2017 Dutch general election

Electoral system and organisation

The House of Representatives (Dutch: Tweede Kamer) is composed of 150 seats elected by proportional representation in a single nationwide constituency, with a legal threshold of 1 full seat (0.67%), and residuals assigned by the D'Hondt method. The Senate is indirectly elected by the States-Provincial.

Electronic voting has been banned since 2007; votes must be cast with a red pencil.

Following reports from the General Intelligence and Security Service (Algemene Inlichtingen- en Veiligheidsdienst, AIVD) that Russian hacking groups Fancy Bear and Cozy Bear had made several attempts to hack into Dutch ministries, including the Ministry of General Affairs, to gain access to secret government documents. Minister of the Interior and Kingdom Relations Ronald Plasterk announced that votes for the election would therefore be processed by hand, although that decision was later reversed.

The election was also seen as an indication of interest in the national political system in the Caribbean Netherlands, after the low turnout seen there in the 2012 election.

Participating parties

Campaign

The 2017 Dutch–Turkish diplomatic incident happened less than a week before the election; it was speculated that this benefited the Prime Minister's party (VVD), as Rutte's response to the incident was well received.

Debates

Opinion polls

Main article: Opinion polling for the 2017 Dutch general election

Polls showed a precipitous collapse for both the VVD and PvdA following their decision to form a coalition government together after the 2012 elections, with support for the latter splitting among other left-wing or liberal parties. As with other right-wing populist parties, the Party for Freedom (PVV) rose in polls during the European migrant crisis, with the party topping polls from September 2015 through to late February 2017. However, in the relative absence of Geert Wilders during the campaign – notably refusing to participate in both RTL debates – support for the PVV collapsed, and the VVD secured a narrow lead in the final weeks before the election.

The seat projections in the graphs below are continuous from September 2012 (the last general election) up to the current date. Each colored line specifies a political party; numbers on the vertical axis represent numbers of seats. These seat estimates are derived from estimates by Peilingwijzer ("polling indicator") by Tom Louwerse, a professor of political science at Leiden University; they are not strictly polling averages, but the results of a model calculating a "trajectory" for each party based on changes in support over time between polls conducted by I&O Research, Ipsos, TNS NIPO, LISS panel, Peil, and De Stemming, and adjusting for the house effects of each individual pollster.

PvdA PVV SP CDA D66 CU

GL SGP PvdD 50+ VNL DENK FVD PPNL}}

Results

Preliminary results were published on 15 March, and the official result was announced at 16:00 CET on 21 March. The total wasted vote was 161,327 votes or 1.55 %.

By province

Government formation

The election resulted in a House of Representatives where at least four parties would be required to form a coalition with a majority (76 seats). Media sources speculated that incumbent Prime Minister Mark Rutte of the VVD would seek to form a government with the support of the centre-right CDA and liberal D66. CU was thought to be the most likely candidate to be the fourth member of the coalition. Minister of Health, Welfare and Sport, Edith Schippers, was selected by the VVD to serve as the party's informateur on 16 March and appointed by Speaker of the House Khadija Arib, seeking to determine whether Jesse Klaver of GroenLinks solely desired a left-wing government, or instead simply viewed the VVD as an unlikely coalition partner. Similarly, talks with Emile Roemer of the Socialist Party (SP), who repeatedly stated during the campaign that his party would not govern with the VVD, remained a possibility.

The leaders of D66, CDA, PvdA, VVD, SP, GroenLinks, and CU stated that they would not enter a coalition with the PVV, and Roemer has also said that the SP will not join a coalition with the VVD.

The first proposed coalition was one involving the VVD-CDA-D66 and GroenLinks. This was the preferred coalition of Alexander Pechtold, Lodewijk Asscher and Gert-Jan Segers, while Jesse Klaver continued to argue that the major policy differences between GL and the VVD would make a coalition difficult. Nevertheless, the four parties began more serious negotiations toward a coalition agreement. Nederlandse Omroep Stichting (NOS) reported that "labour market reform, investment in law enforcement and additional money for nursing homes" would be areas of agreement between the parties, while "refugee policy, income distribution, climate and medical ethics issues are potential stumbling blocks".

On 15 May, talks on the proposed four-way VVD-CDA-D66-GL coalition failed. It was reported that the main dispute concerned immigration, but GL leader Jesse Klaver cited climate issues and income differences as other issues where the parties disagreed. The end of the talks was reported to be a consensus decision, with no party blaming any others.

Coalition talks were reported to be at an impasse, with the VVD and CDA favouring a coalition with the CU, D66 favouring a coalition with either PvdA or SP, SP being absolutely opposed to a coalition with the VVD, CDA being opposed to a coalition without the VVD, PvdA rejecting any coalition, and all parties with more than five seats rejecting a coalition with the PVV. D66 said that it would consider a coalition with the CU very difficult due to disagreements on medical-ethical issues such as doctor-assisted suicide, due to the lack of representation of the political left within that coalition, and due to the small majority of one seat in both chambers, which could make for an unstable coalition.

In late June 2017, discussions began again between VVD, D66, CDA and CU under the lead of new informateur Herman Tjeenk Willink. After a three-week summer break, talks resumed on 9 August 2017, and were reported to be close to a conclusion due to representatives of unions and employers’ organizations joining the discussions, which typically happens near the end of such negotiations. In September 2017, a budget deal compromise was reached allowing the coalition talks to continue. While still 'close to conclusion', it appeared likely that the talks about government formation would exceed the record since World War II of 208 days set in 1977. After 208 days of negotiations, the VVD, D66, CDA and CU agreed to a coalition under a third informateur, Gerrit Zalm, and all members of the House of Representatives of the involved parties approved the agreement on 9 October 2017. On 26 October the new cabinet was formally installed 225 days after the elections, setting a record for the longest cabinet formation in history.

References

References

1. (22 April 2016). "Verkiezingskalender". Kiesraad.
2. Mehreen Khan. (16 March 2017). "Dutch election: everything you need to know as tricky coalition talks loom". Financial Times.
3. (16 March 2017). "PvdA in geen enkele gemeente de grootste". Financieele Dagblad.
4. (16 March 2017). "Tweede Kamerverkiezingen 2017". Tweede Kamer der Staten-Generaal.
5. (29 October 2009). "Act of 28 September 1989 containing new provisions governing the franchise and elections (Elections Act)". Government of the Netherlands.
6. (2005). "The Politics of Electoral Systems". Oxford University Press.
7. Huib Modderkolk. (4 February 2017). "Russen faalden bij hackpogingen ambtenaren op Nederlandse ministeries". Volkskrant.
8. Peter Cluskey. (3 February 2017). "Dutch opt for manual count after reports of Russian hacking". The Irish Times.
9. Huib Modderkolk. (3 March 2017). "Plasterk draait: tóch stemsoftware bij verkiezingen". de Volkskrant.
10. (15 March 2017). "Verkiezingen Caribische graadmeter". Telegraaf.
11. (3 February 2017). "28 partijen nemen deel aan Tweede Kamerverkiezing". Kiesraad.
12. "Persberichten van Lokaal in de Kamer". Lokaal in de Kamer.
13. Tobias den Hartog. (14 March 2017). "PVV zakt flink weg in peilingen, VVD profiteert". Algemeen Dagblad.
14. (27 February 2017). "Rode Hoed Debat scoort ondanks Boer Zoekt Vrouw". Mediacourant.
15. "Carré-debat – De enige politieke arena zonder theater". Carré-debat.
16. (15 February 2017). "Confrontatie Rutte en Wilders in EenVandaag-debat". EenVandaag.
17. (2 February 2017). "Loting NOS-verkiezingsdebatten verricht". NOS.
18. Tom Louwerse. "Peilingwijzer: Methode". Peilingwijzer.
19. (21 March 2017). "Kerngegevens Tweede Kamerverkiezingen 2017". Kiesraad.
20. "Tweede Kamer 15 maart 2017".
21. (16 March 2017). "Dutch election: Wilders defeat celebrated by PM Rutte".
22. (16 March 2017). "Nederland Kiest: 'formatie wordt moeilijk, moeilijk, moeilijk'". NOS.
23. (2 February 2016). "Wilders: liever een coalitie dan een revolte". NOS.
24. (18 October 2015). "Buma weigert regeren met PVV nog steeds". Telegraaf.
25. (14 January 2017). "PvdA-voorzitter Spekman: Henk en Mark, zeg nee tegen de PVV". NOS.
26. (15 January 2017). "Rutte: kans op regering VVD met PVV is nul". NOS.
27. Sasha Kester. (14 January 2017). "Roemer sluit samenwerking met VVD uit en roept PvdA op hetzelfde te doen". Volkskrant.
28. (15 January 2017). "Klaver sluit VVD niet uit, PVV wel". Telegraaf.
29. (23 January 2017). "ChristenUnie sluit samenwerking met PVV uit". Groot Nieuws Radio.
30. (14 January 2017). "Emile Roemer sluit VVD uit". Algemeen Dagblad.
31. (20 March 2017). "Van middenkabinet tot 'christelijk progressief', alle formatiewensen op een rij - Binnenland - Voor nieuws, achtergronden en columns".
32. (23 March 2017). "Formatie dag 8: de onderhandelingen gaan beginnen".
33. [http://www.politico.eu/article/dutch-coalition-talks-failed-says-official-edith-schippers-mark-rutte/ Dutch coalition talks failed say officials], (in English) politico.eu.
34. [https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-39930986 BBC News], Europe.
35. [http://www.telegraaf.nl/binnenland/28208317/Geen_kans_op_slagen_met_CU.html Geen kans op slagen met CU] (in Dutch), telegraaf.nl.
36. [https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2017/05/18/formatie-in-impasse-d66-heeft-nog-geen-zin-in-cu-9326472-a1559535 Formatie in impassie: D66 nog geen zin in CU] (in Dutch), nrc.nl, 2017.05.18.
37. [http://www.politico.eu/article/dutch-government-talks-near-finish-line-report/ Dutch government talks near finish line] Politico 4 August 2017.
38. [https://ph.news.yahoo.com/talks-form-dutch-govt-kick-off-again-break-173358812.html Talks to form Dutch govt kick off again after break] Yahoo News 9 August 2017.
39. (13 September 2017). "Dutch budget deal prevents collapse of shaky coalition". The Irish Times.
40. (10 October 2017). "208 Days to Forge Four-Party Coalition Dutch Government". [[The Australian]].
41. (9 October 2017). "Dutch Coalition Partners Agree on Government Deal, Seek Party Backing". [[Politico]].
42. (9 October 2017). "Dutch Parties Agree Coalition Government After a Record 208 Days". [[The Guardian]].
43. (10 October 2017). "Dutch Government Coalition Deal Receives Parliamentary Backing". [[Politico]].