Constitutional court

History

Before establishment of independent constitutional court

Prior to 1919, the United States, Canada and Australia had adopted the concept of judicial review by their courts, following shared principles of their similar common law legal systems, which they, in turn, had inherited from British colonial law. The Parthenopean Republic's constitution of 1799, written by Mario Pagano, envisaged an organ of magistrates reviewing constitutional law, the eforato, but lasted only 6 months. The 1776 Constitution of Pennsylvania and 1777 Constitution of Vermont both establish a "Council of Censors" separate from the other branches of government, with the task of "recommending to the legislature the repealing of such laws as appear to them to have been enacted contrary to the principles of the constitution," an institution somewhat similar to a modern constitutional court.

After establishment of independent constitutional court

In 1919 the First Austrian Republic established the first dedicated constitutional court, the Constitutional Court of Austria, which however existed in name only until 10 October 1920, when the country's new constitution came into effect, upon which the court gained the power to review the laws of Austria's federal states. The 1920 Constitution of Czechoslovakia, which came into effect on 2 February 1920, was the first to provide for a dedicated court for judicial review of parliamentary laws, but the court did not convene until November 1921. The organization and competences of both courts were influenced by constitutional theories of Hans Kelsen. Subsequently, this idea of having a separate special constitutional court that only heard cases concerning the constitutionality of the national legislature's acts became known as the Austrian System, and it was subsequently adopted by many other countries e.g. Liechtenstein (1925), Greece (1927), Spain (1931), Germany (1949) etc.

National

Following list consists countries with separate constitutional courts. Some other countries do not have separate constitutional courts, but instead delegate constitutional judicial authority to their ordinary court system, with the final decision-making power resting in the supreme ordinary court. Nonetheless, such courts are sometimes also called "constitutional courts".

• Albania
• Angola
• Armenia
• Austria
• Azerbaijan
• Belarus
• Belgium
• Benin
• Bosnia and Herzegovina
• Bulgaria
• Myanmar
• Chad
• Chile
• Colombia
• Democratic Republic of the Congo
• Croatia
• Czech Republic
• Dominican Republic
• Ecuador
• Egypt
• Gabon
• Georgia
• Germany
• Guatemala
• Hungary
• Indonesia
• Iran
• Iraq
• Italy
• Jordan
• Kazakhstan
• Republic of Korea (South Korea)
• Kosovo
• Kuwait
• Kyrgyzstan
• Latvia
• Lebanon
• Lithuania
• Luxembourg
• Republic of North Macedonia
• Malta
• Moldova
• Mongolia
• Montenegro
• Niger
• Pakistan
• Peru
• Poland
• Portugal
• Romania
• Russia
• San Marino
• Serbia
• Singapore
• Slovakia
• Slovenia
• South Africa
• Spain
• Suriname
• Republic of China (Taiwan)
• Tajikistan
• Thailand
• Turkey
• Uganda
• Ukraine
• Uzbekistan
• Zambia
• Zimbabwe

Subnational

Germany

Source:

(German: Verfassungsgerichthof für das Land Baden-Württemberg; abbreviated: VerfGH BW) is the constitutional court for the German Land (state) of Baden-Württemberg and thereby a constitutional organ on the state level. Besides its power of judicial review (), it has a number of other powers and responsibilities which are assign to it by the .

Constitutional Court of Bavaria (German: Bayrischer Verfassungsgerichthof; abbreviated: VerfGH BY) is the state constitutional court for the Free State of Bavaria. It is, along with the Landesregierung (state government) and the Landtag (state parliament), one of the three state constitutional institutions and has the power of judicial review: It may examine the compatibility of state laws with the state constitution.

Constitutional Court of Berlin (German: Verfassungsgerichthof des Landes Berlin; abbreviated: VerfGH BE) is the constitutional court of the city-state of Berlin which is simultaneously the capital of the Federal Republic of Germany. It is located in the same building as the Kammergericht (Oberlandesgericht) and is authorized by Article 84 . It has the power of judicial review, the power to review electoral complaints and the power to hear cases concerning complaints against referendums and popular initiatives among others.

(German: Verfassungsgerichthof des Landes Brandenburg; abbreviated: VerfG BB)

(German: Staatsgerichtshof der Freien Hansestadt Bremen; abbreviated: StGH HB)

Constitutional Court of Hamburg (German: Hamburgisches Verfassungsgericht; abbreviated: VerfG HH)

State Constitutional Court of Hesse (StGH HE)

Land Constitutional Court of Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania (VerfG MV)

State Constitutional Court of Lower Saxony (StGH NDS)

Constitutional Court of North Rhine-Westphalia (German: Verfassungsgericht für das Land Nordrhein-Westfalen; abbreviated: VerfGH NRW or VGH NRW)

Constitutional Court of Rhineland-Palatinate (VerfGH RP)

Constitutional Court of Saarland (VerfGH SL)

Constitutional Court of the Free State of Saxony (VerfGH SN)

State Constitutional Court of Saxony-Anhalt (VerfG ST)

State Constitutional Court of Schleswig-Holstein (VerfG SH)

Thuringian Constitutional Court (VerfGH TH)

Russia

Before 2020, several republics of Russia had their own constitutional courts, while in other federal subjects like oblasts and federal cities they were known as charter courts, as republics are the only federal subjects to have their own constitutions. Constitutional and charter courts were completely independent and were not subordinate courts to the Constitutional Court of Russia.

Constitutional and charter courts used to hear cases relating to conformity with regional constitutions or charters of laws adopted by regional legislatures and governors' decrees, and in this category of cases constitutional and charter courts were courts of single instance.

Constitutional and charter courts of the federal subjects were disestablished by the 2020 amendments to the Constitution of Russia.

As of 2020, constitutional courts remained in force in the 12 (out of 22) following republics:

• Adygea (known as the Constitutional Chamber of Adygea until 2000)
• Bashkortostan
• Chechnya
• Dagestan
• Ingushetia
• Kabardino-Balkaria
• Karelia
• Komi
• Mari El
• North Ossetia–Alania
• Sakha
• Tatarstan (see Constitutional Court of Tatarstan)

In the republics of Buryatia and Tuva, the constitutional courts were abolished by the republican constitutional laws in 2018 and 2019, respectively. In the republics of Bashkortostan, Tatarstan, and Sakha, the disestablished constitutional courts were transformed into constitutional councils, without any judicial powers.

Until 2020, charter courts existed in following federal subjects:

• Kaliningrad Oblast
• Saint Petersburg
• Sverdlovsk Oblast

The charter court of Chelyabinsk Oblast was disestablished in 2014.

former Yugoslavia

In addition to the federal Constitutional Court of Yugoslavia, each of the six constituent republics established its own constitutional court with the promulgation of the 1963 Constitution. The 1974 constitutional reforms further introduced provincial constitutional courts within the Socialist Republic of Serbia, namely the Constitutional Court of Vojvodina and Constitutional Court of Kosovo. Following the breakup of Yugoslavia, the republican courts (those of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia and Slovenia) became the highest bodies of constitutional review in their respective successor states. The provincial constitutional courts in Serbia were abolished in 1990.

In the immediate aftermath of the country's dissolution, the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro) maintained separate subnational courts. However, following Montenegro's independence in 2006, Bosnia and Herzegovina remained the only state in the region with subnational constitutional courts: alongside the state-level Constitutional Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina, there are also the Constitutional Court of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Constitutional Court of Republika Srpska.

References

1. Dudley Odell McGovney, "The British Origin of Judicial Review of Legislation", ''University of Pennsylvania Law Review'' vol. 93, no. 1, 1–49.
2. (2015-05-01). "The political culture of the sister republics, 1794-1806: France, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and Italy". Amsterdam University Press.
3. "Vermont Constitution - 1777: Section XLIV". Vermont State Archives & Records Administration.
4. "Pennsylvania Constitution of 1776 | PHMC > Our Documentary Heritage".
5. "vfgh - Über den Verfassungsgerichtshof - Geschichte".
6. Romeu F.R., The Establishment of Constitutional Courts: A Study of 128 Democratic Constitutions, „Review of Law & Economics”, 2 (1), Washington, D.C.: CQ Press, 2006, p. 104.
7. (September 17, 2008). "U.S. Court Is Now Guiding Fewer Nations". The New York Times.
8. "Tribunal Constitucional".
9. "Суди конститутсионии Тоҷикистон".
10. "Bundesverfassungsgericht - International perspectives - Links to other courts".
11. "Zuständigkeiten".
12. "Bayerischer Verfassungsgerichtshof - Bayerisches Staatsministerium der Justiz".
13. (2023-02-01). "Verfassungsgerichtshof des Landes Berlin".
14. "Start {{!}} Verfassungsgericht des Landes Brandenburg".
15. "Startseite - Staatsgerichtshof der Freien Hansestadt Bremen".
16. "Hamburgisches Verfassungsgericht".
17. Viktor Ovsyukov. (25 April 2018). "Зачем Петербургу нужен Уставный суд, рассматривающий два дела в год".
18. (8 December 2020). "Путин подписал закон об увольнении судей за отказ от гражданства РФ".
19. (5 March 2021). "Уставный суд Петербурга ликвидируют 1 июля".
20. (July 2022). "Уставный суд Свердловской области прекратил работу".
21. Kirill Antonov. (2021-12-15). "И суда нет. Парламент Татарстана готовится к ликвидации Конституционного суда". [[Kommersant]].
22. "Становление органов конституционного правосудия в республиках северного кавказа - Сейчас.ру".
23. link. (19 October 2018 - Constitutional Court of the Republic of Ingushetia. Official website)
24. [http://ksrk.karelia.ru/?page_id=133 Law of the Republic of Karelia from 7 July 2004 No. 790-ZRK "On the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Carelia"]
25. [http://www.sakha.gov.ru/main.asp?c=5409 Constitutional Law of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia) from 15 June 2002 No. 16-z N 363-II "On the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia)"]
26. (24 March 2015). "КС РФ разрешил окончательно упразднить Конституционный суд Бурятии".
27. Kirill Antonov. (2022-10-20). "Суд удаляется из совещания. Госсовет Татарстана внес законопроект об упразднении конституционного суда республики". [[Kommersant]].
28. (2022-10-20). "Госсовет Татарстана проголосовал за ликвидацию Конституционного суда республики". Idel.Realities.
29. (2022-10-20). "Госсовет РТ ликвидировал Конституционный суд республики — вместо него будет совет". Business Online.
30. (2003). "Ustavni sud Republike Srbije: 1963-2003. godina". [[Constitutional Court (Serbia)]].