2011 Mumbai bombings

Timeline and damage

The first device was planted on a motorcycle at Khau Gali in south Mumbai's Zaveri Bazaar and exploded at 18:54 local time. The second device, planted in a tiffin box outside Prasad Chambers and Panchratna Building, in the Opera House area on Charni Road, exploded at 18:55, the area of workplaces of 5,000–6,000 people connected with the diamond-trade industry. The third device was placed on an electric pole at the Dr Antonio Da Silva High School BEST bus stand near Kabutar Khana in Dadar area and exploded at 19:06.

Following the blasts, phone lines were jammed and communications ceased or were available intermittently for at least a few hours. Other metropolitan cities, including Delhi, Chennai, Hyderabad and Bangalore, were also put on high alert. Immediately after the blasts, the Mumbai Police sent an SMS to a few mobile phone users in Mumbai reading,

Most of the injured were rushed to various hospitals in Mumbai, such as J.J. Hospital, St. George Hospital, Hurkisondas Hospital and G. T. Hospital.

Mumbai has been hit by terrorist incidents at least half a dozen times since the early 1990s, with over 600 people dying in these attacks. In an editorial, the Times of India described the city as having become a "hot hunting ground for terror." A loss of Rs. 3 billion per day was reported at the closure of the Panchratna Building, after the blasts, where the people who lost their lives were mainly from the diamond industry, and at Zaveri Bazaar, were mostly goldsmiths. Rakesh Maria said that the Anti-Terrorism Squad (India), would soon release sketches of culprits, as the footage obtained from the closed-circuit television (CCTV) cameras at Opera House site was under scrutiny.

Casualties and compensation

The blasts claimed 26 lives and injured an additional 130 others.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Indian National Congress leader Sonia Gandhi visited Mumbai the next day and met with those injured in blasts at Saifee Hospital. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh announced a compensation of 2,00,000 to the kin of each of those killed and to the seriously injured. Meanwhile, the Maharashtra Government also announced in compensation to the families of each of those killed and about 50,000 to the injured.

Investigations

Speculations

There was speculation that the pattern of the blasts suggested involvement of Indian Mujahideen (IM). According to the Delhi Police, Indian Mujaheddin has been conducting blasts on the 13 or 26 of the month. Speculation was also rife that the hard-line Taliban Mumbai underworld could be behind these blasts, in the light of the killing of journalist Jyotirmoy Dey, as well as the attempted assassination of Dawood Ibrahim's brother, Iqbal Kaskar on 3 May 2011. The day 13 July is also observed as Kashmir Martyr's day, and there could be a possibility that the attacks were carried out by Kashmiri groups. There is also a view that the attacks could have been plotted by those trying to derail the Indo-Pakistani peace process.

The slain MiD DAY crime journalist Jyotirmoy Dey had previously reported that a huge cache of 35 detonators, gelatin sticks and large quantity of ammonium nitrate explosives had been seized on 20 May 2011 from Umarkui and Sayli village in Silvassa. Ammonium nitrate, gelatin and detonators have been used in several bomb blasts in Mumbai previously. The report also mentioned that this cache had gone missing soon after local police took custody. The journalist had also speculated that the cache might be used to trigger terror attacks in the city.

Timeline of investigations

The Home Ministry classified the bomb blasts as a terrorist act and dispatched a National Investigation Agency (NIA) team to the bomb site. The Chief Minister of Maharashtra Prithviraj Chavan said that the bombs used could have been fuel filled, much like molotov cocktails. Preliminary investigations suggested the use of multiple IED explosives in the blasts with ammonium nitrate-based explosives mixed with fuel oil. The explosives indicate some level of sophistication. It is also believed that remote detonators may have been used, with two of the three blasts being high-intensity. The Home Minister also announced that his office would be updating the people through the media every two hours.

The Maharashtra ATS was reported to have sought a list of passengers travelling from Kolkata to Mumbai and Kolkata to Kanpur from the Kolkata Police. The suspicions were a result of a Kolkata man with Indian Mujahideen link having gone missing in the previous few days. A NIA team visited Ahmedabad on 15 July 2011 to meet an Indian Mujahideen suspect who was arrested by the Crime Branch in connection with the 2008 Ahmedabad bombings. On 16 July, Maharashtra ATS Chief Rakesh Maria said that, based on forensic opinion and visit to the various sites, the possibility of a suicide bomber was being ruled out. However, a sketch of a possible suspect based on CCTV footage from one of the blast sites was being prepared. He added that in light of the sensitive nature of the investigation, the entire detail of the probe could not be revealed at that particular stage.

On 4 August, Home Minister P. Chidambaram suggested indications of involvement of a home-grown terror module in the blasts.

On 9 August, the Maharashtra ATS arrested one person it claimed had stolen a bike used in the Zaveri Bazaar explosion. The bike had been stolen from one Amit Singh a few hours before the blasts. CCTV footage showed one person with long hair riding a stolen red colour Honda Activa, entering the crowded lane, taking two left turns, placing the scooter at the spot of the explosion and walking off.

On 23 January 2012, the Mumbai Police claimed that it had solved the Mumbai Blasts case with the arrests of two suspects – Naqi Ahmed Wasi Ahmed Sheikh (22) and Nadeem Akhtar Ashfaq Sheikh (23) – hailing from Darbhanga district of Bihar. The Mumbai Police's ATS claimed that the two had stolen two scooters used in the blasts according to a scheme whose logistics were managed by Yasin Bhatkal, the mastermind of the blast. However, this televised announcement baffled the other intelligence agencies. It was later revealed that Naqi Ahmed was assisting the Delhi Police and other central intelligence agencies in tracking down two other perpetrators of the blast.

On 25 May 2012, Maharashtra ATS filed a chargesheet against Naqee Ahmed, Nadeem Shaikh, Kanwar Pathrija and Haroon Naik (all are under arrest). Additionally, the chargesheet named six others including Indian Mujahideen mastermind Yasin Bhatkal and Riyaz Bhatkal, Waqas Ibrahim Sad, Danish alias Tarbez, Dubai based Muzaffar Kolah and Tehseen Akhtar as wanted accused on the run.

On 4 February 2014, Maharashtra ATS was handed over the custody of Indian Mujahideen mastermind Yasin Bhatkal for probing the 2011 Mumbai Bombings Case.

On 16 July 2014 Mumbai ATS arrested Abdul Mateen Fakki from Goa’s Dabolim Airport, while he arrived from Dubai by flight. He is accused of financing the terrorist operation by passing money through Hawala sources to Indian Mujahideen co-founder Yasin Bhatkal.

Allegations of police brutality

The Mumbai Police detained several men for questioning. One of those detained—Faiz Usmani—died while in police custody on 17 July, sparking allegations of police brutality. Usmani was the brother of one of the accused in the 2008 Ahmedabad bombings case. It was alleged by his family members that Faiz Usmani was healthy when the police picked him up and that he was subjected to torture in police custody. The police dismissed these charges and countered that Usmani was suffering from hypertension and complained of giddiness after walking himself into a police station. He was admitted to the Lokmanya Tilak hospital, Sion, Mumbai, following which he died quickly due to blood clots in brain and a heart attack. A CID probe was ordered into Usmani's death.

Aftermath

In the wake of the blasts, Boeing announced that the Boeing-787 Dreamliner, which was on its maiden visit to India, would skip the Mumbai leg of the trip. An official said that it would have been insensitive to take the plane to Mumbai at this time when such a tragedy had occurred and that the decision had also been taken in view of security concerns and so as not to put added pressure to provide extra cover for the aircraft.

Chief Minister of Maharashtra Prithviraj Chavan revealed a plan by the Maharashtra government for a future use of satellite phones and the development of a secure communication network so that the administrative functioning is not affected during such crises as a result of network problems. He also reiterated the need to expedite the procurement of police modernisation equipment and the installation of CCTV cameras at prominent places in the city. Following the Mumbai terror attacks the Directorate General of Shipping (DGS) banned the use of Thuraya & Iridium satellite phones and infrastructure. Restrictions were already in place in 2010, for similar reasons, under provisions in the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885.

Reactions

Domestic

President Pratibha Patil and Vice-President Hamid Ansari expressed their shock and condemned the attacks in Mumbai. Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh also condemned the bombing, and called on Mumbai citizens to remain calm and show unity. Other politicians, such as Sonia Gandhi, chairperson of the Indian National Congress and Nitin Gadkari of the BJP expressed their anger and offered condolences to the families of the bombing victims. Senior BJP leader L K Advani visited Mumbai on 14 July and stated that the repeated attacks in Mumbai prove policy failure on part of the government. The Left parties (CPI and CPI (M)) strongly condemned the Mumbai serial blasts and rued the government's inability to track down the perpetrators of recent terror strikes. Maharashtra Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan said that this was an attack on the heart of India. Home Minister P. Chidambaram left Delhi for Mumbai on the same night and visited the three blast sites, met the injured in the hospitals, and interacted with the family members of the dead.

Local politician, Manohar Joshi of the Shiv Sena, urged the government to "take immediate steps and find out who are people behind the blasts."

INC general secretary Rahul Gandhi remarked that it was impossible to stop every terror attack. He said that 99 per cent of terror attacks had been prevented in the country thanks to various measures, such as improved intelligence collection efforts. He added that "We work towards defeating it, but it is very difficult to stop all the attacks. Even the United States, they are being attacked in Afghanistan.". His comments drew flak from some quarters of the Indian political spectrum, who criticised him for equating the Mumbai attacks with those in Afghanistan and called it an insult to those killed in the blasts.

Chairman of the moderate Hurriyat faction Mirwaiz Umar Farooq condemned the Mumbai blasts saying such incidents are orchestrated to derail the dialogue process between India and Pakistan and that those involved in the killing of innocent people are enemies of humanity'. In a statement, he said "We are saddened by the huge loss of life in the Mumbai blasts and condemn it. Spilling the blood of innocents, be it in Mumbai, Palestine, Karachi or Kashmir, is a shameful and inhuman act."

International

Organisations

• UN A statement issued by UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon's office read: "The Secretary-General condemns the attacks that have killed and injured many in Mumbai," said a statement from his office. "No cause or grievance can justify indiscriminate violence against civilians. The Secretary-General expresses his solidarity with the Government and people of India, and extends his sincere condolences to the families of the victims," it added. :A statement read by Peter Wittig, Germany's ambassador to the UN and current United Nations Security Council President declared that "the members of the Security Council reaffirmed that terrorism in all its forms and manifestations constitutes one of the most serious threats to international peace and security, and that any acts of terrorism are criminal and unjustifiable, regardless of their motivation." In a deviation from the language used by the Security Council in its condemnations of other such attacks, this press statement did not contain the Security Council's usual admonition to member states that they must ensure that measures taken to combat such incidents, comply with all their obligations under international law, in particular international human rights, refugee and humanitarian law, prompting some observers to comment that this was a result of India's growing clout in the premier body.

• EU European Union foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton's office released a statement that read: "(Ashton) was horrified to hear that Mumbai has again been the target of a series of deadly bomb attacks. She condemns these heinous acts and expresses her condolences to the families and friends of the victims. It is essential that the perpetrators these evil attacks are brought to justice," stated a release issued by her office.

• NATO Secretary General of NATO Anders Fogh Rasmussen expressed deepest sympathies to the victims of the terrorist attacks in heavily populated areas of Mumbai. He condemned in the strongest possible terms the indiscriminate violence and the senseless loss of innocent lives.

Notes

References

• Photos. NDTV
• Eyewitness Photos. NDTV
• Photo Gallery. IBNLive
• Mumbai Blast Coverage, Published by Chris Augeri
• Blasts in Mumbai: July 2011 – slideshow by Life magazine
• Incident summary at the Global Terrorism Database

References

1. "Three blasts in Mumbai, thirteen dead, 81 injured". [[NDTV]].
2. "Three blasts in Mumbai". NDTV 24x7.
3. "3 bomb blasts in Mumbai; 8 killed, 70 injured". [[CNN-IBN]].
4. "Mumbai-blasts-Death-toll-rises-to-26".
5. "Mumbai blasts: Death toll rises to 23". NDTV.
6. "Death toll in Mumbai terror blasts rises to 19". NDTV.
7. "Incident Summary for GTDID: 201107130009".
8. Ram Sehgal, ET Bureau. (14 July 2011). "Mumbai terror attack: Chaos reigns in city's famous diamond hub Opera House". The Economic Times.
9. (13 July 2011). "Three blasts go off in Mumbai, 50 injured". [[Rediff.com]].
10. (13 July 2011). "Serial Blasts in Mumbai, at Least 10 Killed". International Business Times.
11. "Security alert in Delhi, Bangalore and Chennai". [[NDTV]].
12. (13 July 2011). "The SMS sent by police to cellphone users in Mumbai". NDTV.
13. "Mumbai blasts: hospitals struggle to cope up". IBN News.
14. (14 July 2011). "Mumbai's 'macabre dance of death' – Indian press". BBC.
15. (14 July 2011). "Mumbai: Hot hunting ground for terror". [[The Times of India]].
16. Terror Again. Frontline Volume 28 – Issue 16 :: 30 Jul. – 12 August 2011 [http://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl2816/stories/20110812281602300.htm]
17. (30 July 2011). "Mumbai blasts: Death toll rises to 26". Hindustan Times.
18. "List of those killed in Mumbai bombings". Indo Asian News Service.
19. (15 July 2011). "PM, Sonia visit Mumbai blasts victims at Saifee". [[The Times of India]].
20. (14 July 2011). "PM to visit Mumbai, announces Rs 2 lakh for kin of deceased". [[The Times of India]].
21. "Date, modus operandi point to IM involvement: Special Cell".
22. (14 July 2011). "Mumbai blasts: Is underworld behind the return of terror?". [[The Times of India]].
23. (14 July 2011). "Mumbai bomb blasts a ploy to derail India-Pakistan talks?". The Economic Times.
24. "35 detonators vanish from police custody".
25. "MiD DAY expose may hold key to July 13 blasts".
26. "Terror Strikes Mumbai, 3 blasts, 10 reported dead". [[NDTV]].
27. "Bombs used were like Molotov Cocktails: Chavan". NDTV 24x7.
28. (16 July 2011). "Mumbai blasts: ATS claims good leads, suicide bomber ruled out". [[The Times of India]].
29. "Mumbai blasts: Sophisticated IEDs controlled by cellphones used". NDTV.
30. "Ammonium nitrate used to carry out Mumbai blasts". CNN-IBN.
31. "Mumbai ATS seeks passengers detail from Kolkata police".
32. "Mumbai: Maha ATS in touch with Kolkata STF".
33. "Mumbai blasts: Possibility of suicide bomber can be ruled out, says police".
34. "Mumbai blasts probe: digital timers used".
35. "Pune and Mumbai blasts are 'major blots' on my career: PC". The Indian Express.
36. (4 August 2011). "Government: Indian Group Likely Behind Mumbai Blasts". The Indian Express.
37. (8 September 2011). "13/7 blasts: Man who stole two-wheeler used by terrorists held". CNN-IBN.
38. (3 October 2011). "EXCLUSIVE! July 2011 Mumbai bombers identified". Rediff.
39. (23 January 2011). "Union home ministry officials baffled as Maharashtra ATS 'cracks' 13/7 Mumbai blasts". [[The Times of India]].
40. (23 January 2011). "MHA not kept in the loop on 13/7 Mumbai blasts arrests by Maharashtra ATS: sources". CNN-IBN.
41. (19 April 2012). "13/7 bombers used 18 SIMs to evade cops". [[The Times of India]].
42. (25 May 2012). "Mumbai: ATS files chargesheet in 13/7 blast case". IBN India.
43. (25 May 2012). "13/7 blasts case: ATS files charge sheet, names Riyaz Bhatkal".
44. "IM Founder Yasin Bhatkal is under arrest of Mumbai ATS". Biharprabha News.
45. "2011 Mumbai Triple Bomb blast accused arrested in Goa". news.biharprabha.com.
46. (17 July 2011). "Police dismiss custodial violence charges in death of Mumbai blast detainee". The Times of India.
47. (17 July 2011). "Faiz Usmani suffered heart attack, had clots in brain: Autopsy". [[The Times of India]].
48. "Mumbai: CID probe ordered in Faiz Usmani's death".
49. "Boeing Dreamliner to skip Mumbai leg of India visit". Newsleaks.
50. (15 July 2011). "Maharashtra mulls satphones after collapse of cell network". [[The Times of India]].
51. (3 December 2018). "Alert: Ban on use of satellite phones in India: 6 years on and violations still occur". [[Assuranceforeningen Gard.
52. R. P. Singh, Director (Customs). "Subject: Illegal use of Satellite Phones in India – regarding". Government of India, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, [[Central Board of Excise & Customs]].
53. "President, political leaders condemn Mumbai blasts".
54. "Blast reax: Obama, Sonia Gandhi condemn attacks".
55. "Yahoo! Live news".
56. "President, political leaders condemn Mumbai blasts".
57. "Repeated Mumbai attacks prove policy failure: Advani".
58. (14 July 2011). "Left parties condemn Mumbai blasts". The Hindu.
59. "This is an attack on the heart of India:Prithviraj Chavan".
60. "P Chidambaram leaves for Mumbai". IBN India.
61. "Govt should find out who all are behind the blasts: Shiv Sena".
62. "Difficult to stop terror attacks all the time, says Rahul Gandhi".
63. "Sena slams Rahul for equating Mumbai and Afghan attacks".
64. "Opposition slams Rahul's statement on terror".
65. "Hurriyat condemns Mumbai blasts".
66. "Hurriyat condemns Mumbai serial blasts".
67. "UN chief, Security Council condemn Mumbai terror attacks".
68. "As UNSC Condemns Mumbai Bombings, Human Rights Phrase Used From Kabul to Kampala, & India 2008, Gets Omitted". Inner City Press.
69. "EU condemns Mumbai attacks".
70. "NATO Secretary General condemns Mumbai attacks".
71. (2013-09-14). "NIA announces Rs 10 lakh reward for Mumbai triple blasts suspect".