Ersatz good

Etymology

Ersatz () is a German word meaning substitute or replacement. Although it is used as an adjective in English, it is a noun in German. In German orthography noun phrases formed are usually represented as a single word, forming compound nouns such as Ersatzteile ("spare parts") or Ersatzspieler ("substitute player"). While ersatz in English generally means that the substitution is of unsatisfactory or inferior quality compared with the "real thing", in German, there is no such implication: e.g., Ersatzteile 'spare parts' is a technical expression without any implication about quality, Kaffeeersatz 'coffee substitute' is a drink from something other than coffee beans, and Ersatzzug 'replacement train' performs a comparable service. The term for inferior substitute in German would be Surrogat, which is cognate to the English word "surrogate".

Historical examples

World War I

In the opening months of World War I, replacement troops for battle-depleted German infantry units were drawn from lesser-trained Ersatz Corps, which were less effective than the troops they replaced.

Another example of the word's usage in Germany exists in the German naval construction programs at the beginning of the 20th century. In this context, the phrasing "Ersatz (ship name)" indicates that a new, larger or more capable ship was a replacement for an ageing or lost vessel. Because German practice was not to reveal the name of a new ship until its launch, this meant that the ship was known by its "Ersatz (ship name)" throughout its construction. At the end of World War I, the last three ships of the planned of battlecruisers were redesigned and initially known simply as the , since the first ship was considered to be a replacement for the lost armored cruiser .

The Allied naval blockade of Germany limited maritime commerce with Germany, forcing Germany and Austria-Hungary to develop substitutes for products such as chemical compounds and provisions. More than 11,000 ersatz products were sold in Germany during the war. Patents for ersatz products were granted for 6000 varieties of beer, wine and lemonade; 1000 kinds of soup cubes; 837 types of sausage and 511 assortments of coffee.

Ersatz products developed in Germany and Austria-Hungary during this time included:

• synthetic rubber Kautschuk produced from petroleum for rubber
• benzene for heating oil (coal gas)
• industrial lubricants made by extracting oils from coal tar and brown-coal slags
• synthetic camphor for imported natural camphor
• nitrate crepe paper made from cellulose for gun cotton
• glycerin from sugar rather than fats
• gypsum-yielded sulphur
• pigeon guano used to make fertilizer
• flowers and weeds processed to make alcohol for ammunition
• rosins and gums extracted from coal derivatives
• tea composed of roasted barley, grasses, wild flowers, ground raspberry leaves or catnip
• coffee substitute using roasted acorns, chicory and beechnuts (stretched with caramel-flavoured raw sugar and beet flower later in the war)
• butter replaced by curdled milk, sugar and food colouring
• cooking oil replaced by a mixture of beets, carrots, turnips and spices
• salad oil was 99% mucilage
• eggs replaced by yellow-coloured corn or potato flour
• ground European beetles (cockchafers) and linden wood replaced fats
• sausage made of water, plant fibres, animal scraps and blood (the infamous 'war sausage' which was equated to 'a mouthful of sawdust')
• bouillon cubes made 70–90% of salt rather than meat extract
• wheat flour stretched by adding potato flour and powdered hay
• chocolates and cocoa replaced by ground cocoa shells and mixed pure pepper
• oil and sunflower 'cakes' replaced corn and oats as horse feed
• rapeseed, poppy and mustard 'cakes' replaced green feed for cattle
• paper, peat, reeds, bulrushes and free-growing stinging nettle fibres replaced cotton in textiles
• wood and paper used for shoe soles

Germany also stretched its supply of petrol with 'gasohol' (Benzolspiritus), which by today's standards would be classed as E25 petrol, consisting of 75% petrol and 25% distilled alcohol, likely ethanol.

World War II

In World War II, Ersatzbrot (substitute bread) made of potato starch, frequently stretched with extenders such as sawdust, was furnished to soldiers as Kommissbrot, a dark German bread baked from rye and other flours used for military rations, and also to prisoners of war. One recipe reportedly discovered in the "Food Providing Ministry" (Reichsnährstand) in Berlin, labeled "(Top Secret) Berlin 24.X1 1941", contained 50% bruised rye grain, 20% sliced sugar beets, 20% "tree flour" (sawdust), and 10% minced leaves and straw.

During the siege of Leningrad, its citizens were given ersatz flour instead of actual wheat flour (of which there was an extremely limited supply then) by the Soviet authorities. The lack of proper food with any nutrition meant that the city residents not only starved but became vulnerable to deadly illnesses and diseases (such as dysentery) owing to their weakened physical conditions. As a result, the word ersatz entered as a pejorative into Russian and other Slavic languages.

In Britain, this was additionally popularised as an adjective from the experiences of thousands of U.S., British, and other English-speaking combat personnel, primarily airmen, who were captured in the European Theater of Operations during World War II. These Allied prisoners of war were given ersatz goods such as Ersatzkaffee, an inferior Getreidekaffee or "grain coffee" as a coffee substitute by their German captors.

Eastern Bloc

In the Eastern Bloc, many agricultural goods could not be produced domestically, such as tea, coffee, nuts, and citrus fruits. These were generally imported from abroad with scarce foreign currency reserves, or inferior substitutes were produced domestically. In 1977, the East German coffee crisis resulted in the introduction of many coffee substitutes, which were generally rejected by the population. Replacements for orangeat and succade were made from candied carrot and unripe tomatoes.

Other

A study of conditions in the Southern United States during the American Civil War is called Ersatz in the Confederacy.

Effectiveness

When presented with a choice of ersatz, one tends to prefer the generic version of the brand rather than an entirely different product. Specifically one that most closely resembles the original and meets the same goal.

For instance, a person who desires a gourmet chocolate is more likely to choose another, less expensive chocolate as a substitute than a different kind of dessert or snack. Because such "within-category" substitutes are easier to compare to the desired good, however, those that are inferior are less effective than "cross-category" substitutes that fulfill the same goal. People are more able to notice their inferiority during consumption, which leads them to be less satisfying than goal-derived substitutes from different taxonomic categories.

During the First World War in Germany and Austria-Hungary, people succumbed to sickness from the consumption of ersatz goods. In Austria, the term "Vienna sickness" was coined after malnutrition from such goods was linked to a cause of the tuberculosis epidemic (10,000 reported cases).

In Germany, Princess Blücher suffered from influenza in 1916, suggesting that she was suffering from "ersatz illness". She writes: "everyone is feeling ill from too many chemicals in the hotel food. I don't believe that Germany will ever be starved out, but she will be poisoned out first with these substitutes."

References

References

1. Mises, Ludwig von. (1949). "Human Action".
2. (2012-08-31). "Ersatz - Definition and More from the Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary". Merriam-webster.com.
3. (1936). "Das unbekannte Heer. Frauen kampfen fur Deutschland 1914-1918". E.S. Mittler & Sohn.
4. (1997). "The First World War Germany and Austria-Hungary 1914-1918". Arnold.
5. Ganse, Alexander. (15 February 2002). "War Economies". World History at KMLA.
6. (28 July 1941). "Medicine: Feeding the Reichswehr".
7. "Life at Stalag VII A". [[University of Hawaiʻi]].
8. (2019). "Plants Go to War: A Botanical History of World War II". McFarland.
9. "The Liberation of Nordhausen Concentration Camp".
10. (2005-01-19). "Writing The Siege Of Leningrad: Women's Diaries, Memoirs, and Documentary Prose (Pitt Series in Russian and East European Studies)". University of Pittsburgh Press.
11. (22 April 1991). "Geheimsache Süßtafel". [[Der Spiegel]].
12. Massey, Mary Elizabeth. (1952). "Ersatz in the Confederacy: Shortages and Substitutes on the Southern Homefront". University of South Carolina.
13. (2016-06-01). "More Similar but Less Satisfying Comparing Preferences for and the Efficacy of Within- and Cross-Category Substitutes for Food". Psychological Science.
14. (1966). "The Passing of the Hapsburg Monarchy 1914-1918". University of Pennsylvania Press.
15. (1920). "An English Wife in Berlin: A Private Memoir of Events, Politics, and Daily Life in Germany throughout the War and the Social Revolution of 1918". E.P. Dutton.