Axis of evil

Origins

David Frum

The phrase was attributed to former Bush pro-Israel speechwriter David Frum, originally as the axis of hatred and then evil. Information about his authorship first came out when emails of Frum's wife to friends were picked up by the media. Frum explained his rationale for creating the phrase axis of evil in his 2003 book The Right Man: The Surprise Presidency of George W. Bush. According to Frum, in late December 2001 head speechwriter Michael Gerson gave him the assignment of articulating the case for dislodging the regime of Saddam Hussein in Iraq in only a few sentences for the upcoming State of the Union address. Frum says he began by rereading President Franklin D. Roosevelt's "date which will live in infamy" speech given on December 8, 1941, after the Japanese surprise attack on Pearl Harbor. While Americans needed no convincing about going to war with Japan, Roosevelt saw the greater threat to the United States coming from Nazi Germany, and he had to make the case for fighting a two-ocean war.

Frum points in his book to a now often-overlooked sentence in Roosevelt's speech which reads in part, "...we will not only defend ourselves to the uttermost but will make very certain that this form of treachery shall never endanger us again." Frum interprets Roosevelt's oratory like this: "For FDR, Pearl Harbor was not only an attack—it was a warning of future and worse attacks from another, even more dangerous enemy." Japan, a country with one-tenth of America's industrial capacity, a dependence on imports for its food, and already engaged in a war with China, was extremely reckless to attack the United States, a recklessness "that made the Axis such a menace to world peace", Frum says. Saddam Hussein's two wars, against Iran and Kuwait, were just as reckless, Frum decided, and therefore presented the same threat to world peace.

In his book Frum relates that the more he compared the Axis powers of World War II to modern "terror states", the more similarities he saw. "The Axis powers disliked and distrusted one another", Frum writes. "Had the Axis somehow won the war, its members would quickly have turned on one another." Iran, Iraq, al-Qaeda, and Hezbollah, despite quarreling among themselves, "all resented power of the West and Israel, and they all despised the humane values of democracy." There, Frum saw the connection: "Together, the terror states and the terror organizations formed an axis of hatred against the United States."

Frum tells that he then sent off a memo with the above arguments and also cited some of the atrocities perpetrated by the Iraqi government. He expected his words to be chopped apart and altered beyond recognition, as is the fate of much presidential speechwriting, but his words were ultimately read by Bush nearly verbatim, though Bush changed the term axis of hatred to axis of evil. North Korea was added to the list, he says, because it was attempting to develop nuclear weapons, had a history of reckless aggression, and "needed to feel a stronger hand".

Yossef Bodansky

A decade before the 2002 State of the Union address, in August 1992, the Israeli-American political scientist Yossef Bodansky wrote a paper entitled "Tehran, Baghdad & Damascus: The New Axis Pact"{{cite web

2002 State of the Union Address

Main article: Iraq–United States relations, Iran–United States relations during the G.W. Bush administration, North Korea–United States relations, Iraq–Iran relations, North Korea–Iran relations, Iraq–North Korea relations

In his 2002 State of the Union Address, Bush called North Korea "A regime arming with missiles and weapons of mass destruction, while starving its citizens." He also stated Iran "aggressively pursues these weapons and exports terror, while an unelected few repress the Iranian people's hope for freedom." Bush gave the most criticism to Iraq, stating "Iraq continues to flaunt its hostility toward America and to support terror. The Iraqi regime has plotted to develop anthrax and nerve gas and nuclear weapons for over a decade. This is a regime that has already used poison gas to murder thousands of its own citizens, leaving the bodies of mothers huddled over their dead children. This is a regime that agreed to international inspections, then kicked out the inspectors. This is a regime that has something to hide from the civilized world." Afterwards, Bush said, "States like these and their terrorist allies constitute an axis of evil, arming to threaten the peace of the world."

Bolton: "Beyond the Axis of Evil"

On May 6, 2002, then-Undersecretary of State John Bolton gave a speech entitled "Beyond the Axis of Evil". In it he added three more nations to be grouped with the already mentioned rogue states: Cuba, Libya, and Syria. The criteria for inclusion in this grouping were: "state sponsors of terrorism that are pursuing or who have the potential to pursue weapons of mass destruction (WMD) or have the capability to do so in violation of their treaty obligations."

China, Russia, Iran, North Korea new axis

In February 2022, American conservative political commentator Danielle Pletka called China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea as the "new" axis of evil in an article for the National Review. Following the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine, the Taipei Times published an editorial calling the alliance between Russia and China "the real axis of evil".

In October 2023, Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell told CBS' "Face The Nation" that Iran, North Korea, Russia, and China are the new "axis of evil. The Speaker of the House, Mike Johnson, echoed a very similar comment on Fox News' "Hannity".

In October 2023, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu described an axis of evil involving Hamas and Iran in an op-ed in The Wall Street Journal.

In January 2024, NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg and his predecessor, Anders Fogh Rasmussen, cautioned about the formation of a new axis of autocracies led by China, but joined by Russia, Iran and North Korea. The same states have been recognized as a new axis of evil by several American politicians, including Christopher Cavoli, Mike Johnson, and Mitch McConnell.

On April 17, 2024, GOP U.S. speaker of the house Mike Johnson referred to China as part of "the axis of evil" that also includes Iran and Russia. Johnson based his statement on the belief that the countries pose threats the western-aligned countries of Taiwan, Israel, and Ukraine. This preceded a change of tact, where the speaker decided to support $95 billion of defence aid for the combined countries, despite the opposition of the more conservative members of his caucus.

In July 2024, British Army General Sir Patrick Sanders said that Russia, China and Iran were the "new axis powers" in an interview with The Times. He argued they posed more of a threat than Nazi Germany in 1939, stating "They are more interdependent and more aligned than the original axis powers were" and that the world is facing "as dangerous a moment as any time that we've had since 1945". On July 23, newly appointed Army chief General Sir Roland Walker said in a speech that the UK faced danger from an "axis of upheaval" with threats from an angered Russia, that China was intent on retaking Taiwan, and that Iran was likely to pursue nuclear weapons.

Criticism

Iran and Iraq fought the long Iran–Iraq War in the 1980s under basically the same leadership as that which existed at the time of Bush's speech, leading some to believe that the linking of the nations under the same banner was misguided. Others argued that each of the three nations in the "axis of evil" had some special characteristics which were obscured by grouping them together. Anne Applebaum wrote about the debate over North Korea's inclusion in the group.

In the days after the September 11 attacks, Ryan Crocker — who would later become the United States ambassador to Iraq from 2007 to 2009 — and other senior U.S. State Department officials flew to Geneva to meet secretly with representatives of the government of Iran. For several months, Crocker and his Iranian counterparts cooperated on capturing Al Qaeda operatives in the region and fighting the Taliban government in Afghanistan. These meetings stopped after the "Axis of Evil" speech hardened Iranian attitudes toward cooperating with the U.S.

Also, immediately after the attacks, the Iranian President Mohammad Khatami—in a message to the American people—showed sympathy with the victims and the Iranian people took to mosques and streets to pray and show their condolences. None of the terrorists involved in 9/11 were citizens of the three nations Bush cited.

Other axes

In January 2006, Israeli Defense Minister Shaul Mofaz implicated "the axis of terror that operates between Iran and Syria" following a suicide bomb in Tel Aviv.

In April 2006 the phrase axis of terror earned more publicity. Israel's UN Ambassador, Dan Gillerman, cautioned of a new axis of terror—Iran, Syria and the Hamas-run Palestinian government; Gillerman repeated the term before the UN over the crisis in Lebanon. Some three months later Israeli senior foreign ministry official Gideon Meir branded the alleged alliance an axis of terror and hate.

In 2006, Isaias Afewerki, the president of Eritrea, had declared in response to the deteriorating relations with the neighboring countries of Ethiopia, Sudan and Yemen by accusing them of being an "Axis of Belligerence."

In 2006, the former president of Venezuela, Hugo Chávez, described the so-called New Latin Left as an "axis of good" which comprised Bolivia, Chile, Cuba, Ecuador, Nicaragua, Uruguay and Venezuela but described "Washington and its allies" as an "axis of evil".

In 2007, the commander of Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps declared that the United States, the United Kingdom and Israel were part of an "axis of evil" alleging mass violence against the Islamic world, crimes against humanity and attempting to divide Shi'ites and Sunnis.

In 2008, The Economist featured an article about the "Axis of Diesel" in reference to a burgeoning alliance of Iran, Russia, and Venezuela. They cite the billions of dollars in arms sales to Venezuela and the construction of Iranian nuclear facilities as well as the rejection of added sanctions on Iran. They did conclude that the benefits of the arrangement were exaggerated, however.

From 2010 onward, the term "Axis of Resistance" has been used to describe an anti-Western and anti-Israeli alliance between Iran, Syria, Hezbollah, Iraqi Shia militias, and the Houthis.

In 2012, author William C. Martel, in a short essay for The Diplomat, wrote of an "Authoritarian Axis", comprising China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, Syria, and Venezuela. Following the death of Venezuela's Hugo Chávez in 2013, Martel removed Venezuela from the assigned list of countries, in his subsequent writings about the "axis". Martel's thesis drew criticism from The American Conservative and Muslim Village, with the main arguments cited in opposition to his idea being the lack of cohesion and generally low levels of cooperation shown between the cited countries.

Several environmental non-governmental organizations, including Greenpeace and the Green Party of Canada, have dubbed Australia, Canada and United States, the "Axis of Environmental Evil" because of their lack of support for international environmental agreements, particularly those related to climate change.

During a March 2018 interview with the Egyptian media, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman referred Iran, Turkey and Islamist organizations such as the Islamic State and the Muslim Brotherhood as the "triangle of evil", to describe their current policies in the Middle East. Those remarks were later dismissed by Iran, describing it as "childish" and said that Saudi Arabia's intervention in Yemen has "caused instability and extremism and stuck in a quagmire" in Yemen.

In October 2018, the economist Paul Krugman tweeted, "[t]here's a new axis of evil: Russia, Saudi Arabia—and the United States", the three countries that declined to endorse the United Nation's latest climate study at the 2018 United Nations Climate Change Conference.

Media's use of the term

Parodies

Various related pun phrases include:

• Axis of weasels – mocking certain countries that did not support the 2003 invasion of Iraq
• Axis of Eve – a women's political action group that opposed Bush through satirical expression
• Asses of evil – a mocking insult against George W. Bush, Dick Cheney and John Ashcroft
• Axles of evil – denouncing sport utility vehicles for their poor fuel efficiency, and several other variations
• Coalition of the drilling – mocking the 'coalition of the willing', stating the possible goal behind the "willing" in getting access to oil
• "Axes of Evil" – the title of a song by the Canadian heavy metal band 3 Inches of Blood and the title of a book about Billy the Axeman
• The Axis of Awesome – an Australian musical comedy act

The term has also lent itself to various parodies, including the following:

• In a Saturday Night Live skit with host Jonny Moseley, George W. Bush played by Will Ferrell expands the "Axis of Evil" (although he doesn't mention North Korea, instead saying "one of the Koreas") to include things with "evil" in it or things he does not understand (including Enron, Tom Daschle, the economy, France, those who "mess with Texas", the "original Axis of Evil", mathematics, Dick Cheney (for now), and Evel Knievel, with the exception of Dr. Evil). Ferrell mispronounces "axis" so it sounds like "Access of Evil".
• Serj Tankian, lead singer for the group System of a Down and Tom Morello, guitarist and former guitarist for Rage Against the Machine and Audioslave (respectively) founded a political action group called the Axis of Justice.
• Andrew Marlatt wrote an extensive parody for SatireWire, where Libya, China, and Syria formed the "Axis of Just as Evil" and other countries "rushed to gain triumvirate status" in a "game of geopolitical chairs".
• The Economist ran a 2006 (May 13–19) cover headline titled "Axis of Feeble" about the end of the George Bush–Tony Blair partnership.
• King Dedede, a character from the Kirby series, refers to the titular character as an "axis of evil" in an episode of the Japanese version of the anime.
• In the Top Gear Middle East Special, during a road trip through Syria, Jeremy Clarkson installs an "axle of evil" to make his Mazda MX-5 a six-wheeled vehicle.
• In Total Drama Presents: The Ridonculous Race, Sanders refers to the super-team composed of the Ice Dancers, the Police Cadets and the Haters as an "axis of evil". Don laters coins them as such (to the displeasure of Ryan) and liking the sound of it, they form an alliance with the intent of backstabbing each other, though it later falls apart.

Comedy tour

In response to the problems which Americans of Middle-Eastern descent have in the current climate, a group of comedians have banded together to form the Axis of Evil Comedy Tour. The comedians, Ahmed Ahmed (from Egypt), Maz Jobrani (from Iran), and Aron Kader (whose father is Palestinian), have created a show which aired on Comedy Central. They have also included half-Palestinian, half-Italian Dean Obeidallah in some of their acts.

The group took the comedy tour around the Middle East (November–December 2007), performing in the UAE, Egypt, Kuwait, Jordan, and Lebanon to sell-out crowds.

Lullabies

In 2003 the Norwegian record label Kirkelig Kulturverksted published the CD Lullabies from the Axis of Evil containing 14 lullabies from Iran, Iraq, North Korea, Palestine, Syria, Afghanistan and Cuba. Every lullaby is presented in its original form sung by women from these countries, and then a western version with interpretations in English.

Other

• Holidays in the Axis of Evil is a documentary by BBC.
• Literature from the "Axis of Evil"
• Behind Enemy Lines II: Axis of Evil is a direct to video film.
• Empire of Evil (documentary film)
• Team America: World Police comedy film
• In Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance, after Operation Tecumseh, commentators label even allied Pakistan as a member of the axis of evil.
• The song "Axis Of Evil" by "Sodom" in their self-titled album Sodom.

References

References

1. Tucker, Jonathan B.. (November 1, 2009). "The Rollback of Libya's Chemical Weapons Program". The Nonproliferation Review.
2. (February 5, 2024). "Axis of Resistance revived: A new turn in the US-Iran conflict, what's next?".
3. "The Axis of Evil: From Rhetoric to Reality". Bloomberg.com.
4. [https://www.theguardian.com/bush/story/0,7369,658724,00.html "Proud wife turns 'axis of evil' speech into a resignation letter"] {{Webarchive. link. (November 10, 2021 , Matthew Engel, ''[[The Guardian]]'', February 27, 2002)
5. Borger, Julian. (January 28, 2003). "How I created the axis of evil". The Guardian.
6. [http://www.slate.com/id/2076552/ "Axis of Evil" Authorship Settled! It was Frum and Gerson, and definitely not Bush.] January 9, 2003. {{webarchive. link. (February 6, 2008)
7. Rapoza, Kenneth. "On Syria, Putin Becomes 'Man Of Reason'".
8. "State of the Union Address (January 29, 2002)". Miller Center.
9. Poole, Steven. (June 24, 2020). "'Axis of adults': are the White House staff working together to keep Trump in line?". The Guardian.
10. John R. Bolton. (May 6, 2002). "Beyond the Axis of Evil: Additional Threats from Weapons of Mass Destruction".
11. (February 12, 2022). "China's Olympics Are at the Center of a New Axis of Evil".
12. (March 16, 2022). "EDITORIAL: Real 'axis of evil' revealed".
13. (2023-10-22). "Transcript: Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell on "Face the Nation," Oct. 22, 2023".
14. (2023-10-22). "US faces new "axis of evil" in Iran, China, and Russia: Mitch McConnell".
15. (October 27, 2023). "Speaker of the House Mike Johnson on "Hannity" Oct. 26, 2023".
16. (October 31, 2023). "Netanyahu warns world if Hamas wins, you are the 'next target'".
17. (January 19, 2024). "Former NATO Chief Warns Against 'Axis of Autocracies'".
18. (April 6, 2024). "Laura Kuenssberg: West facing 'authoritarian' alliance, says Nato chief".
19. Brennan, David. (April 21, 2024). "'New Axis of Evil' Conflicts Threaten US Upheaval on Eve of Election".
20. Wooten, Claude. (April 19, 2024). "Mike Johnson Names New "Axis Of Evil"– Echoing George W. Bush".
21. Kika, Thomas. (October 22, 2023). "US Faces New 'Axis of Evil' in Iran, China and Russia: Mitch McConnell".
22. McCartney, Micah. (April 19, 2024). "China hits back at Mike Johnson".
23. (April 21, 2024). "House approves $95 billion in aid to Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan".
24. (July 8, 2024). "Rearm now or face threat of global conflict, ex-army chief warns". The Times.
25. (July 9, 2024). "Ex-army chief issues WW3 warning and brands 'new axis powers' more dangerous than the Nazis". Sky News.
26. (July 23, 2024). "UK must be ready for war in three years, says Army head". BBC News.
27. Anne Applebaum. (February 12, 2002). "North Korea: Threat or Menace?".
28. Dexter Filkins. (September 30, 2013). "Dexter Filkins: Qassem Suleimani, the Middle East's Most Powerful Operative".
29. Amanpour, Christiane. "Iranian president condemns September 11 attacks".
30. "us state department thanks iranian sympathy with sept 11 victims in 2001".
31. Glass, Andrew. (January 29, 2019). "President Bush cites 'axis of evil,' Jan. 29, 2002".
32. (January 20, 2006). "Israel attacks 'axis of terror'". BBC News.
33. (February 22, 2006). "Gillerman fingers 'axis of terror'". The Jerusalem Post.
34. (July 14, 2006). "Israel blames Iran and Syria for violence". Gulf Times.
35. "parade-magazine-2007-02-17>".
36. Alba Gil. (January 5, 2006). "Evo Morales hace amigos".
37. (August 9, 2007). "Iran Guard says U.S., Britain, Israel "axis of evil"".
38. (October 23, 2008). "An axis in need of oiling". The Economist.
39. (July 12, 2012). "Syria: Iran vows it will not allow Assad to fall". [[The Daily Telegraph]].
40. (August 7, 2012). "Iran backs Assad as Syrian forces choke off Aleppo". [[Reuters]].
41. (August 7, 2012). "Iran: Syria part of 'axis of resistance'". [[CNN]].
42. William C. Martel, The Diplomat. "An Authoritarian Axis Rising?". The Diplomat.
43. [[Daniel Larison]]. (June 29, 2012). "The "Authoritarian Axis" That Doesn't Exist". The American Conservative.
44. (July 24, 2012). "The Return of the "Authoritarian Axis" That Doesn't Exist". The American Conservative.
45. [[Nick Ottens]]. (July 4, 2012). "There is no cabal: The "Authoritarian Axis" nonsense". Muslim Village.
46. Peter I Hajnal; John J Kirton, "Sustainability, civil society, and international governance : local, North American, and global contributions" page 344
47. (November 13, 2006). "Canada pressured at UN climate change talks". [[CTV Television Network]].
48. (May 31, 2003). "The unbearable lightness of being at Bali".
49. (September 7, 2002). "More gold than green".
50. Jansen, Michael. (March 11, 2018). "State visit to Britain by Saudi leader fails to sway critics". Irish Times.
51. Al-Monitor Staff. (March 8, 2018). "Iran dismisses Saudi talk of 'triangle of evil' as 'childish'". [[Al-Monitor]].
52. (December 10, 2018). "NYT's Krugman: US, Russia and Saudi Arabia are 'new axis of evil'". The Hill.
53. (May 9, 2003). "Axis of weasels".
54. Archibold, Randal C.. (June 13, 2004). "'Hey Hey, Ho Ho, Those Old Protest Tactics Have to Go'". The New York Times.
55. Anderson, Perry. (March 6, 2003). "Casuistries of Peace and War". London Review of Books.
56. (October 17, 2004). "The SUV debate: 'Axles of evil' the backlash grows".
57. (December 18, 2015). "Coalition of the Drilling: Oil Fuels the Saudi-Led War Against ISIS".
58. "3 Inches of Blood - Axes of Evil Lyrics".
59. "Axes of Evil: The True Story of the Ax-Man Murders - Elliott, Todd C.".
60. Harmon, Steph. (February 15, 2016). "Axis of Awesome comedian Jordan Raskopoulos on being transgender: 'I never felt right as a boy'". The Guardian.
61. SNL. (2002). "Saturday Night Live S27E13 - Jonny Moseley".
62. Andrew Marlatt. (February 1, 2002). "Angered by snubbing, Libya, China Syria form Axis of Just as Evil". SatireWire.
63. (May 11, 2006). "George Bush and Tony Blair: The end of a Bush-Blair era". [[The Economist]].
64. (December 21, 2007). "Comedic Trio Takes Tour to Middle East".
65. Erik Hillestad. "?". Kirkelig Kulturverksted.