 Carnegie Endowment report condemning the actions of all participants in the Balkan Wars contained various new terms to describe brutalities committed toward ethnic groups.

During the Holocaust in World War II, Nazi Germany pursued a policy of ensuring that Europe was "cleaned of Jews" (judenrein). The Nazi Generalplan Ost called for the genocide and ethnic cleansing of most Slavic people in central and eastern Europe for the purpose of providing more living space for the Germans. During the Genocide of Serbs in the Independent State of Croatia, the euphemism čišćenje terena ("cleansing the terrain") was used by the Croatian Ustaše to describe military actions in which non-Croats were purposely systematically killed or otherwise uprooted from their homes. The term was also used in the December 20, 1941, directive of Serbian Chetniks in reference to the genocidal massacres they committed against Bosniaks and Croats between 1941 and 1945. The Russian phrase очистка границ (ochistka granits; lit. "cleansing of borders") was used in Soviet documents of the early 1930s to refer to the forced resettlement of Polish people from the 22 km border zone in the Byelorussian and Ukrainian SSRs. This process of the population transfer in the Soviet Union was repeated on an even larger scale in 1939–1941, involving many other groups suspected of disloyalty.

In its complete form, the term appeared for the first time in the Romanian language (purificare etnică) in an address by Vice Prime Minister Mihai Antonescu to cabinet members in July 1941. After the beginning of the invasion by the Soviet Union, he concluded: "I do not know when the Romanians will have such chance for ethnic cleansing." In the 1980s, the Soviets used the term "etnicheskoye chishcheniye" which literally translates to "ethnic cleansing" to describe Azerbaijani efforts to drive Armenians away from Nagorno-Karabakh. It was widely popularized by the Western media during the Bosnian War (1992–1995).

In 1992, the German equivalent of ethnic cleansing (, ) was named German Un-word of the Year by the Gesellschaft für deutsche Sprache due to its euphemistic, inappropriate nature.

Definitions

The Final Report of the Commission of Experts established pursuant to Security Council Resolution 780 defined ethnic cleansing as:

The official United Nations definition of ethnic cleansing is "rendering an area ethnically homogeneous by using force or intimidation to remove from a given area persons of another ethnic or religious group." As a category, ethnic cleansing encompasses a continuum or spectrum of policies. In the words of Andrew Bell-Fialkoff, "ethnic cleansing ... defies easy definition. At one end it is virtually indistinguishable from forced emigration and population exchange while at the other it merges with deportation and genocide. At the most general level, however, ethnic cleansing can be understood as the expulsion of a population from a given territory."

Terry Martin has defined ethnic cleansing as "the forcible removal of an ethnically defined population from a given territory" and as "occupying the central part of a continuum between genocide on one end and nonviolent pressured ethnic emigration on the other end."

Gregory Stanton, the founder of Genocide Watch, has criticised the rise of the term and its use for events that he feels should be called "genocide": because "ethnic cleansing" has no legal definition, its media use can detract attention from events that should be prosecuted as genocide. Ethnic cleansing has therefore and for being read as euphemistic alternatively identified as ethnocide or cultural genocide.

As a crime under international law

There is no international treaty that specifies a specific crime of ethnic cleansing; however, ethnic cleansing in the broad sense—the forcible deportation of a population—is defined as a crime against humanity under the statutes of both the International Criminal Court (ICC) and the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY). The gross human rights violations integral to stricter definitions of ethnic cleansing are treated as separate crimes falling under public international law of crimes against humanity and in certain circumstances genocide. There are also situations, such as the expulsion of Germans after World War II, where ethnic cleansing has taken place without legal redress (see Preussische Treuhand v. Poland). Timothy v. Waters argues that similar ethnic cleansing could go unpunished in the future.

Mutual ethnic cleansing

Mutual ethnic cleansing occurs when two groups commit ethnic cleansing against minority members of the other group within their own territories. For instance in the 1920s, Turkey expelled its Greek minority and Greece expelled its Turkish minority following the Greco-Turkish War. Other examples where mutual ethnic cleansing occurred include the First Nagorno-Karabakh War and the population transfers by the Soviets of Germans, Poles, and Ukrainians after World War II.

Causes

According to Michael Mann, in The Dark Side of Democracy (2004), murderous ethnic cleansing is strongly related to the creation of democracies. He argues that murderous ethnic cleansing is due to the rise of nationalism, which associates citizenship with a specific ethnic group. Democracy, therefore, is tied to ethnic and national forms of exclusion. Nevertheless, it is not democratic states that are more prone to commit ethnic cleansing, because minorities tend to have constitutional guarantees. Neither are stable authoritarian regimes (except the Nazi and communist regimes) which are likely perpetrators of murderous ethnic cleansing, but those regimes that are in process of democratization. Ethnic hostility appears where ethnicity overshadows social classes as the primordial system of social stratification. Usually, in deeply divided societies, categories such as class and ethnicity are deeply intertwined, and when an ethnic group is seen as oppressor or exploitative of the other, serious ethnic conflict can develop. Michael Mann holds that when two ethnic groups claim sovereignty over the same territory and can feel threatened, their differences can lead to severe grievances and danger of ethnic cleansing. The perpetration of murderous ethnic cleansing tends to occur in unstable geopolitical environments and in contexts of war. As ethnic cleansing requires high levels of organisation and is usually directed by states or other authoritative powers, perpetrators are usually state powers or institutions with some coherence and capacity, not failed states as it is generally perceived. The perpetrator powers tend to get support by core constituencies that favour combinations of nationalism, statism, and violence.

Ethnic cleansing was prevalent during the Age of Nationalism in Europe (19th and 20th centuries). Multi-ethnic European engaged in ethnic cleansing against minorities in order to pre-empt their secession and the loss of territory. Ethnic cleansing was particularly prevalent during periods of interstate war.

Genocide

Ethnic cleansing has been described as part of a continuum of violence whose most extreme form is genocide. Ethnic cleansing is similar to forced deportation or population transfer. While ethnic cleansing and genocide may share the same goal and methods (e.g., forced displacement), ethnic cleansing is intended to displace a persecuted population from a given territory, while genocide is intended to destroy a group.Ethnic cleansing versus genocide:

Some academics consider genocide to be a subset of "murderous ethnic cleansing". Norman Naimark writes that these concepts are different but related, for "literally and figuratively, ethnic cleansing bleeds into genocide, as mass murder is committed in order to rid the land of a people." William Schabas states "ethnic cleansing is also a warning sign of genocide to come. Genocide is the last resort of the frustrated ethnic cleanser." Multiple genocide scholars have criticized distinguishing between ethnic cleansing and genocide, with Martin Shaw arguing that forced deportation necessarily results in the destruction of a group and this must be foreseen by the perpetrators.{{efn| "How could ‘forced deportation’ ever be achieved without extreme coercion, indeed violence? How, indeed, could deportation not be forced? How could people not resist? How could it not involve the destruction of a community, of the way of life that a group has enjoyed over a period of time? How could those who deported a group not intend this destruction? In what significant way is the forcible removal of a population from their homeland different from the destruction’ of a group? If the boundary between ‘cleansing’ and genocide is unreal, why police it?" Furthermore ethnic cleansing has been identified as a euphemism for genocide or cultural genocide.

As a military, political, and economic tactic

The foibe massacres (; ; ), or simply "the foibe", refers to ethnic cleansing, mass killings and deportations both during and immediately after World War II, mainly committed by Yugoslav Partisans and OZNA in the then-Italian territories of Julian March (Karst Region and Istria), Kvarner and Dalmatia, against local Italians (Istrian Italians and Dalmatian Italians) and Slavs, primarily members of fascist and collaborationist forces, and civilians opposed to the new Yugoslav authorities, and Italian, German, Croat and Slovene anti-communists against the regime of Josip Broz Tito, presumed to be associated with fascism, Nazism, collaboration with Axis and reventive purge of real, potential or presumed opponents of Titoism The foibe massacres were followed by the Istrian–Dalmatian exodus, which was the post-World War II exodus and departure of between 230,000 and 350,000 local ethnic Italians (Istrian Italians and Dalmatian Italians) towards Italy, and in smaller numbers, towards the Americas, Australia and South Africa. From 1947, after the war, they were subject by Yugoslav authorities to less violent forms of intimidation, such as nationalization, expropriation, and discriminatory taxation, which gave them little option other than emigration. In 1953, there were 36,000 declared Italians in Yugoslavia, just about 16% of the original Italian population before World War II. According to the census organized in Croatia in 2001 and that organized in Slovenia in 2002, the Italians who remained in the former Yugoslavia amounted to 21,894 people (2,258 in Slovenia and 19,636 in Croatia).

The resettlement policy of the Neo-Assyrian Empire in the 9th and 7th centuries BC is considered by some scholars to be one of the first cases of ethnic cleansing.

During the 1980s, in Lebanon, ethnic cleansing was common during all phases of the conflict, notable incidents were seen in the early phase of the war, such as the Damour massacre, the Karantina massacre, the Siege of the Tel al-Zaatar Palestinian refugee camp, and during the 1982 Lebanon War such as the Sabra and Shatila Massacre committed by Lebanese Maronite forces backed by Israel against Palestinian refugees and Lebanese Shia civilians. After the Israeli withdrawal from the Chouf, the Mountain War broke out, where ethnic cleansings (mostly in the form of tit-for-tat killings) occurred. During that time, the Syrian backed, mostly Druze dominated People's Liberation Army used a policy they called "territorial cleansing" to "drain" the Chouf of Maronite Christians in order to deny them of resisting the advance of the PSP. As a result, 163,670 Christian villagers were displaced due to these operations. In response to these massacres, the Lebanese Forces conducted a similar policy, which resulted in 20,000 Druze displaced.

Ethnic cleansing was a common phenomenon in the wars in Croatia, Kosovo, and Bosnia and Herzegovina. This entailed intimidation, forced expulsion, or killing of the unwanted ethnic group as well as the destruction of the places of worship, cemeteries and cultural and historical buildings of that ethnic group in order to alter the population composition of an area in the favour of another ethnic group which would become the majority.

According to numerous ICTY verdicts and indictments, Serb and Croat forces performed ethnic cleansing of their territories planned by their political leadership to create ethnically pure states (Republika Srpska and Republic of Serbian Krajina by the Serbs; and Herzeg-Bosnia by the Croats).

Survivors of the ethnic cleansing were left severely traumatized as a consequence of this campaign.

Israeli herders have engaged in a systemic displacement of Palestinian herders in Area C of the West Bank as a form of nationalist and economic warfare.

According to historian Norman Naimark, during an ethnic cleansing process, there may be destruction of physical symbols of the victims including temples, books, monuments, graveyards, and street names: "Ethnic cleansing involves not only the forced deportation of entire nations but the eradication of the memory of their presence."

Instances

Main article: List of ethnic cleansing campaigns

Explanatory notes

Notes

References

• {{cite journal | archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20040203190219/http://www.foreignaffairs.org/19930601faessay5199/andrew-bell-fialkoff/a-brief-history-of-ethnic-cleansing.html | archive-date=February 3, 2004 | url-access=subscription}}
• {{cite book | author-link1 = Donald Bloxham | author-link2 = A. Dirk Moses | editor-first1 = Donald | editor-last1 = Bloxham | editor-first2 = Robert | editor-last2 = Gerwarth
• {{Cite book|language = en | archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20200223115751/https://www.kozina.com/premik/indexeng_porocilo.htm | archive-date = February 23, 2020 | chapter-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20201105021740/http://www.kozina.com/premik/poreng4.htm
• {{cite book | editor-first1 = Ota | editor-last1 = Konrád | editor-first2 = Boris | editor-last2 = Barth | editor-first3 = Jaromír | editor-last3 = Mrňka | access-date = November 5, 2022
• {{cite journal
• {{cite journal
• Vladimir Petrović (2007), Etnicizacija čišćenja u reči i nedelu (Ethnicisation of Cleansing), Hereticus 1/2007, 11–36
• {{cite book

References

1. (2000). "The history and politics of ethnic cleansing". The International Journal of Human Rights.
2. (2003). "'Ethnic Cleansing' and Genocide: Similarities and Distinctions". European Yearbook of Minority Issues Online.
3. The danger of overstretching the term can be avoided...The goal of ethnic cleansing is to permanently remove a group from the area it inhabits...There is a popular dimension to ethnic cleansing because there are people needed to threaten with violence, to evict homes, organize mass transports, and to prevent the return of the unwanted...The main goal of ethnic cleansing was the removal of a group from a certain territory ''The Oxford Handbook of Postwar European History''. (2012). United Kingdom: OUP Oxford.
4. "Peace, preference, and property : return migration after violent conflict". University of Michigan.
5. (September 27, 2023). "'Ethnic Cleansing': An Analysis of Conceptual and Empirical Ambiguity". Political Science Quarterly.
6. "Who first coined the euphemism "ethnic cleansing" for racial murder and persecution? Surely it must have been a dictator? {{!}} Notes and Queries {{!}} guardian.co.uk".
7. Howe, Marvine. (July 12, 1982). "Exodus of Serbians stirs province in Yugoslavia". The New York Times.
8. (2018). "The state of the field and debates on ethnic cleansing". Nationalities Papers.
9. "Ethnic cleansing". United Nations Office on Genocide Prevention and the Responsibility to Protect.
10. (2012). "Crimes Against Humanity: A Beginner's Guide". Simon and Schuster.
11. (2003). "'Ethnic Cleansing' and Genocide: Similarities and Distinctions". European Yearbook of Minority Issues Online.
12. (2011). "[[The Young Turks' Crime Against Humanity: The Armenian Genocide and Ethnic Cleansing in the Ottoman Empire]]". Princeton University Press.
13. Booth Walling, Carrie. (2012). "The Kosovo Tragedy: The Human Rights Dimensions". Routledge.
14. (2012). "Deleuze and Race". Edinburgh University Press.
15. (2005). "Raphael Lemkin as historian of genocide in the Americas". [[Journal of Genocide Research]].
16. Sousa, Ashley. (2016). "Ethnic Cleansing and the Indian: The Crime That Should Haunt America by Gary Clayton Anderson". Journal of Southern History.
17. Richmond, Walter. (2013). "The Circassian Genocide". Rutgers University Press.
18. Levene, Mark. (2005). "Genocide in the Age of the Nation-State Volume II: The Rise of the West and the Coming of Genocide". New York, NY.
19. Ther, Philipp. (2004). "Diasporas and Ethnic Migrants: Germany, Israel and Russia in Comparative Perspective". Routledge.
20. Akhund, Nadine. (December 31, 2012). "The Two Carnegie Reports: From the Balkan Expedition of 1913 to the Albanian Trip of 1921". Balkanologie. Revue d'études pluridisciplinaires.
21. Fulbrooke, Mary. (2004). "A Concise History of Germany". Cambridge University Press.
22. Eichholtz, Dietrich. (September 2004). "'Generalplan Ost' zur Versklavung osteuropäischer Völker". Utopie Kreativ.
23. (2011). "Bosnia Remade: Ethnic Cleansing and Its Reversal". Oxford University Press.
24. West, Richard. (1994). "Tito and the Rise and Fall of Yugoslavia". Carroll & Graf.
25. Becirevic, Edina. (2014). "Genocide on the River Drina". Yale University Press.
26. (May 23, 2017). "The Nakba did not start or end in 1948". Al Jazeera.
27. Petrovic, Vladimir. (2017). "Ethnopolitical Temptations Reach Southeastern Europe: Wartime Policy Papers of Vasa Čubrilović and Sabin Manuilă". CEU Press.
28. Allen, Tim, and Jean Seaton, eds. ''The media of conflict: War reporting and representations of ethnic violence''. Zed Books, 1999. p. 152
29. Feierstein, Daniel. (April 4, 2023). "The Meaning of Concepts: Some Reflections on the Difficulties in Analysing State Crimes". HARM – Journal of Hostility, Aggression, Repression and Malice.
30. (August 2024)
31. Gunkel, Christoph. (October 31, 2010). "Ein Jahr, ein (Un-)Wort!". [[Spiegel Online]].
32. (May 27, 1994). "Final Report of the Commission of Experts Established Pursuant to United Nations Security Council Resolution 780 (1992)". United Nations Security Council.
33. (May 27, 1994). "Final Report of the Commission of Experts Established Pursuant to United Nations Security Council Resolution 780 (1992)". United Nations Security Council.
34. Hayden, Robert M. (1996) [https://www.jstor.org/stable/2501233 "Schindler's Fate: Genocide, Ethnic Cleansing, and Population Transfers"] {{Webarchive. link. (April 11, 2016 . ''[[Slavic Review]]'' 55 (4), 727–48.)
35. Andrew Bell-Fialkoff, [http://www.foreignaffairs.org/19930601faessay5199/andrew-bell-fialkoff/a-brief-history-of-ethnic-cleansing.html "A Brief History of Ethnic Cleansing"] {{webarchive. link. (February 3, 2004 , ''Foreign Affairs'' 72 (3): 110, Summer 1993. Retrieved May 20, 2006.)
36. Martin, Terry (1998). [https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/235168 "The Origins of Soviet Ethnic Cleansing"] {{Webarchive. link. (July 24, 2019. ''[[The Journal of Modern History]]'' 70 (4), 813–861. p. 822)
37. Douglas Singleterry (April 2010), "Ethnic Cleansing and Genocidal Intent: A Failure of Judicial Interpretation?", ''Genocide Studies and Prevention'' 5, 1
38. Heiskanen, Jaakko. (October 1, 2021). "In the Shadow of Genocide: Ethnocide, Ethnic Cleansing, and International Order". Global Studies Quarterly.
39. Ferdinandusse, Ward. (2004). "The Interaction of National and International Approaches in the Repression of International Crimes". The European Journal of International Law.
40. [https://www.un.org/law/icc/statute/99_corr/2.htm "Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court"] {{webarchive. link. (January 13, 2008 , Article 7; [https://www.un.org/icty/legaldoc-e/index.htm ''Updated Statute of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia''] {{Webarchive). link. (August 6, 2009 , Article 5.)
41. (2004). "The International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia". The European Journal of International Law.
42. link. (November 6, 2018 , Paper 951, 2006, [[University of Mississippi]] School of Law. Retrieved on 2006, 12–13)
43. (2009). "When God Comes to Town: Religious Traditions in Urban Contexts". Berghahn Books.
44. (September 1998). "Religion as a factor in Caucasian conflicts". Civil Wars.
45. (2004). "The Reconstruction of Nations: Poland, Ukraine, Lithuania, Belarus, 1569–1999". Yale University Press.
46. [https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/dark-side-of-democracy/7E75A132A188A2804E91F4F209B6FE1F] {{Webarchive. link. (May 3, 2020, Mann, Michael (2005), ''The Dark Side of Democracy: Explaining Ethnic Cleansing''. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, Ch. 1 "The Argument," pp. 1–33.)
47. (2024). "'Right-Peopling' the State: Nationalism, Historical Legacies, and Ethnic Cleansing in Europe, 1886–2020". Journal of Conflict Resolution.
48. Mylonas, Harris. (2013). "The Politics of Nation-Building: Making Co-Nationals, Refugees, and Minorities". Cambridge University Press.
49. International Association of Genocide Scholars. (December 16, 2007). "Genocide Scholars Association Officially Recognizes Assyrian, Greek Genocides".
50. Schabas, William. (2000). "Genocide in International Law". Cambridge University Press.
51. Mann, Michael. (2005). "The Dark Side of Democracy: Explaining Ethnic Cleansing". Cambridge University Press..
52. Naimark, Norman. (2007). "Theoretical Paper: Ethnic Cleansing".
53. 978-0-7456-8706-3 ‘Cleansing’ and genocide.
54. (2021–2022). "Settling the Genocide v. Ethnic Cleansing Debate: Ending Misuse of the Euphemism Ethnic Cleansing". Denver Journal of International Law and Policy.
55. (2016). "Genocide: A Comprehensive Introduction". [[Taylor & Francis]].
56. Richmond, Walter. (2013). "The Circassian Genocide". Rutgers University Press.
57. Richmond, Walter. (2013). "The Circassian Genocide". Rutgers University Press.
58. Levene, Mark. (2005). "Genocide in the Age of the Nation-State Volume II: The Rise of the West and the Coming of Genocide".
59. Troha, Nevenka. (2014). "Nasilje vojnih in povojnih dni". Inštitut za novejšo zgodovino.
60. (February 10, 2014). "Il Giorno del Ricordo".
61. (February 5, 2019). "L'esodo giuliano-dalmata e quegli italiani in fuga che nacquero due volte".
62. Pamela Ballinger. (2009). "Genocide: Truth, Memory, and Representation". Duke University Press.
63. (2013). "Ethnic Cleansing and the European Union". Springer.
64. (2003). "History in Exile: Memory and Identity at the Borders of the Balkans". Princeton University Press.
65. Anna C. Bramwell. (1988). "Refugees in the Age of Total War". Unwin Hyman.
66. Klemenčič, Matjaž. "The Effects of the Dissolution of Yugoslavia on Minority Rights: the Italian Minority in Post-Yugoslav Slovenia and Croatia".
67. "12. Population by ethnicity, by towns/municipalities, census 2001".
68. "Popis 2002".
69. "Ethnic cleansing". Encyclopaedia Britannica.
70. (August 16, 1991). "News". An-Nahar.
71. (2004). "La réconciliation des druzes et des chrétiens du Mont Liban ou le retour à un code coutumier". Critique Internationale.
72. "Prosecutor v. Vujadin Popovic, Ljubisa Beara, Drago Nikolic, Ljubomir Borovcanin, Radivoje Miletic, Milan Gvero, and Vinko Pandurevic".
73. "ICTY: Radoslav Brđanin judgement".
74. "Tadic Case: The Verdict".
75. "Prosecutor v. Jadranko Prlic, Bruno Stojic, Slobodan Praljak, Milivoj Petkovic, Valentin Coric and Berislav Pusic".
76. Amira, Saad. (2021). "The slow violence of Israeli settler-colonialism and the political ecology of ethnic cleansing in the West Bank". Settler Colonial Studies.
77. (October 21, 2023). "'The most successful land-grab strategy since 1967' as settlers push Bedouins off West Bank territory". The Guardian.
78. Ziv, Oren. (October 19, 2023). "בעוד העיניים נשואות לדרום ולעזה, הטיהור האתני בגדה מואץ". Mekomit.
79. (April 4, 2025). "Displaced Communities, Forgotten People: Israel's Forcible Transfer of Palestinians in the West Bank". [[Yesh Din]].
80. Naimark, Norman M.. (2002). "Fires of Hatred: Ethnic Cleansing in Twentieth-Century Europe". Harvard University Press.