Bee

Evolution

The immediate ancestors of bees were stinging wasps in the family Ammoplanidae, which were predators of other insects. The switch from insect prey to pollen may have resulted from the consumption of prey insects which were flower visitors and were partially covered with pollen when they were fed to the wasp larvae. This same evolutionary scenario may have occurred within the vespoid wasps, where the pollen wasps evolved from predatory ancestors.

Based on phylogenetic analysis, bees are thought to have originated during the Early Cretaceous (about 124 million years ago) on the supercontinent of West Gondwana, just prior to its breakup into South America and Africa. The supercontinent is thought to have been a largely xeric environment at this time; modern bee diversity hotspots are also in xeric and seasonal temperate environments, suggesting strong niche conservatism among bees ever since their origins.

Genomic analysis indicates that despite only appearing much later in the fossil record, all modern bee families had already diverged from one another by the end of the Cretaceous. The Melittidae, Apidae, and Megachilidae had already evolved on the supercontinent prior to its fragmentation. Further divergences were facilitated by West Gondwana's breakup around 100 million years ago, leading to a deep Africa-South America split within both the Apidae and Megachilidae, the isolation of the Melittidae in Africa, and the origins of the Colletidae, Andrenidae and Halictidae in South America. The rapid radiation of the South American bee families is thought to have followed the concurrent radiation of flowering plants within the same region. Later in the Cretaceous (80 million years ago), colletid bees colonized Australia from South America (with an offshoot lineage evolving into the Stenotritidae), and by the end of the Cretaceous, South American bees had also colonized North America. The North American fossil taxon Cretotrigona belongs to a group that is no longer found in North America, suggesting that many bee lineages went extinct during the Cretaceous–Paleogene extinction event (the "K-Pg extinction").

Following the K-Pg extinction, surviving bee lineages continued to spread into the Northern Hemisphere, colonizing Europe from Africa by the Paleocene, and then spreading east to Asia. This was facilitated by the warming climate around the same time, allowing bees to move to higher latitudes following the spread of tropical and subtropical habitats. By the Eocene (~45 mya) there was already considerable diversity among eusocial bee lineages. A second extinction event among bees is thought to have occurred due to rapid climatic cooling around the Eocene-Oligocene boundary, leading to the extinction of some bee lineages such as the tribe Melikertini. During the Paleogene and Neogene periods, bee lineages expanded worldwide. This came about as continental drift and changing climates created new barriers and habitats, isolating populations and driving the evolution of many new tribes.

Fossils

The oldest non-compression bee fossil is Cretotrigona prisca, a corbiculate bee of Late Cretaceous age (~70 mya) found in New Jersey amber. A fossil from the early Cretaceous (~100 mya), Melittosphex burmensis, was initially considered "an extinct lineage of pollen-collecting Apoidea sister to the modern bees", but subsequent research has rejected the claim that Melittosphex is a bee, or even a member of the superfamily Apoidea to which bees belong, instead treating the lineage as incertae sedis within the Aculeata.

The Allodapini (within the Apidae) appeared around 53 Mya. The Colletidae appear as fossils only from the late Oligocene (~25 Mya) to early Miocene. The Melittidae are known from Palaeomacropis eocenicus in the Early Eocene. The Megachilidae are known from trace fossils (characteristic leaf cuttings) from the Middle Eocene. The Andrenidae are known from the Eocene-Oligocene boundary, around 34 Mya, of the Florissant shale. The Halictidae first appear in the Early Eocene with species found in amber. The Stenotritidae are known from fossil brood cells of Pleistocene age.

Coevolution

The earliest animal-pollinated flowers were shallow, cup-shaped blooms pollinated by insects such as beetles, so the syndrome of insect pollination was well established before bees evolved. Bees represent a further step in this process, being specialized for pollination through behavioral and physical traits that specifically enhance the task and make them the most efficient pollinating insects. In a process of coevolution, flowers developed floral rewards such as nectar and longer tubes, and bees developed longer tongues to extract the nectar. The appearance of these structures drove the adaptive radiation of the angiosperms, and, in turn, bees themselves. Bees and certain mites have indeed coevolved, with some bee species evolving specialized structures called acarinaria that serve as lodgings for mites, demonstrating a mutualistic relationship. Mites residing in these acarinaria can benefit their bee hosts by eating fungi that attack pollen and brood, leading to reduced fungal contamination and improved bee survivorship.

Phylogeny

External

Molecular phylogeny was used by Debevic et al, 2012, to demonstrate that the bees (Anthophila) arose from deep within the Crabronidae sensu lato, which was thus rendered paraphyletic. In their study, the placement of the monogeneric Heterogynaidae was uncertain. The small family Mellinidae was not included in this analysis.

Further studies by Sann et al., 2018, elevated the subfamilies (plus one tribe and one subtribe) of Crabronidae sensu lato to family status. They also recovered the placement of Heterogyna within Nyssonini and sunk Heterogynaidae. The newly erected family, Ammoplanidae, formerly a subtribe of Pemphredoninae, was recovered as the most sister family to bees.

Internal

This cladogram of the bee families is based on Hedtke et al., 2013, which places the former families Dasypodaidae and Meganomiidae as subfamilies inside the Melittidae. English names, where available, are given in parentheses.

Characteristics

Bees differ from closely related groups such as wasps by having branched or plume-like setae (hairs), combs on the forelimbs for cleaning their antennae, small anatomical differences in limb structure, and the venation of the hind wings. In females, the seventh dorsal abdominal plate is also divided into two half-plates.

Bees have the following characteristics:

• A pair of large compound eyes which cover much of the surface of the head. Between and above these are three small simple eyes (ocelli) which provide information on light intensity.
• The antennae usually have 13 segments in males and 12 in females, and are geniculate, having an elbow joint part way along. They house large numbers of sense organs that can detect touch (mechanoreceptors), smell and taste; and small, hairlike mechanoreceptors that can detect air movement so as to "hear" sounds.
• The mouthparts are adapted for both chewing and sucking by having both a pair of mandibles and a long proboscis for sucking up nectar.
• The thorax has three segments, each with a pair of robust legs, and a pair of membranous wings on the hind two segments. The front legs of corbiculate bees bear combs for cleaning the antennae. In many species the hind legs bear pollen baskets, flattened sections with incurving hairs to secure the collected pollen. The wings are synchronized in flight, and the somewhat smaller hind wings connect to the forewings by a row of hooks along their margin which connect to a groove in the forewing.
• The abdomen has nine segments, the hindermost three being modified into the sting.
• Many bees are brightly colored, displaying contrasting bands of yellow, orange, or red against black. These colors function as aposematic signals, warning potential predators that the insect may sting or otherwise defend itself, although similar warning patterns are also seen in many harmless insects that mimic bees or wasps, a form of Batesian mimicry.

The largest species of bee is thought to be Wallace's giant bee Megachile pluto, whose females can attain a length of 39 mm. The smallest species may be dwarf stingless bees in the tribe Meliponini whose workers are less than 2 mm in length.

Sociality

Haplodiploid breeding system

According to inclusive fitness theory, an organism can increase its evolutionary success not only by increasing its own offspring, but also by helping close relatives reproduce. In genetic terms, cooperation is favored when the cost to the helper is less than the product of relatedness and benefit. This condition is more easily met in haplodiploid species such as bees, where the genetic relationships create strong incentives for cooperative behavior.

Haplodiploidy alone does not explain the evolution of eusociality. Some eusocial species such as termites are not haplodiploid. Conversely, many haplodiploid species, including most bees, are not eusocial, and even among eusocial bees, queens often mate with several males, producing half sisters that share only about a quarter of their genes. However, since single mating appears to be the ancestral condition in all eusocial lineages studied so far, haplodiploidy may still have played an important role in the early evolution of eusocial behaviour in bees.

Eusociality

Bees may be solitary or may live in various types of community. Eusociality appears to have arisen independently at least three times in halictid bees. The most advanced of these form eusocial colonies; these are characterized by cooperative brood care and a division of labour into reproductive and non-reproductive adults, with overlapping generations. This division of labour creates specialized groups within eusocial societies, called castes. In some species, groups of cohabiting females are sisters. If these sisters share a division of labour, the group is described as semisocial. When the group instead includes a mother (the queen) and her daughters (the workers), it is considered eusocial. If the castes differ only in behavior and size, as in many paper wasps, the system is primitively eusocial. When the castes show clear morphological differences, the system is described as highly eusocial.

True honey bees (genus Apis, with eight species) are highly eusocial, and are among the best known insects. Their colonies are established by swarms, consisting of a queen and several thousand workers. There are 29 subspecies of one of these species, Apis mellifera, native to Europe, the Middle East, and Africa. Africanized bees are a hybrid strain of A. mellifera that escaped from experiments involving crossing European and African subspecies; they are extremely defensive.

Stingless bees are also highly eusocial. They practice mass provisioning, with complex nest architecture and perennial colonies also established via swarming.

Many bumblebees are eusocial, similar to the eusocial Vespidae such as hornets in that the queen initiates a nest on her own rather than by swarming. Bumblebee colonies typically have from 50 to 200 bees at peak population, which occurs in mid to late summer. Nest architecture is simple, limited by the size of the pre-existing nest cavity, and colonies rarely last more than a year. In 2011, the International Union for Conservation of Nature set up the Bumblebee Specialist Group to review the threat status of all bumblebee species worldwide using the IUCN Red List criteria.

There are many more species of primitively eusocial than highly eusocial bees, but they have been studied less often. Most are in the family Halictidae, or "sweat bees". Colonies are typically small, with a dozen or fewer workers, on average. Queens and workers differ only in size, if at all. Most species have a single season colony cycle, even in the tropics, and only mated females hibernate. A few species have long active seasons and attain colony sizes in the hundreds, such as Halictus hesperus. Some species are eusocial in parts of their range and solitary in others, or have a mix of eusocial and solitary nests in the same population. The orchid bees (Apidae) include some primitively eusocial species with similar biology. Some allodapine bees (Apidae) form primitively eusocial colonies, with progressive provisioning: a larva's food is supplied gradually as it develops, as is the case in honey bees and some bumblebees.

Solitary and communal bees

Most other bees, including familiar insects such as carpenter bees, leafcutter bees and mason bees are solitary in the sense that every female is fertile, and typically inhabits a nest she constructs herself. There is no division of labor, so these nests lack queens and worker bees. Solitary bees typically produce neither honey nor beeswax. Bees collect pollen to feed their young, and have the necessary adaptations to do this. However, certain wasp species such as pollen wasps have similar behaviours, and a few species of bee scavenge from carcasses to feed their offspring.

Most solitary bees are fossorial, digging nests in the ground in a variety of soil textures and conditions, while others create nests in hollow reeds or twigs, or holes in wood. The female typically creates a compartment (a "cell") with an egg and some provisions for the resulting larva, then seals it off. A nest may consist of numerous cells. When the nest is in wood, usually the last (those closer to the entrance) contain eggs that will become males. The adult does not provide care for the brood once the egg is laid, and usually dies after making one or more nests. The males typically emerge first and are ready for mating when the females emerge. Solitary bees are very unlikely to sting (only in self-defense, if ever), and some (esp. in the family Andrenidae) are stingless.

While solitary, females each make individual nests. Some species, such as the European mason bee Hoplitis anthocopoides, and the Dawson's Burrowing bee, Amegilla dawsoni, are gregarious, preferring to make nests near others of the same species, and giving the appearance of being social. Large groups of solitary bee nests are called aggregations, to distinguish them from colonies. In some species, multiple females share a common nest, but each makes and provisions her own cells independently. This type of group is called "communal" and is not uncommon. The primary advantage appears to be that a nest entrance is easier to defend from predators and parasites when multiple females use that same entrance regularly.

File:Megachile rotundata.JPG|A leafcutting bee, Megachile rotundata, cutting circles from acacia leaves File:Anthidium February 2008-1.jpg|A solitary bee, Anthidium florentinum (family Megachilidae), visiting Lantana File:Osmia cornifrons.5.1.08.w.jpg|The mason bee Osmia cornifrons nests in a hole in dead wood. Bee "hotels" are often sold for this purpose.

Biology

Life cycle

The life cycle of both solitary and social bees involves the laying of an egg, the development through several moults of a legless larva, a pupa in which the insect undergoes complete metamorphosis, and the emergence of a winged adult. Most solitary bees and bumble bees in temperate climates overwinter as adults or pupae and emerge in spring when increasing numbers of flowering plants come into bloom. The males usually emerge first and search for females with which to mate. Like the other members of Hymenoptera, bees are haplodiploid; the sex of a bee is determined by whether or not the egg is fertilized. After mating, a female stores the sperm, and determines which sex is required at the time each individual egg is laid, fertilized eggs producing female offspring and unfertilized eggs, males. Tropical bees may have several generations in a year and no resting diapause stage

The egg is generally oblong, slightly curved and tapering at one end. Solitary bees, lay each egg in a separate cell with a supply of mixed pollen and nectar next to it. This may be rolled into a pellet or placed in a pile and is known as mass provisioning. Social bee species provision progressively, that is, they feed the larva regularly while it grows. The nest varies from a hole in the ground or in wood, in solitary bees, to a substantial structure with wax combs in bumblebees and honey bees.

In most species, bee larvae are whitish grubs, roughly oval and bluntly-pointed at both ends. They have 15 segments and spiracles in each segment for breathing. They have no legs but move within the cell, helped by tubercles on their sides. They have short horns on the head, jaws for chewing food and an appendage on either side of the mouth tipped with a bristle. There is a gland under the mouth that secretes a viscous liquid which solidifies into the silk they use to produce a cocoon. The cocoon is semi-transparent and the pupa can be seen through it. Over the course of a few days, the larva undergoes metamorphosis into a winged adult. When ready to emerge, the adult splits its skin dorsally and climbs out of the exuviae and breaks out of the cell.

File:Apoidea.jpg|Nest of common carder bumblebee, wax canopy removed to show winged workers and pupae in irregularly placed wax cells File:Carpenter Bee Galleries.jpeg|Carpenter bee nests in a cedar wood beam (sawn open) File:Bienen mit Brut 2.jpg|Honeybees on brood comb with eggs and larvae in cells

Flight

In the 1930s, calculations based on the aerodynamics of fixed wings appeared to show that insect flight was impossible, with results taken from equations meant for aircraft to wings that beat rapidly through short arcs. The author of the study remarked that "one should not be surprised that the results of the calculations do not square with reality," but this comment was later taken out of context and gave rise to the myth that "the bumblebee should not be able to fly."

In fact, those early models were never suited to describe how insects fly. Studies later showed that bees and many other insects produce lift through swirling vortices that form along the leading edge of the wing. High-speed imaging and robotic wing experiments confirmed that lift in bees results from rapid wing reversals and high wing-beat frequency, which together sustain the airflow needed to stay in the air.

File:Apis mellifera flying.jpg|Honeybee in flight carrying pollen in pollen basket File:HoneyBeeFlying.webm|thumbtime=115|Honey bee on Geranium (cultivar Rozanne) and flying. Second portion taken at 12,000 frames per second with 60 frames shown per second.

Navigation, communication, and finding food

The ethologist Karl von Frisch showed that honey bees communicate by the waggle dance, a pattern of movement that informs other workers about the direction and distance to food. He showed that honey bees use the sun as their main compass but can still locate its position on cloudy days by reading the polarization pattern of skylight. They use spatial memory with a "rich, map-like organization".

Digestion

The gut of bees is relatively simple, but multiple metabolic strategies exist in the gut microbiota. Pollinating bees consume nectar and pollen, which require different digestion strategies by somewhat specialized bacteria. While nectar is a liquid of mostly monosaccharide sugars and so easily absorbed, pollen contains complex polysaccharides: branching pectin and hemicellulose. Approximately five groups of bacteria are involved in digestion. Three groups specialize in simple sugars (Snodgrassella and two groups of Lactobacillus), and two other groups in complex sugars (Gilliamella and Bifidobacterium). Digestion of pectin and hemicellulose is dominated by bacterial clades Gilliamella and Bifidobacterium respectively. Bacteria that cannot digest polysaccharides obtain enzymes from their neighbors, and bacteria that lack certain amino acids do the same, creating multiple ecological niches.

Although most bee species eat nectar and pollen, some do not. The vulture bees in the genus Trigona, consume carrion and the immature stages of wasps, turning meat into a honey-like substance. Bees drink guttation drops from leaves for energy and nutrients.

Ecology

Floral relationships

Most bees are generalists, collecting pollen from a range of flowering plants. Some are specialists, gathering pollen only from one or a few species or genera of closely related plants. Some genera in Melittidae and Apidae are highly specialized for collecting plant oils as well as or instead of nectar; they mix the oils with pollen to feed their larvae. Male orchid bees in some species gather aromatic compounds from orchids, which is one of the few cases where male bees are effective pollinators. All bees are able to detect desirable flowers by recognizing ultraviolet patterning on flowers, and by floral odors. Bumblebees can in addition detect flowers' electromagnetic fields. Once landed, a bee uses nectar quality

In rare cases, a plant species may only be effectively pollinated by a single bee species; some plants are endangered in part because their pollinator is threatened. Such specialist bees are however strongly associated with common, widespread plants visited by multiple pollinator species. For example, in the arid southwestern United States, the creosote bush (Larrea tridentata) supports more than forty bee species that specialize in collecting its pollen.

As mimics and models

Main article: Mimicry, Batesian mimicry, Müllerian mimicry

Many bees are aposematically colored, typically orange and black, warning of their ability to defend themselves with a powerful sting. As such they are models for Batesian mimicry by non-stinging insects such as bee-flies, robber flies and hoverflies, all of which gain a measure of protection by superficially looking and behaving like bees.

Bees are themselves Müllerian mimics of other aposematic insects with the same color scheme, including wasps, lycid and other beetles, and many butterflies and moths (Lepidoptera) which are themselves distasteful, often through acquiring bitter and poisonous chemicals from their plant food. All the Müllerian mimics, including bees, benefit from the reduced risk of predation that results from their easily recognized warning coloration.

Bees are mimicked by plants such as the bee orchid which imitates both the appearance and the scent of a female bee; male bees attempt to mate (pseudocopulation) with the furry lip of the flower, thus pollinating it.

File:Bombylius major on flower.jpg|The bee-fly Bombylius major, a Batesian mimic of bees, taking nectar and pollinating a flower File:Ophrys apifera flower1.jpg|Bee orchid lures male bees to attempt to mate with the flower's lip, which resembles a bee perched on a pink flower.

As brood parasites

Main article: Brood parasite, Nest usurpation

Brood parasites occur in several bee families including the apid subfamily Nomadinae. Females of these species lack pollen collecting structures (the scopa) and do not construct their own nests. They typically enter the nests of pollen collecting species, and lay their eggs in cells provisioned by the host bee. When the "cuckoo" bee larva hatches, it consumes the host larva's pollen ball, and often the host egg also. In particular, the Arctic species of Bumblebee, Bombus hyperboreus, is an aggressive brood parasite that invades and enslaves colonies of other bumblebees within the same subgenus, Alpinobombus. Unlike most socially parasitic bumblebees, which have lost the ability to collect pollen, B. hyperboreus retains functional pollen baskets and has been observed gathering pollen and nectar in the field. This retention of foraging ability may be an adaptation to the severe Arctic climate, in which the short breeding season and limited availability of host colonies favor flexibility and a degree of metabolic self-reliance.

In Southern Africa, hives of African honeybees (A. mellifera scutellata) are being destroyed by parasitic workers of the Cape honeybee, A. m. capensis. These lay diploid eggs ("thelytoky"), escaping normal worker policing, leading to the colony's destruction; the parasites can then move to other hives.

The cuckoo bees in the Bombus subgenus Psithyrus are closely related to, and resemble, their hosts in looks and size. This common pattern gave rise to the ecological principle "Emery's rule". Others parasitize bees in different families, like Townsendiella, a nomadine apid, two species of which are cleptoparasites of the dasypodaid genus Hesperapis, while the other species in the same genus attacks halictid bees.

Nocturnal bees

Four bee families (Andrenidae, Colletidae, Halictidae, and Apidae) contain some species that are crepuscular. Most are tropical or subtropical, but some live in arid regions at higher latitudes. These bees have greatly enlarged ocelli, which are extremely sensitive to light and dark, though incapable of forming images. Some have refracting superposition compound eyes: these combine the output of many elements of their compound eyes to provide enough light for each retinal photoreceptor. Their ability to fly by night enables them to avoid many predators, and to exploit flowers that produce nectar only or also at night.

Predators, parasites and pathogens

Vertebrate predators of bees include bee-eaters, shrikes and flycatchers, which make short sallies to catch insects in flight. Swifts and swallows fly almost continually, catching insects as they go. The honey buzzard attacks bees' nests and eats the larvae. The greater honeyguide interacts with humans by guiding them to the nests of wild bees. The humans break open the nests and take the honey and the bird feeds on the larvae and the wax. Among mammals, predators such as the badger dig up bumblebee nests and eat both the larvae and any stored food.

Specialist ambush predators of visitors to flowers include crab spiders, which wait on flowering plants for pollinating insects; predatory bugs, and praying mantises, some of which (the flower mantises of the tropics) wait motionless, aggressive mimics camouflaged as flowers. Beewolves are large wasps that habitually attack bees; the ethologist Niko Tinbergen estimated that a single colony of the beewolf Philanthus triangulum might kill several thousand honeybees in a day: all the prey he observed were honeybees. Other predatory insects that sometimes catch bees include robber flies and dragonflies. Honey bees are affected by parasites including tracheal and Varroa mites. However, some bees are believed to have a mutualistic relationship with mites.

Some mites of the genus Tarsonemus are associated with bees. They live in bee nests and ride on adult bees for dispersal. They are presumed to feed on fungi, nest materials or pollen. However, the impact they have on bees remains uncertain.

File:Pair of Merops apiaster feeding detail.jpg|The bee-eater, Merops apiaster, specializes in feeding on bees; here a male catches a nuptial gift for his mate. File:Wasp and bee August 2008-2.jpg|The beewolf Philanthus triangulum paralysing a bee with its sting

Exposure to chemical stressors

Bees are exposed to a wide range of chemical stressors, both natural and synthetic, though their relative impacts differ sharply. Comparative toxicological studies indicate that synthetic insecticides, such as neonicotinoids, are 1,000 to 10,000 times more acutely toxic to honeybees than commonly encountered natural alkaloids such as nicotine and caffeine, which are among the most thoroughly studied plant secondary metabolites.

Insecticides remain the most damaging chemical stressor for bees. Neonicotinoids such as Imidacloprid, Clothianidin, and Thiamethoxam interfere with navigation, thermoregulation, and immune responses even at sub-lethal concentrations. Long-term exposure reduces colony growth, foraging success, and queen survival in both laboratory and field conditions. Following EFSA's 2018 risk assessment, outdoor agricultural uses of these active ingredients were banned throughout the European Union. Other synthetic insecticides, including organophosphates and pyrethroids, as well as some fungicide mixtures, act synergistically with parasites and pathogens such as Varroa destructor, a parasitic mite of honeybees, and Nosema ceranae, compounding the physiological stress on colonies. Industrial emissions and road traffic release traces of heavy metals such as cadmium, lead, and zinc, which can accumulate in hive products and bee tissues. These metals induce oxidative stress, developmental abnormalities and altered foraging behaviour. These substances are much less acutely toxic than insecticides, however their persistence and the fact that they are found everywhere results in chronic exposure that weakens immunity and increases disease susceptibility.

A minority of flowering plants produce secondary metabolites that can become toxic to pollinators when concentrated. Alkaloids, saponins and glycosides in species such as Aesculus californica (California buckeye) and Rhododendron spp. (grayanotoxins) can deter feeding or cause mortality. However, because their occurrence is sporadic and seasonal, natural floral toxins rarely affect colonies at a population level.

Chemical stressors affecting pollinators are best characterized by their acute and sublethal toxicity as well as ecological impact. In this way, synthetic insecticides consistently present the greatest risk across meta-analyses, followed by fungicides and certain industrial pollutants. Natural floral toxins (plant secondary metabolites) are typically sublethal. As well, they rarely drive population declines and are minor in impact compared to anthropogenic chemicals.

Overall, synthetic agrochemicals (particularly insecticides and some fungicides) and industrial pollutants remain the dominant chemical drivers of pollinator decline,whereas the majority of natural floral toxins have sublethal impacts that do not generally contribute to major population-level effects.

Relationship with humans

In mythology and folklore

Main article: Bees in mythology

Homer's Hymn to Hermes describes three bee-maidens with the power of divination and thus speaking truth, and identifies the food of the gods as honey. Sources associated the bee maidens with Apollo and, until the 1980s, scholars followed Gottfried Hermann (1806) in incorrectly identifying the bee-maidens with the Thriae. Honey, according to a Greek myth, was discovered by a nymph called Melissa ("Bee"); and honey was offered to the Greek gods from Mycenean times. Bees were also associated with the Delphic oracle and the prophetess was sometimes called a bee.

The image of a community of honey bees has been used from ancient to modern times, in Aristotle and Plato; in Virgil and Seneca; in Erasmus and Shakespeare; Tolstoy, and by political and social theorists such as Bernard Mandeville and Karl Marx as a model for human society. In English folklore, bees would be told of important events in the household, in a custom known as "Telling the bees". Honey bees, signifying immortality and resurrection, were royal heraldic emblems of the Merovingians, revived by Napoleon.

In art and literature

Some of the oldest examples of bees in art are rock paintings in Spain which have been dated to 15,000 BC.

W. B. Yeats's poem The Lake Isle of Innisfree (1888) contains the couplet "Nine bean rows will I have there, a hive for the honey bee, / And live alone in the bee loud glade." At the time he was living in Bedford Park in the West of London. Beatrix Potter's illustrated book The Tale of Mrs Tittlemouse (1910) features Babbity Bumble and her brood (pictured). Kit Williams' treasure hunt book The Bee on the Comb (1984) uses bees and beekeeping as part of its story and puzzle. Sue Monk Kidd's The Secret Life of Bees (2004), and the 2009 film starring Dakota Fanning, tells the story of a girl who escapes her abusive home and finds her way to live with a family of beekeepers, the Boatwrights.

Bees have appeared in films such as Jerry Seinfeld's animated Bee Movie, or Eugene Schlusser's A Sting in the Tale (2014). The playwright Laline Paull's fantasy The Bees (2015) tells the tale of a hive bee named Flora 717 from hatching onwards.

Beekeeping

Main article: Beekeeping

Humans have kept honey bee colonies, commonly in hives, for millennia. Simple hives and smoke were used.

Among Classical Era authors, beekeeping with the use of smoke is described in Aristotle's History of Animals Book 9. The account mentions that bees die after stinging; that workers remove corpses from the hive, and guard it; castes including workers and non-working drones, but "kings" rather than queens; predators including toads and bee-eaters; and the waggle dance, with the "irresistible suggestion" of άροσειονται ("aroseiontai", it waggles) and παρακολουθούσιν ("parakolouthousin", they watch). Beekeeping is described in detail by Virgil in his Georgics; it is mentioned in his Aeneid, and in Pliny's Natural History.

From the 18th century, European understanding of the colonies and biology of bees allowed the construction of the moveable comb hive so that honey could be harvested without destroying the colony.

File:Beekeeper.jpg|A commercial beekeeper at work File:Western honey bee on a honeycomb.jpg|Western honey bee on a honeycomb

As commercial pollinators

Bees play an important role in pollinating flowering plants, and are the major type of pollinator in many ecosystems that contain flowering plants. It is estimated that one third of the human food supply depends on pollination by insects, birds and bats, most of which is accomplished by bees, whether wild or domesticated.

Since the 1970s, there has been a general decline in the species richness of wild bees and other pollinators, probably attributable to stress from increased parasites and disease, the use of pesticides, and a decrease in the number of wild flowers. Climate change probably exacerbates the problem. This is a major cause of concern, as it can cause biodiversity loss and ecosystem degradation as well as increase climate change.

Contract pollination has overtaken the role of honey production for beekeepers in many countries. After the introduction of Varroa mites, feral honey bees declined dramatically in the US, though their numbers have since recovered. The number of colonies kept by beekeepers declined slightly, through urbanization, systematic pesticide use, tracheal and Varroa mites, and the closure of beekeeping businesses. In 2006 and 2007 the rate of attrition increased, and was described as colony collapse disorder. In 2010 invertebrate iridescent virus and the fungus Nosema ceranae were shown to be in every killed colony, and deadly in combination. Winter losses increased to about 1/3. Varroa mites were thought to be responsible for about half the losses.

Apart from colony collapse disorder, losses outside the US have been attributed to causes including pesticide seed dressings, using neonicotinoids such as clothianidin, imidacloprid and thiamethoxam. From 2013 the European Union restricted some pesticides to stop bee populations from declining further. In 2014 the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report warned that bees faced increased risk of extinction because of global warming. In 2018 the European Union decided to ban field use of all three major neonicotinoids; they remain permitted in veterinary, greenhouse, and vehicle transport usage.

Farmers have focused on alternative solutions to mitigate these problems. By raising native plants, they provide food for native bee pollinators like Lasioglossum vierecki and L. leucozonium, leading to less reliance on honey bee populations.

File:Peponapis pruinosaCane-12.JPG|Squash bees (Apidae) are important pollinators of squashes and cucumbers. File:A bee covered with pollen.jpg|A mason bee (Osmia sp.) covered in pollen File:Bee migration 9045 (cropped).JPG|US migratory commercial beekeeper moving many hives of spring bees from South Carolina to Maine for blueberry pollination

As food producers

Honey is a natural product produced by bees and stored for their own use, but its sweetness has always appealed to humans. Before domestication of bees was even attempted, humans were raiding their nests for their honey. Smoke was often used to subdue the bees and such activities are depicted in rock paintings in Spain dated to 15,000 BC. Honey bees are used commercially to produce honey.

As food

Bees are considered edible insects. People in some countries eat insects, including the larvae and pupae of bees, mostly stingless species. They also gather larvae, pupae and surrounding cells, known as bee brood, for consumption. In the Indonesian dish botok tawon from Central and East Java, bee larvae are eaten as a companion to rice, after being mixed with shredded coconut, wrapped in banana leaves, and steamed.

Bee brood (pupae and larvae) although low in calcium, has been found to be high in protein and carbohydrate, and a useful source of phosphorus, magnesium, potassium, and trace minerals iron, zinc, copper, and selenium. In addition, while bee brood was high in fat, it contained no fat soluble vitamins (such as A, D, and E) but it was a good source of most of the water-soluble B vitamins including choline as well as vitamin C. The fat was composed mostly of saturated and monounsaturated fatty acids with 2.0% being polyunsaturated fatty acids.

File:Botoktawon.jpg|Bee larvae as food in the Javanese dish botok tawon File:Fried bees dish.jpg|Fried whole bees served in a Ukrainian restaurant

As alternative medicine

Apitherapy is a branch of alternative medicine that uses honey bee products, including raw honey, royal jelly, pollen, propolis, beeswax and apitoxin (Bee venom). The claim that apitherapy treats cancer, which some proponents of apitherapy make, remains unsupported by evidence-based medicine.

Stings

The painful stings of bees are mostly associated with the poison gland and the Dufour's gland which are abdominal exocrine glands containing various chemicals. In Lasioglossum leucozonium, the Dufour's Gland mostly contains octadecanolide as well as some eicosanolide. There is also evidence of n-triscosane, n-heptacosane, and 22-docosanolide.

Notes

References

References

1. (October 2006). "The history of early bee diversification based on five genes plus morphology". [[PNAS]].
2. (2016). "Safeguarding pollinators and their values to human well-being". [[Nature (journal).
3. Grüter, Christoph. (2020). "Stingless Bees: Their Behaviour, Ecology and Evolution". Springer New York.
4. (2018). "Phylogenomic analysis of Apoidea sheds new light on the sister group of bees". [[BMC Evolutionary Biology]].
5. (2023-08-21). "The evolutionary history of bees in time and space". [[Current Biology]].
6. Engel, Michael S.. (2001). "Monophyly and Extensive Extinction of Advanced Eusocial Bees: Insights from an Unexpected Eocene Diversity". [[PNAS]].
7. (February 2010). "Re-evaluation of alleged bees' nests from the Upper Triassic of Arizona". [[Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology]].
8. (2011). "The Antiquity and Evolutionary History of Social Behavior in Bees". [[PLOS One]].
9. (2006). "A fossil bee from Early Cretaceous Burmese amber". [[Science (journal).
10. (2021). "Apoid wasps (Hymenoptera: Apoidea) from mid-Cretaceous amber of northern Myanmar". [[Cretaceous Research]].
11. (28 August 2012). "The Impact of Molecular Data on Our Understanding of Bee Phylogeny and Evolution". [[Annual Review of Entomology]].
12. (2012). "Biogeography and diversification of colletid bees (Hymenoptera: Colletidae): emerging patterns from the southern end of the world". [[Journal of Biogeography]].
13. (2007). "The oldest fossil of a melittid bee (Hymenoptera: Apiformes) from the early Eocene of Oise (France)". [[Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society]].
14. (2008). "A Leafcutter Bee Trace Fossil from the Middle Eocene of Patagonia, Argentina, and a Review of Megachilid (Hymenoptera) Ichnology". [[Palaeontology (journal).
15. (2014). "A new interpretation of the bee fossil Melitta willardi Cockerell (Hymenoptera, Melittidae) based on geometric morphometrics of the wing". [[ZooKeys]].
16. (2003). "An Early Eocene bee (Hymenoptera: Halictidae) from Quilchena, British Columbia". [[The Canadian Entomologist]].
17. (1995). "''Neocorynura electra'', a New Fossil Bee Species from Dominican Amber (Hymenoptera:Halictidae)". [[Journal of the New York Entomological Society]].
18. (2000). "Classification of the bee tribe Augochlorini (Hymenoptera, Halictidae)". [[Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History]].
19. (1987). "Fossil brood cells of stenotritid bees (Hymenoptera: Apoidea) from the Pleistocene of South Australia". [[Transactions of the Royal Society of South Australia]].
20. Armbruster, W. Scott. (2012). "Evolution of Plant-Pollinator Relationships". [[Cambridge University Press]].
21. (2000). "The Bees of the World". Johns Hopkins University Press.
22. (2012). "The Forgotten Pollinators". Island Press.
23. (June 2009). "Cleaner Mites: Sanitary Mutualism in the Miniature Ecosystem of Neotropical Bee Nests". [[The American Naturalist]].
24. (June 2007). "Museum Specimens And Phylogenies Elucidate Ecology's Role in Coevolutionary Associations Between Mites And Their Bee Hosts". [[Evolution (journal).
25. (2012). "Identifying the sister group to the bees: a molecular phylogeny of Aculeata with an emphasis on the superfamily Apoidea". [[Zoologica Scripta]].
26. (2018). "Phylogenomic analysis of Apoidea sheds new light on the sister group of bees.". [[BMC Evolutionary Biology]].
27. (2013). "The bee tree of life: a supermatrix approach to apoid phylogeny and biogeography". [[BMC Evolutionary Biology]].
28. (2005). "Evolution of the Insects". Cambridge University Press.
29. (19 June 2014). "Anatomy of the Honey Bee". Extension.
30. (2018). "Avoiding Attack: The Evolutionary Ecology of Crypsis, Warning Signals, and Mimicry". [[Oxford University Press]].
31. (2012). "The relationship between morphological and behavioral mimicry in hoverflies (Diptera: Syrphidae)". [[The American Naturalist]].
32. Messer, A. C.. (1984). "''Chalicodoma pluto'': The World's Largest Bee Rediscovered Living Communally in Termite Nests (Hymenoptera: Megachilidae)". [[Journal of the Kansas Entomological Society]].
33. (1974). "Oviposition Behavior of Two Dwarf Stingless Bees, ''Hypotrigona'' (''Leurotrigona'') ''muelleri'' and ''H.'' (''Trigonisca'') ''duckei'', with Notes on the Temporal Articulation of Oviposition Process in Stingless Bees". Journal of the Faculty of Science [[Hokkaido University]] Series Vi. Zoology.
34. (2008). "Ancestral Monogamy Shows Kin Selection is Key to the Evolution of Eusociality". [[Science (journal).
35. Hamilton, W. D.. (20 March 1964). "The Genetical Evolution of Social Behaviour II". [[Journal of Theoretical Biology]].
36. (2014). "The Insects: An Outline of Entomology". Wiley Blackwell.
37. Nowak, Martin. (2010). "The evolution of eusociality". [[Nature (journal).
38. (May 2008). "Ancestral Monogamy Shows Kin Selection Is Key to the Evolution of Eusociality". American Association for the Advancement of Science.
39. (2006). "Recent and simultaneous origins of eusociality in halictid bees". [[Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences]].
40. Wilson, Edward O. (1971). "The Insect Societies". Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
41. Michener, Charles Duncan. (1974). "The Social Behavior of the Bees: A Comparative Study". [[Harvard University Press]].
42. (2006). "The Africanized Honey Bee in the Americas: A Biological Revolution with Human Cultural Implications". Apis Enterprises.
43. (2006). "Stingless bee nesting biology". Apidologie.
44. "Bumblebee nests". Bumblebee Conservation Trust.
45. "Bumblebee Specialist Group: 2011 Update". [[IUCN]].
46. (1983). "A Halictine bee with distinct castes: ''Halictus hesperus'' (Hymenoptera: Halictidae) and its bionomics in Central Panama". Sociobiology.
47. (1996). "Solitary behavior in a high-altitude population of the social sweat bee Halictus rubicundus (Hymenoptera: Halictidae)". [[Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology]].
48. (1993). "Environmental effects on male production and social structure in ''Halictus rubicundus'' (Hymenoptera: Halictidae)". [[Insectes Sociaux]].
49. Michener, Charles Duncan. (1974). "The Social Behavior of the Bees: A Comparative Study". [[Harvard University Press]].
50. (1 October 1980). "Management of Wild Bees". Beesource Beekeeping Community.
51. "Solitary Bees (Hymenoptera)". Royal Entomological Society.
52. "Other bees". Bumblebee Conservation Trust.
53. Westreich, Lila. (May 2020). "Spring signals female bees to lay the next generation of pollinators".
54. (1975). "Gregarious Nesting of the Mason Bee Hoplitis anthocopoides and the Evolution of Parasitism and Sociality Among Megachilid Bees". [[Evolution (journal).
55. Alcock, John. (1 May 1999). "The Nesting Behavior of Dawson's Burrowing Bee, Amegilla dawsoni (Hymenoptera: Anthophorini), and the Production of Offspring of Different Sizes". [[Journal of Insect Behavior]].
56. Roubik, David W.. (1992). "Ecology and Natural History of Tropical Bees". [[Cambridge University Press]].
57. "The bumblebee lifecycle". [[Bumblebee Conservation Trust]].
58. "Learning About Honey Bees". The South Carolina Mid-State Beekeepers Association.
59. "Solitary Bees". [[National Bee Unit]].
60. Shuckard, William Edward. (1866). "British bees: an introduction to the study of the natural history and economy of the bees indigenous to the British Isles". L. Reeve & Co..
61. Magnan, Antoine. (1934). "Le vol des insectes". Hermann et Cie.
62. Eberhardt, Frederick. (2007). "Why Do Bees Fly? The Myth and the Mathematics". [[University of Cambridge]].
63. (1996). "Leading-edge vortices in insect flight". [[Nature (journal).
64. Maxworthy, T.. (1981). "The fluid dynamics of insect flight". [[Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics]].
65. (1999). "Wing rotation and the aerodynamic basis of insect flight". [[Science (journal).
66. (2011). "Insect Flight". [[Current Biology]].
67. von Frisch, Karl. (1953). "The Dancing Bees". Harcourt, Brace & World.
68. (2005). "Honey bees Navigate According to a Map-Like Spatial Memory". [[PNAS]].
69. "How honey bee gut bacteria help to digest their pollen-rich diet".
70. "Bee gut microbes have a division of labor when it comes to metabolizing complex polysaccharides".
71. (December 2019). "Division of labor in honey bee gut microbiota for plant polysaccharide digestion". [[PNAS]].
72. (February 2004). "Predatory behavior in a necrophagous bee Trigona hypogea (Hymenoptera; Apidae, Meliponini)". [[Naturwissenschaften]].
73. (30 September 2020). "Plant guttation provides nutrient-rich food for insects". [[Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences]].
74. Waser, Nickolas M.. (2006). "Plant-Pollinator Interactions: From Specialization to Generalization". [[University of Chicago Press]].
75. (2010). "The evolution and loss of oil-offering flowers: New insights from dated phylogenies for angiosperms and bees". Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences.
76. (2012). "Pollen and Pollination". Springer Science & Business Media.
77. (2016). "Mechanosensory hairs in bumblebees (Bombus terrestris) detect weak electric fields". [[PNAS]].
78. (2016). "Bees use the taste of pollen to determine which flowers to visit". [[Biology Letters]].
79. (1975). "The principal Larrea bees of the southwestern United States (Hymenoptera, Apoidea)". [[Smithsonian Contributions to Zoology]].
80. (1983). "Bumble Bees and Cuckoo Bumble Bees of California (Hymenoptera, Apidae)". University of California Press.
81. (1940). "Adaptive Coloration in Animals". Oxford University Press.
82. "Bee Orchids and Insect Mimicry". Natural History Museum.
83. "Obligate Brood Parasitism". Aculeata Research Group.
84. "Brood Parasitism". Amateur Entomologists' Society.
85. Milliron, H. E.. (1966). "Bumblebees from northern Ellesmere Island, with observations on usurpation by ''Megabombus hyperboreus'' (Schönh.) (Hymenoptera: Apidae)". [[The Canadian Entomologist]].
86. (2018). "The cephalic labial gland secretions of two socially parasitic bumblebees ''Bombus hyperboreus'' and ''B. inexspectatus'' question the chemical insignificance hypothesis". Insect Science.
87. (2019). "Pollinators on the polar edge of the Ecumene: taxonomy, phylogeography, and ecology of bumble bees from Novaya Zemlya". [[ZooKeys]].
88. (2014). "The Insects: An Outline of Entomology". [[Wiley-Blackwell]].
89. (1991). "Biology and Larvae of the Cleptoparasitic Bee ''Townsendiella pulchra'' and Nesting Biology of its Host ''Hesperapis larreae'' (Hymenoptera, Apoidea)". [[American Museum Novitates]].
90. (1987). "An Annotated Catalog of the Halictid Bees of the Western Hemisphere (Hymenoptera, Halictidae)". [[Smithsonian Institution Press]].
91. (June 2008). "Seeing in the dark: vision and visual behaviour in nocturnal bees and wasps". [[The Journal of Experimental Biology]].
92. (26 September 2013). "Hornet attacks kill dozens in China". The Guardian.
93. Friedmann, Herbert. (1955). "The Honey-Guides". [[Bulletin of the United States National Museum]].
94. "What predators do bumblebees have?". [[Bumblebee Conservation Trust]].
95. (28 May 2001). "Cognitive Ecology of Pollination: Animal Behaviour and Floral Evolution". [[Cambridge University Press]].
96. (30 November 2013). "Found! First Known Predator To Lure Prey By Mimicking Flowers". LiveScience.
97. Tinbergen, Niko. (1958). "Curious Naturalists". [[Methuen Publishing.
98. "Honey Bee Disorders: Honey Bee Parasites". University of Georgia.
99. "Tarsonemus {{!}} Bee Mite ID".
100. Johnson, Reed M.. (2015-01-07). "Honey Bee Toxicology". [[Annual Review of Entomology]].
101. (2016). "Sub-lethal effects of dietary neonicotinoid insecticide exposure on honey bee queen fecundity and colony development". [[Scientific Reports]].
102. Woodcock, Ben A.. (2016). "Impacts of neonicotinoid use on long-term population changes in wild bees in England". [[Nature Communications]].
103. (2015). "Bee declines driven by combined stress from parasites, pesticides, and lack of flowers". [[Science (journal).
104. (2018-05-30). "Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/783 of 29 May 2018". [[Official Journal of the European Union]].
105. (2018-05-30). "Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/784 of 29 May 2018". Official Journal of the European Union.
106. (2018-05-30). "Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/785 of 29 May 2018". Official Journal of the European Union.
107. Tadei, Riccardo. (2025). "Co-exposure to a honeybee pathogen and an insecticide: synergistic effects in a solitary bee host but not in ''Apis mellifera''". Proceedings of the Royal Society B.
108. Potts, Simon G.. (2016). "Safeguarding pollinators and their values to human well-being". Nature.
109. (July 2012). "Spatial and temporal variation of metal concentrations in adult honeybees (Apis mellifera L.)". [[Environmental Monitoring and Assessment]].
110. (2001). "Honeybees and their products as bioindicators of environmental contamination". Environmental Monitoring and Assessment.
111. Mărgăoan, Rodica D.. (2024). "Environmental pollution effect on honey bees and their derived products: a comprehensive analysis". [[Life (journal).
112. Vanbergen, A. J.. (2013). "Threats to an ecosystem service: pressures on pollinators". Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment.
113. (1993). "Attraction, deterrence or intoxication of bees (''Apis mellifera'') by plant allelochemicals". Chemoecology.
114. (2022-05-19). "Artificial Intelligence-Aided Meta-Analysis of Toxicological Assessment of Agrochemicals in Bees". [[Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution]].
115. Johnson, Reed M.. (2015-01-07). "Honey Bee Toxicology". [[Annual Review of Entomology]].
116. (2022-05-19). "Artificial Intelligence-Aided Meta-Analysis of Toxicological Assessment of Agrochemicals in Bees". [[Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution]].
117. Johnson, Reed M.. (2015-01-07). "Honey Bee Toxicology". [[Annual Review of Entomology]].
118. (2019-12-10). "Fungicides, herbicides and bees: A systematic review of existing research and methods". [[PLOS One]].
119. Susan Scheinberg, "The Bee Maidens of the Homeric ''Hymn to Hermes''", in Albert Heinrichs, ed., ''Harvard Studies in Classical Philology'' (Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, 1980), 11. {{ISBN. 0674379306; and many others since questioning Gottfried Hermann's 1806 equation of the ''Thriae'' with bee-maidens. Heinrich Gottfried, ''Homeri nomine dignissimum''/Homeric Hymns (Leipzig: 1806), 346 and cxiii. Many took Hermann's unfounded identification at face-value, repeating it ''ad nauseam'', e.g. Hilda M. Ransome, ''The Sacred Bee in Ancient Times and Folklore'' (NY: Courier, 1937; reprinted as recently as NY: Dover, 2012), 97. {{ISBN. 0486122980
120. Scheinberg, Susan. (1979). "The Bee Maidens of the Homeric Hymn to Hermes". [[Harvard Studies in Classical Philology]].
121. Wilson, Bee. (2004). "The Hive: the Story of the Honeybee". [[John Murray (publishing house).
122. Roud, Steve. (6 April 2006). "The Penguin Guide to the Superstitions of Britain and Ireland". [[Penguin Books]].
123. [http://www.napoleon.org/en/essential_napoleon/symbols/index.asp Eagle and the bee on the Napoleonic coat of arms]
124. (12 March 2008). "Encyclopaedia of the History of Science, Technology, and Medicine in Non-Western Cultures". [[Springer Science+Business Media.
125. "Yeats in Bedford Park". ChiswickW4.com.
126. "Bee Movie".
127. (21 May 2014). "The Bees by Laline Paull review – a fantasy with a sting in its tail". The Guardian.
128. (6 April 2003). "Ancient Egypt: Bee-keeping".
129. (23 February 2008). "Beekeeping in Ancient Egypt". Bee Lore.
130. Bodenheimer, F. S.. (1960). "Animal and Man in Bible Lands". Brill Archive.
131. (1910). "The Works of Aristotle". Clarendon Press.
132. (October 1956). "Cambridge University Press and The Classical Association are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Greece & Rome. Virgil and the Bees: A Study in Ancient Apicultural Lor". [[Greece and Rome]].
133. Thomas Wildman, ''A Treatise on the Management of Bees'' (London, 1768, 2nd edn 1770).
134. (2012). "A 17th Century Testimony on the Use of Ceramic Top-bar Hives". Bee World.
135. (25 October 2006). "Pollinators help one-third of world's crop production, says new study". UC Berkeley.
136. Connor, Steve. (16 June 2015). "Wild bees just as important as domesticated bees for pollinating food crops". [[The Independent]].
137. (2015). "Bee declines driven by combined stress from parasites, pesticides, and lack of flowers". [[Science (journal).
138. "Why bees are climate heroes".
139. (2006). "Feral honey bees in southern Arizona, 10 years after varroa infestation". American Bee Journal.
140. (2016). "Africanization of a feral honey bee (Apis mellifera) population in South Texas: does a decade make a difference?". [[Ecology and Evolution]].
141. (29 January 2007). "Honey Bee Die-Off Alarms Beekeepers, Crop Growers and Researchers". Pennsylvania State University College of Agricultural Sciences.
142. Johnson, Kirk (6 October 2010) [https://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/07/science/07bees.html Scientists and Soldiers Solve a Bee Mystery] {{webarchive. link. (7 October 2010 {{cbignore. ''[[The New York Times]]''.)
143. Eban, Katherine. (8 October 2010). "What a scientist didn't tell the New York Times about his study on bee deaths". CNN.
144. (6 October 2010). "Iridovirus and Microsporidian Linked to Honey Bee Colony Decline". [[PLOS One]].
145. [https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/1545516/Honey-bees-in-US-facing-extinction.html "Honey bees in US facing extinction"] {{webarchive. link. (6 September 2008 , ''[[The Daily Telegraph]]'' (London), 14 March 2007.)
146. Benjamin, Alison (2 May 2010) [https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2010/may/02/food-fear-mystery-beehives-collapse Fears for crops as shock figures from America show scale of bee catastrophe] {{webarchive. link. (4 December 2013 . ''[[The Observer]]'' (London).)
147. (12 May 2008). "Beekeepers Report Continued Heavy Losses From Colony Collapse Disorder". Sciencedaily.com.
148. (22 May 2012). "Hiver fatal pour la moitié des colonies d'abeilles en Suisse". Radio Télévision Suisse.
149. Storkstad, Erik. (30 March 2012). "Field Research on Bees Raises Concern About Low-Dose Pesticides". [[Science (journal).
150. (20 September 2012). "EFSA identifies risks to bees from neonicotinoids". [[European Food Safety Authority]].
151. (30 April 2013). "EU moves to protect bees". 3 News NZ.
152. Gosden, Emily (29 March 2014) [https://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/earthnews/10730667/Bees-and-the-crops-they-pollinate-are-at-risk-from-climate-change-IPCC-report-to-warn.html Bees and the crops they pollinate are at risk from climate change, IPCC report to warn] {{webarchive. link. (29 August 2014 ''The Daily Telegraph'' (London). Retrieved 30 March 2014)
153. (27 April 2018). "EU agrees total ban on bee-harming pesticides". [[The Guardian]].
154. Kuehn, Faith. (2011). "Farming for native bees".
155. Adamson, Nancy Lee. [http://www.step-project.net/NPDOCS/Adamson_NL_D_2011.pdf An Assessment of Non-Apis Bees as Fruit and Vegetable Crop Pollinators in Southwest Virginia] {{webarchive. link. (20 November 2015. Diss. 2011. Web. 15 October 2015.)
156. (7 April 1915). "Honey and Its Uses in the Home". US Department of Agriculture, Farmers' Bulletin, No. 653.
157. Holland, Jennifer. (14 May 2013). "U.N. Urges Eating Insects: 8 Popular Bugs to Try". National Geographic.
158. "Botok Tempe Tahu Teri (Botok Tempe Tofu Anchovy)". Tasty Indonesian Food.
159. (6 December 2013). "Sensasi Rasa Unik Botok Lebah yang Menyengat". Sayangi.com.
160. Fink, Mark D.. (2007). "Nutrient Composition of Bee Brood and its Potential as Human Food". Ecology of Food and Nutrition.
161. Jensen, Annette Bruun. (2016). "Standard methods for Apis mellifera brood as human food". Journal of Apicultural Research.
162. "What is apitherapy?". MedicineWorld.Org.
163. (2011). "The Complete Guide to Complementary Therapies in Cancer Care: Essential Information for Patients, Survivors and Health Professionals". World Scientific.
164. (2009). "American Cancer Society Complete Guide to Complementary and Alternative Cancer Therapies". American Cancer Society.
165. (1978). "Chemistry of the dufour's gland secretion of halictine bees". [[Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology B]].
166. (1982). "Systematic relationship of halictinae bees based on the pattern of macrocyclic lactones in the Dufour gland secretion". Insect Biochemistry.