Perspectivism

Precursors and early developments

In Western languages, scholars have found perspectivism in the philosophies of Heraclitus ( – ), Protagoras ( – ), Michel de Montaigne (1533 – 1592 CE), and Gottfried Leibniz In Asian languages, scholars have found perspectivism in Buddhist, Jain, and Daoist texts. Anthropologists have found a kind of perspectivism in the thinking of some indigenous peoples. Some theologians believe John Calvin interpreted various scriptures in a perspectivist manner.

Ancient Greek philosophy

The Western origins of perspectivism can be found in the pre-Socratic philosophies of Heraclitus and Protagoras. The antiperspectivism of Plato made him a central target of critique for later perspectival philosophers such as Nietzsche.

Montaigne

Montaigne's philosophy presents in itself a less as a doctrinaire position than as a core philosophical approach put into practice. Inasmuch as no one can occupy a God's-eye view, Montaigne holds that no one has access to a view which is totally unbiased, which does not interpret according to its own perspective. It is instead only the underlying psychological biases which view one's own perspective as unbiased.|author=Michel de Montaigne|title="Of Cannibals"|source=Essais (1595), trans. J. M. Cohen}}

Nietzsche

In his works, Nietzsche makes a number of statements on perspective which at times contrast each other throughout the development of his philosophy. Nietzsche's begins by challenging the underlying notions of 'viewing from nowhere', 'viewing from everywhere', and 'viewing without interpreting' as being absurdities. Instead, all viewing is attached to some perspective, and all viewers are limited in some sense to the perspectives at their command. In The Genealogy of Morals he writes:

In this, Nietzsche takes a contextualist approach which rejects any God's-eye view of the world. This has been further linked to his notion of the death of God and the dangers of a resulting relativism. However, Nietzsche's perspectivism itself stands in sharp contrast to any such relativism.|author=Friedrich Nietzsche|source=The Will to Power, §481 (1883–1888), transl. Walter Kaufmann and R. J. Hollingdale}}

While Nietzsche does not plainly reject truth and objectivity, he does reject the notions of absolute truth, external facts, and non-perspectival objectivity.

Truth theory and the value of truth

Despite receiving much attention within contemporary philosophy, there is no academic consensus on Nietzsche's conception of truth. While his perspectivism presents a number of challenges regarding the nature of truth, its more controversial element lies in its questioning of the value of truth.}}

Later developments

20th century

In the 20th century, perspectivism was discussed separately by José Ortega y Gasset and Karl Jaspers. Ortega's perspectivism, replaced his previous position that "man is completely social". His reversal is prominent in his work Verdad y perspectiva ("Truth and perspective"), where he explained that "each man has a mission of truth" and that what he sees of reality no other eye sees. He explained:From different positions two people see the same surroundings. However, they do not see the same thing. Their different positions mean that the surroundings are organized in a different way: what is in the foreground for one may be in the background for another. Furthermore, as things are hidden one behind another, each person will see something that the other may not.Ortega also maintained that perspective is perfected by the multiplication of its viewpoints. He noted that war transpires due to the lack of perspective and failure to see the larger contexts of the actions among nations. Ortega also cited the importance of phenomenology in perspectivism as he argued against speculation and the importance of concrete evidence in understanding truth and reality. In this discourse, he highlighted the role of "circumstance" in finding out the truth since it allows us to understand realities beyond ourselves.

21st century

During the 21st century, perspectivism has led a number of developments within analytic philosophy and philosophy of science,Examples of perspectivism in philosophy of science include:| | | | | particularly under the early influence of Ronald Giere, Jay Rosenberg, Ernest Sosa, and others. This contemporary form of perspectivism, also known as scientific perspectivism, is more narrowly focused than prior forms—centering on the perspectival limitations of scientific models, theories, observations, and focused interest, while remaining more compatible for example with Kantian philosophy and correspondence theories of truth. Furthermore, scientific perspecitivism has come to address a number of scientific fields such as physics, biology, cognitive neuroscience, and medicine, as well as interdisciplinarity and philosophy of time. Studies of perspectivism have also been introduced into contemporary anthropology, initially through the influence of Eduardo Viveiros de Castro and his research into indigenous cultures of South America.

Types of perspectivism

Contemporary types of perspectivism include:

• Individualist perspectivism
• Collectivist perspectivism
• Transcendental perspectivism
• Theological perspectivism

References

References

1. Nehamas, Alexander. (1998). "The Art of Living: Socratic Reflections from Plato to Foucault". [[University of California Press]].
2. Sandywell, Barry. (2012). "'Perspectives, Philosophical' and 'Perspectivism'". Routledge.
3. Agazzi, Evandro. (2016). "Scientific realism within perspectivism and perspectivism within scientific realism". Springer.
4. Anderson, R. Lanier. (Summer 2017). "Friedrich Nietzsche".
5. Meyer, Matthew. (2014). "Reading Nietzsche through the Ancients: An Analysis of Becoming, Perspectivism, and the Principle of Non-Contradiction". Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co KG.
6. Conway, Daniel. (1999). "Nietzsche, Epistemology, and Philosophy of Science". Springer.
7. Nehamas, Alexander. (1998). "The Art of Living: Socratic Reflections from Plato to Foucault". [[University of California Press]].
8. Lacewing, Michael. "Nietzsche's perspectivism". Routledge.
9. Conant, James F.. (2005). "The Dialectic of Perspectivism, I". Philosophia Press.
10. Miner, Robert. (2017). "Nietzsche and Montaigne". [[Palgrave Macmillan]].
11. Van Riel, Gerd. (2017). "Plato and the Power of Images". Brill.
12. Davis, Bret W.. (2018). "Buddhist Philosophy: A Comparative Approach". [[Wiley-Blackwell]].
13. Stroud, Scott R.. (July 2014). "Anekāntavāda and engaged rhetorical pluralism: explicating Jaina views on perspectivism, violence, and rhetoric". Advances in the History of Rhetoric.
14. Connolly, Tim. (November 2011). "Perspectivism as a way of knowing in the Zhuangzi". Dao.
15. (August 2014). "Perspectivism". [[Oxford University Press]].
16. Van den Brink, G.. (2020). "Reformed Theology and Evolutionary Theory". Eerdmans.
17. Long, A. A.. (1998). "Heraclitus (c.540–c.480 BC)". Taylor and Francis.
18. Montaigne, Michel de. (1595). "Essais". Penguin.
19. Hales, Steven D.. (2020). "Knowledge from a Human Point of View". Springer, Cham.
20. Conway, Daniel. (1999). "Nietzsche, Epistemology, and Philosophy of Science". Springer.
21. Nietzsche, Friedrich. (1887). "On the Genealogy of Morals". Vintage Books.
22. Doyle, Tsarina. (2005). "Nietzsche on the Possibility of Truth and Knowledge". Minerva.
23. Remhof, Justin. (2015). "Nietzsche's Conception of Truth: Correspondence, Coherence, or Pragmatist?". Journal of Nietzsche Studies.
24. Holmes, Oliver. (Summer 2011). "José Ortega y Gasset".
25. (2013). "Karl Jaspers' multiperspectivalism". [[Psychopathology (journal).
26. Dobson, Andrew. (2009). "An Introduction to the Politics and Philosophy of José Ortega Y Gasset". Cambridge University Press.
27. Shahibzadeh, Yadullah. (2016). "Islamism and Post-Islamism in Iran: An Intellectual History". Palgrave Macmillan.
28. Kern, Stephen. (2003). "The Culture of Time and Space, 1880–1918: With a New Preface". Harvard University Press.
29. Berry, David. (2016). "Journalism, Ethics and Society". Routledge.
30. Mou, Bo. (2009). "Substantive Perspectivism: An Essay on Philosophical Concern with Truth". [[Springer-Verlag]].
31. (2019). "Understanding Perspectivism: Scientific and Methodological Prospects". [[Routledge]].
32. Hales, Steven D.. (2020). "Knowledge from a Human Point of View". Springer, Cham.