2013 Punggol East by-election

Background

On 8 December 2012, local tabloid The New Paper reported receiving a tip-off in the form of screengrabs of phone messages suggesting that Palmer was involved in an affair. The messages indicated a close relationship between Palmer and the other party, with regular meetings on Mondays. The tabloid also reported that the relationship had lasted for a year. On the same day of the exposé, Palmer met Deputy Prime Minister Teo Chee Hean to tender his resignation as Speaker and MP. The following day, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong met Palmer to formally confirm his resignation. Subsequently, the by-election was called by President Tony Tan Keng Yam on the advice of the Prime Minister after the Punggol East seat became vacant.

On 12 December 2012, the PAP held a press conference where Palmer announced his resignation, stating he was stepping down to "take full responsibility for a grave mistake" involving an improper relationship with a People's Association (PA) staff member, Laura Ong, who worked in the Pasir Ris West constituency office. Although Ong did not report directly to Palmer, they collaborated on constituency matters within the Pasir Ris–Punggol division. At the press conference, Deputy Prime Minister Teo Chee Hean announced that Teo Ser Luck would serve as interim MP for Punggol East, while Zainal Sapari would take over as chairman of the Pasir Ris–Punggol Town Council. Deputy Speaker Charles Chong served as Acting Speaker until 14 January 2013, when Halimah Yacob was appointed as the new Speaker.

Confirmation of by-election

On 9 January 2013, President Tan issued a writ of election for the electoral division of Punggol East. The nominations were held on 16 January at North Vista Secondary School and voting took place on 26 January.

Candidates

Four candidates were successfully nominated for this election:

The Singapore Democratic Party (SDP) initially expressed interest in contesting the election, with the SDP attempting to broker a deal with WP for a joint alliance, but later withdrew on 15 January. There were potential independent candidates who declared their intentions to run. They included former People's Liberal Democratic Party (PLDP) founder Ooi Boon Ewe, retired acupuncturist Zeng Guoyuan and former Singapore People's Party (SPP) member Benjamin Pwee.

Results

Before the results were announced, SDA's Desmond Lim conceded at about 10.42pm (SGT) thanking his supporters and vowed to 'keep SDA's flame alive' in the next election.

Results were announced at 22:57pm (SGT) when WP's Lee was declared candidate-elect with 54.52% out of 29,415 valid votes, defeating PAP opponent Koh with 43.71% of the vote. Two candidates had forfeited their $14,500 election deposit for garnering below the 12.5% threshold, namely Kenneth Jeyaretnam of the RP and Desmond Lim of the SDA with 1.20% and 0.57% of the votes respectively, with the latter becoming the second candidate to have his election deposit forfeited twice since Harbans Singh, and setting a record-low vote share at the time of the election surpassing Teo Kim Hoe's former record of 196 votes or 0.81% in post-independence Singapore.

Overseas votes were tabulated four days after the by-election, on 30 January, seeing a 0.02% change in the top two parties after Koh and Lee received 19 and 7 votes respectively (there is only one spoilt and 32 abstained votes). The results are as follows:

|reg. electors= 31,649

Aftermath

The election was seen as another setback for the PAP following the formation of the 12th Parliament after the 2011 election, when the WP won Aljunied GRC. At the time, it appeared that public support for the PAP was waning. The WP made history with Lee Li Lian becoming the first female MP in post-independence Singapore to helm a SMC and the second female opposition MP after WP chairwoman Sylvia Lim. It was also only the second instance of the PAP losing a parliamentary seat mid-term to the opposition, the first being in 1981 when the WP captured Anson. Lee was sworn in as MP a week later, on 4 February.

Prime Minister Lee congratulated the WP on their victory and expressed respect for the voters' decision, noting that by-elections are often about choosing an MP rather than a government, and acknowledging that some voters may use them to support the opposition. He added that the government would focus on pressing national issues in Parliament, including the Population White Paper (PWP) and the annual Budget statement. Lee emphasised that the PAP was prepared for the long term, committed to delivering results, improving the lives of Singaporeans and presenting their performance for voters to assess in the next general election. Similarly, WP chief Low Thia Khiang told the media that voters should not take the by-election result for granted and emphasised that the WP would continue to hold the government accountable while representing their constituents.

Subsequent elections

In the 2015 general election, PAP's Koh was elected as an MP for the Yio Chu Kang division under Ang Mo Kio GRC, and later represented Tampines Central in Tampines GRC during the 2020 and 2025 general elections. WP's Lee Li Lian was unable to retain Punggol East in 2015, losing narrowly to the PAP candidate Charles Chong, returning the constituency to PAP control. Punggol East was later dissolved during the 2020 general election and absorbed into the newly formed Sengkang GRC. The WP subsequently won the GRC, effectively returning the area formerly known as Punggol East, now Rivervale, to the party. As of 2025, the ward remains under WP's control, with Rivervale overseen by Louis Chua.

The four-cornered contest within a single constituency, last seen in 1997 at Chua Chu Kang SMC and the 2011 presidential election, remained the most recent instance of such a contest until 12 years later in the 2025 general election. In Tampines GRC, a four-way race unfolded between the PAP, whose team coincidentally included Koh, the WP led by former Aljunied GRC MP Faisal Manap, the National Solidarity Party (NSP) and the People's Power Party (PPP). In the ensuing election, the PAP retained Tampines GRC with 52.02% of the vote compared to WP's 47.37%. Meanwhile, both the PPP and NSP performed poorly, receiving only 0.43% and 0.18% of the valid votes respectively, marking the lowest vote shares in post-independence Singapore and causing both parties to forfeit their election deposits.

References

References

1. (12 December 2012). "Speaker of Parliament Michael Palmer resigns over 'grave mistake'". [[Channel NewsAsia]].
2. (26 January 2013). "WP's Lee wins Punggol East by-election". Channel NewsAsia.
3. "SMSes expose Michael Palmer's affair". The New Paper.
4. (9 January 2013). "Punggol East by-election announced, Polling Day is Jan 26". The Straits Times.
5. (10 January 2013). "PAP fields Koh Poh Koon as its candidate for by-election". Channel NewsAsia.
6. (14 January 2013). "WP fields Lee Li Lian as its candidate for by-election". [[Channel NewsAsia]].
7. (June 2025). ["SDP still keen to contest by-election"](http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/specialreport/news/1247902_189/1/.html }}{{Dead link). Channel NewsAsia.
8. (June 2025). ["SDA fields Desmond Lim as its candidate for by-election"](http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/singaporelocalnews/view/1247989/1/.html }}{{Dead link). Channel NewsAsia.
9. (15 January 2013). "RP picks Kenneth Jeyaretnam as candidate for by-election". Channel NewsAsia.
10. (11 January 2013). "SDP proposes joint campaign with WP in Punggol East by-election". Channel NewsAsia.
11. (15 January 2013). "SDP not contesting Punggol East by-election". Channel NewsAsia.
12. (June 2025). ["Ooi Boon Ewe, Zeng Guoyuan issued Political Donation Certificates"](http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/specialreport/news/1247787_189/1/.html }}{{Dead link). Channel NewsAsia.
13. (15 January 2013). "Benjamin Pwee pulls out". Channel NewsAsia.
14. (26 January 2013). "SDA's Lim concedes defeat". Channel NewsAsia.
15. "Candidates name list (H-I): Harbans Singh".
16. (30 January 2013). "Overseas votes for Punggol-East by-election counted". The Straits Times.
17. (February 4, 2013). "WP's Lee Li Lian sworn in as MP for Punggol East". Channel NewsAsia.
18. (26 January 2013). "I respect the choice of Punggol East voters: PM Lee". The Straits Times.
19. (26 January 2013). "Punggol East by-election: Statement of PM Lee Hsien Loong". The Straits Times.
20. (27 January 2013). "Low: Don't take by-election result as sign of future trend". The Straits Times.
21. (29 Jan 2016). "Parliament: House votes to fill NCMP seat vacated by WP Punggol East candidate Lee Li Lian".
22. (13 March 2020). "White Paper on the Report of the Electoral Boundaries Review Committee, 2020". Electoral Boundaries Review Committee.
23. (11 July 2020). "GE2020 results: WP wins in Sengkang with 52.13% of the votes". The Straits Times.
24. (2025-05-04). "GE2025: WP wins in Sengkang GRC with 56.31%, improving on 2020 showing". The Straits Times.
25. (23 April 2025). "GE2025: Stage set for four-way fight in Tampines GRC; PAP and WP go head-to-head in Tampines Changkat SMC".
26. (4 May 2025). "GE2025: PAP retains Tampines GRC in 4-way fight, wins Tampines Changkat SMC".