1958 French presidential election

Background

The election took place during the Algerian War and after the May 1958 crisis, which led to General Charles de Gaulle's return to power. On June 1, 1958, after having been President of the Provisional Government of the French Republic at the end of the Second World War, "the General", at the request of President René Coty, became President of the Council of Ministers. Three months later, at the end of September, he had the Constitution of the Fifth Republic adopted by referendum, with 82.6% of "yes" votes.

The conditions for General de Gaulle's return to power - the investiture of his government by the National Assembly in a context of high tension - were denounced by a section of the left, notably the French Communist Party (PCF), which saw it as a "coup d'état". The Radical Party and the French Section of the Workers' International (SFIO) entered the government, with the socialist leader Guy Mollet being Minister of State, but opposition to support for de Gaulle within these parties quickly led to schisms. This is how the coalition of the Union of the Democratic Forces (UFD) was created, which brought together figures such as Pierre Mendès France, a radical dissident, and François Mitterrand (UDSR).

The vote also took place during the Cold War. As such, the PCF, the leading party in France after the Second World War were concerned the public opinion was increasingly rejecting the Eastern Bloc and appeared to be losing momentum while systematically supporting the USSR.

The legislative elections of November 1958 were marked by a victory for the Gaullist right and by a historic decline in the number of left-wing deputies, notably communists - only 10 were elected, a great loss from the 150 elected in 1956. With less than 2% of the votes, the UFD did not obtain any seats.

Terms

Article 6 of the 1958 Constitution indicates that the President of the Republic is elected for seven years "by an electoral college comprising members of Parliament, general councils and assemblies of overseas territories, as well as elected representatives of municipal councils", the latter differing according to the size of the municipalities. The two-round majority single-member constituency system is retained by article 7.

Due to the large number of sparsely populated communes in France, the electoral college mainly favours rural areas or the "France du seigle et de la châtaigne" (France of rye and chestnuts), according to the expression of Georges Vedel. Indeed, communes with fewer than 4,000 inhabitants have three times more delegates than towns with more than 100,000 inhabitants.

The order of the November 7, 1958 organic law specifies the voting procedures. It provides that candidates must have collected, at least twelve days before the first round, 50 signatures from the electoral college. These electors vote in the capital of their department of election. If no candidate has obtained the majority of votes cast, a second round is planned within eight days.

The choice not to impose direct universal suffrage resulted from a compromise with the opponents of de Gaulle, who feared too great a break with the Fourth Republic. Furthermore, the French colonial Empire was expected to vote almost exclusively for the General, which predestined the latter to extremely high scores in the colonies if direct universal suffrage had been chosen.

Candidates

On December 13, 1958, when a duel between the right (Charles de Gaulle) and the communist left (Georges Marrane) was expected, the Provisional Constitutional Commission (Constitutional Council) announced that Albert Châtelet, honorary dean of the Paris Faculty of Sciences, had also gathered the necessary signatures to run. This candidacy, submitted just before the deadline on the initiative of Daniel Mayer, was supported by the UFD, which stated that it “opposed the dangerous simplification that tends to present French politics as a battle between two blocs.”

Campaign

The academic Jean-François Condette sums up the situation of the two candidates facing Charles de Gaulle as follows: "Georges Marrane is identified by his political label, the designated representative of the communist danger who, in the midst of the Cold War, must serve as a foil. Albert Châtelet, for his part, is presented as 'the dean', a respectable but outdated figure, an academic lost in politics"  .

The fact that Charles de Gaulle was the clear favorite due to his prestige and his position, as well as the voting method, did not give rise to an intense or media-heavy campaign. Albert Châtelet, while believing that "de Gaulle and the communists contain the seeds of civil war", refused to campaign, recognizing that his candidacy was "symbolic and principled".

Results

Analysis

As widely predicted, General de Gaulle easily obtained an absolute majority of the votes cast, which did not require a second round. In Metropolitan France alone (i.e., excluding Algeria and the overseas territories), the 74,391 votes cast were distributed as follows: 77.5% for the winner, 13.6% for Georges Marrane and 8.9% for Albert Châtelet .

Although the President of the Council won in all the departments, his victory was not considered humiliating for his opponents. The communist candidate achieved his best scores in his party's strongholds, particularly Nord-Pas-de-Calais, while Albert Châtelet came second in 39 metropolitan departments, notably in the socialist and radical strongholds located in the south of France.

References

References

1. Philip Thody. (1989). "French Caesarism from Napoleon I to Charles de Gaulle". Palgrave Macmillan UK.
2. "Constitution du 4 octobre 1958 - Texte originel - Sénat".
3. Condette, Jean-François Condette. (2009). "Le Nord-Pas-de-Calais en 1958". IRHIS, CEGES, Université Charles de Gaulle-Lille 3.
4. Susana Galera. (1 January 2010). "Judicial Review: A Comparative Analysis Inside the European Legal System". Council of Europe.
5. Serge Berstein, vol. I : ''La République gaullienne (1959-1969)'', Paris, Éditions du Seuil, 1989, 384 p., p. 24.
6. Condette, Jean-François. (2009). "Un « Nordiste » candidat à l'élection présidentielle de décembre 1958 : Albert Châtelet contre Charles de Gaulle. La toge contre l'uniforme ?". Publications de l’Institut de recherches historiques du Septentrion.
7. "Constitution du 4 octobre 1958 Texte originel".
8. Ségur, Philippe. (2013). "La Ve République". Ellipses.
9. "Droit Constitutionnel Et Institutions Politiques. 4eme Edition".
10. https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/download/securePrint?token=uJyAk!OYKZsHF0@90Xg9
11. "Décision n° 58-1 PDR du 13 décembre 1958".