Curse of the ninth

History

The curse of the ninth superstition originated in the late-Romantic period of classical music. According to Arnold Schoenberg, the superstition began with Gustav Mahler, who, after writing his Eighth Symphony, wrote Das Lied von der Erde, which, while structurally a symphony, was able to be disguised as a song cycle, each movement being a setting of a poem for soloist and orchestra. Then he wrote his Ninth Symphony and thought he had beaten the curse, but died with his Tenth Symphony incomplete.

This superstition, however, was only hatched by Mahler. Before him, Beethoven and Schubert had died before or while writing their tenth symphonies. Upon realizing this, Mahler created the curse of the ninth and led this superstition into popularity by seemingly proving it true. This superstition has, however, lost popularity, and while it is spoken about, any possible "proof" of it has not happened recently as it did in the era of Beethoven and Mahler. As Maddy Shaw Roberts writes, "The Curse of the Nine is a great story, and it probably fueled a lot of the angst behind Mahler's heart-wrenching symphonies. But perhaps it's best to treat it as a superstition."

After Beethoven, Schubert, and Mahler, some composers cited as examples of the curse include:

• Malcolm Arnold
• Kurt Atterberg
• Anton Bruckner (he completed 10 symphonies, but "Study Symphony" and "Symphony No.0" are not counted)
• Antonín Dvořák (only 5 of his symphonies were known during his lifetime)
• Alexander Glazunov
• David Maslanka
• Vincent Persichetti
• Einojuhani Rautavaara
• Luis Humberto Salgado
• Alfred Schnittke
• Roger Sessions
• Ralph Vaughan Williams
• Boris Tishchenko

In contrast, there are numerous composers who completed ten or more symphonies.

• Havergal Brian
• David Diamond
• Roy Harris
• Vagn Holmboe
• Rued Langgaard
• Andrzej Panufnik
• Allan Pettersson
• Edmund Rubbra
• William Schuman
• Robert Simpson
• Dmitri Shostakovich
• Emil Tabakov
• Heitor Villa-Lobos
• Mieczyslaw Weinberg

In 2012, composer Philip Glass stated, "Everyone is afraid to do a ninth. It is a jinx that people think about".

In popular culture

The curse of the ninth symphony was addressed in the sixth episode of the 19th season of the British crime series Midsomer Murders in 2018 and in the fifth episode of the ninth series of the British anthology series Inside No. 9, "Curse of the Ninth" (2024).

References

References

1. (17 October 2016). "The Curse of the Ninth Haunted These Composers {{!}} WQXR Editorial".
2. Ethan Mordden, ''A Guide to Orchestral Music: The Handbook for Non-Musicians''. New York: Oxford University Press (1980): 312. {{ISBN. 9780198020301. "Though it is more a song-cycle than a symphony, this was to have been Mahler's Ninth Symphony—but superstition cautioned him. Beethoven and Schubert both died after completing their respective Ninths, and Bruckner died with his Ninth unfinished. ... He thought he saw a way out: give his Ninth Symphony a name—no number—thus leaping the verge unscathed. He could then go on to a 'tenth' (really his Tenth). But fate laughed at Mahler, and he, like his predecessors, died before he could complete a Tenth Symphony."
3. Roberts, Maddy. (January 30, 2019). "What is the Curse of the Ninth - and does it really exist".
4. "What is the Curse of the Ninth – and does it really exist?". Classic FM.
5. (17 October 2016). "The Curse of the Ninth Haunted These Composers". New York Public Radio.
6. "Arnold Complete Symphonies". Mark Allen Group.
7. "Kurt Atterberg". Classical Net.
8. "Recordings by Alexander Konstantinovich Glazunov {{!}} Now available to stream and purchase at Naxos".
9. "Symphony No. 10: The River of Time". Maslanka Press.
10. "Recordings of Vincent Persichetti". Naxos Digital Services Ltd..
11. (12 October 2004). "Einojuhani Rautavaara".
12. Castiglione, Néstor. (2021-04-26). "luis humberto salgado — Interviews".
13. "Principal Works". The Roger Sessions Society.
14. "BORIS TISHCHENKO (1939-2010): Symphony No. 8 (World Premiere Recording), Concerto for Violin, Piano and String Orchestra, 3 Songs to Poems of Marina Tsvetayeva (arr. Leonid Rezetdinov [b.1961]).".
15. Guardian Staff. (2012-02-05). "Pass notes No 3,119: Curse of the ninth symphony".
16. Street, Joan. "The Curse Of The Ninth: Series 19, Episode 6".
17. "Inside No. 9 - Series 9: 5. Curse of the Ninth".