Encyclopædia Britannica

History

Main article: History of the Encyclopædia Britannica

Past owners have included, in chronological order, the Scottish printers Colin Macfarquhar and Andrew Bell, the Scottish bookseller Archibald Constable, the Scottish publisher A. & C. Black, Horace Everett Hooper, Sears Roebuck, William Benton, and Jacqui Safra, a Swiss billionaire residing in New York.

Recent advances in information technology and the rise of electronic encyclopaedias such as Encyclopædia Britannica Ultimate Reference Suite, Encarta and Wikipedia have reduced the demand for print encyclopaedias. To remain competitive, Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. has stressed the reputation of the Britannica, reduced its price and production costs, and developed electronic versions on CD-ROM, DVD, and the World Wide Web. Since the early 1930s, the company has also promoted spin-off reference works.

Editions

The Encyclopaedia Britannica has been issued in 15 editions, with multi-volume supplements to the 3rd edition and to the 4th, 5th, and 6th editions as a group (see the Table below). The 5th and 6th editions were reprints of the 4th, and the 10th edition was only a supplement to the 9th, just as the 12th and 13th editions were supplements to the 11th. For the 15th edition (1974), the Britannica underwent a massive reorganization and became the New Encyclopaedia Britannica. The 14th and 15th editions were edited every year throughout their runs, so that later printings of each were quite different from early ones.

Throughout its history, the Britannica has had two aims: to be an excellent reference book, and to provide educational material. In 1974, the 15th edition adopted a third goal: to systematize all human knowledge.

The history of the Britannica can be divided into five eras, punctuated by changes in management or reorganization of the encyclopaedia.

1768–1824

In the first era (1st–6th editions, 1768–1824), the Britannica was managed and published by its founders, Colin Macfarquhar and Andrew Bell, by Archibald Constable, and by others.

The Britannica was first published in serial instalments between December 1768 and about August 1771 in Edinburgh as the Encyclopædia Britannica, or, A Dictionary of Arts and Sciences, compiled upon a New Plan. The new plan in question was an organizational one, namely to include two kinds of typographically distinct entries (articles and longer "treatises") in a single alphabetical sequence. In principle, "treatises" were to cover the arts and sciences, leaving articles to deal with their subordinate objects. The idea may have been inspired by Dennis de Coetlogon's Universal History of Arts and Sciences, an alphabetical encyclopaedia that contained only treatises. Regardless, the Britannica continued to intermix formally distinguished articles and treatises through the 10th edition.

According to Arthur Herman's book How the Scots Invented the Modern World, the Encyclopaedia Britannica is one of the most enduring legacies of the Scottish Enlightenment. It is important to be more specific, however, about how the early Britannica was and was not Scottish and a monument to the Scottish Enlightenment. The two publishers and William Smellie, whom they engaged to compile the work, were all Scots. Much of the first edition was compiled by Smellie from Scottish sources. At the same time, despite working in Edinburgh, the centre of the Scottish Enlightenment, neither Smellie nor James Tytler, the editor of the second edition, arranged for contributions from any local luminaries. Nor does the work seem to have been much noticed by participants in the Scottish Enlightenment before its third edition. Likewise, it is significant that the title chosen was the Encyclopaedia Britannica (and not the Encyclopaedia Scotorum, or 'Scottish Encyclopaedia'). Indeed, by the time of the third edition, the Britannica was starting to evolve into a symbol of Britishness.

In this era, the Britannica grew significantly in size, sales, and reputation. Just as important were changes to the way it was compiled and edited. On his tombstone, Smellie was characterized as the editor of the first edition of the Britannica, but he was not an editor in anything like the sense in which Macvey Napier, who edited the Supplement to the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Editions, was. Smellie compiled nearly all the articles in the first edition himself, although we know he had minor help from at least one contributor, James Anderson, who wrote the articles "Dictionary," "Pneumatics," and "Smoke." For the third edition and its Supplement, editors still compiled the bulk of the articles, but they were assisted by dozens of collaborators. We know of thirty-five who wrote for the third edition, for example, some of them named in the preface, including the chemist Joseph Black and the natural philosopher John Robison. Then, by the time of the Supplement, Napier had become mostly a managing editor. He still wrote some articles, but his main job was recruiting collaborators, for the prospectus stipulated that "the various articles, in the Supplement, shall be written by the most Eminent Men, in the different departments of Science."

Several other encyclopaedias competed with the Britannica throughout this period, among them editions of Ephraim Chambers' and Abraham Rees's Cyclopædia, Coleridge's Encyclopædia Metropolitana, and David Brewster's Edinburgh Encyclopædia.

1827–1901

During the second era (7th–9th editions, 1827–1901), the Britannica was managed by the Edinburgh publishing firm A & C Black. Although some contributors were again recruited through friendships of the chief editors, notably Macvey Napier, others were attracted by the Britannica reputation. The contributors often came from other countries and included the world's most respected authorities in their fields. A general index of all articles was included for the first time in the 7th edition, a practice maintained until 1974.

Production of the 9th edition was overseen by Thomas Spencer Baynes, the first English-born editor-in-chief. Dubbed the "Scholar's Edition", the 9th edition is the most scholarly of all Britannicas. After 1880, Baynes was assisted by William Robertson Smith. No biographies of living persons were included. James Clerk Maxwell and Thomas Huxley were special advisors on science. However, by the close of the 19th century, the 9th edition was outdated, and the Britannica faced financial difficulties.

1901–1973

In the third era (10th–14th editions, 1901–1973), the Britannica was managed by American businessmen who introduced direct marketing and door-to-door sales. The American owners gradually simplified articles, making them less scholarly for a mass market. The 10th edition was an eleven-volume supplement (including one each of maps and an index) to the 9th, numbered as volumes 25–35, but the 11th edition was a completely new work; its owner, Horace Hooper, lavished enormous effort on the project.

When Hooper fell into financial difficulties, the Britannica was managed by Sears Roebuck for 18 years (1920–1923, 1928–1943). In 1932, the vice-president of Sears, Elkan Harrison Powell, assumed presidency of the Britannica; in 1936, he began the policy of continuous revision. This was a departure from earlier practice, in which the articles were not changed until a new edition was produced, at roughly 25-year intervals, some articles unchanged from earlier editions. Powell developed new educational products that built upon the Britannica reputation.

In 1943, Sears donated the Encyclopædia Britannica to the University of Chicago. William Benton, then a vice president of the university, provided the working capital for its operation. The stock was divided between Benton and the university, with the university holding an option on the stock. Benton became chairman of the board and managed the Britannica until his death in 1973. Benton set up the Benton Foundation, which managed the Britannica until 1996, and whose sole beneficiary was the University of Chicago. In 1968, the Britannica celebrated its bicentennial.

1974–1994

In the fourth era (1974–1994), the Britannica introduced its 15th edition, which was reorganized into three parts: the Micropædia, the Macropædia, and the Propædia. Under Mortimer J. Adler (member of the Board of Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica since its inception in 1949, and its chair from 1974; director of editorial planning for the 15th edition of Britannica from 1965), the Britannica sought not only to be a good reference work and educational tool, but to systematize all human knowledge. The absence of a separate index and the grouping of articles into parallel encyclopaedias (the Micro- and Macropædia) provoked a "firestorm of criticism" of the initial 15th edition.{{multiref2||||||||

On 9 March 1976 the US Federal Trade Commission entered an opinion and order enjoining Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. from using: a) deceptive advertising practices in recruiting sales agents and obtaining sales leads, and b) deceptive sales practices in the door-to-door presentations of its sales agents.

1994–present

In the fifth era (1994–present), digital versions have been developed and released on optical media and online.

In 1996, the Britannica was bought by Jacqui Safra at well below its estimated value, owing to the company's financial difficulties. Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. split in 1999. One part retained the company name and developed the print version, and the other, Britannica.com Incorporated, developed digital versions. Since 2001, the two companies have shared a CEO, Ilan Yeshua, who has continued Powell's strategy of introducing new products with the Britannica name. In March 2012, Britannica's president, Jorge Cauz, announced that it would not produce any new print editions of the encyclopaedia, with the 2010 15th edition being the last. The company will focus only on the online edition and other educational tools.

Britannica final print edition was in 2010, a 32-volume set. Britannica Global Edition was also printed in 2010, containing 30 volumes and 18,251 pages, with 8,500 photographs, maps, flags, and illustrations in smaller "compact" volumes, as well as over 40,000 articles written by scholars from across the world, including Nobel Prize winners. Unlike the 15th edition, it did not contain Macro- and Micropædia sections, but ran A through Z as all editions up through the 14th had. The following is Britannica description of the work:

In 2020, Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. released the Britannica All New Children's Encyclopedia: What We Know and What We Don't, an encyclopaedia aimed primarily at younger readers, covering major topics. The encyclopaedia was widely praised for bringing back the print format. It was Britannica first encyclopaedia for children since 1984.

Dedications

The Britannica was dedicated to the reigning British monarch from 1788 to 1901 and then, upon its sale to an American partnership, to the British monarch and the President of the United States. Thus, the 11th edition is "dedicated by Permission to His Majesty George the Fifth, King of Great Britain and Ireland and of the British Dominions beyond the Seas, Emperor of India, and to William Howard Taft, President of the United States of America." The order of the dedications has changed with the relative power of the United States and Britain, and with relative sales; the 1954 version of the 14th edition is "Dedicated by Permission to the Heads of the Two English-Speaking Peoples, Dwight David Eisenhower, President of the United States of America, and Her Majesty, Queen Elizabeth the Second."

Print version

From 1985, the Britannica consisted of four parts: the Micropædia, the Macropædia, the Propædia, and a two-volume index. The Britannica articles are contained in the Micro- and Macropædia, which encompass 12 and 17 volumes, respectively, each volume having roughly one thousand pages. The 2007 Macropædia has 699 in-depth articles, ranging in length from two pages to 310 pages, with references and named contributors. In contrast, the 2007 Micropædia has roughly 65,000 articles, the vast majority (about 97%) of which contain fewer than 750 words, no references, and no named contributors. The Micropædia articles are intended for quick fact-checking and to help in finding more thorough information in the Macropædia. The Macropædia articles are meant as authoritative, well-written commentaries on their subjects, as well as storehouses of information not covered elsewhere. The longest article (310 pages) is on the subject of the United States, and it resulted from merging separate articles on the individual US states. A 2013 "Global Edition" of Britannica contained approximately 40,000 articles.

Information can be found in the Britannica by following the cross-references in the Micropædia and Macropædia; these are sparse, however, averaging one cross-reference per page. Readers are instead recommended to consult the alphabetical index or the Propædia, which organizes the Britannica contents by topic.

The core of the Propædia is its "Outline of Knowledge", which aims to provide a logical framework for all human knowledge. Accordingly, the Outline is consulted by the Britannica editors to decide which articles should be included in the Micro- and Macropædia. The Outline can also be used as a study guide, as it puts subjects in their proper perspective and suggests a series of Britannica articles for the student wishing to learn a topic in depth. However, libraries have found that it is scarcely used for this purpose, and reviewers have recommended that it be dropped from the encyclopaedia. The Propædia contains colour transparencies of human anatomy and several appendices listing the staff members, advisors, and contributors to all three parts of the Britannica.

Taken together, the Micropædia and Macropædia comprise roughly 40 million words and 24,000 images. The two-volume index has 2,350 pages, listing the 228,274 topics covered in the Britannica, together with 474,675 subentries under those topics. The Britannica generally prefers British spelling over American; for example, it uses colour (not color), centre (not center), and encyclopaedia (not encyclopedia). There are some exceptions to this rule, such as defense rather than defence. Common alternative spellings are provided with cross-references such as "Color: see Colour."

Since 1936, the contents (articles) of Britannica have been revised on a regular schedule, with at least 10% of the articles considered for revision each year. According to one Britannica website, 46% of the articles in the 2007 edition were revised over the preceding three years; however, according to another Britannica website, only 35% of the articles were revised over the same period.

The alphabetization of articles in the Micropædia and Macropædia follows strict rules. Diacritical marks and non-English letters are ignored, while numerical entries such as "1812, War of" are alphabetized as if the number had been written out ("Eighteen-twelve, War of"). Articles with identical names are ordered first by persons, then by places, then by things. Rulers with identical names are organized first alphabetically by country and then by chronology; thus, Charles III of France precedes Charles I of England, listed in Britannica as the ruler of Great Britain and Ireland. (That is, they are alphabetized as if their titles were "Charles, France, 3" and "Charles, Great Britain and Ireland, 1".) Similarly, places that share names are organized alphabetically by country, then by ever-smaller political divisions.

In March 2012, the company announced that the 2010 edition would be the last printed version. This was part of a move by the company to adapt to the times and focus on its future using digital distribution. The peak year for the printed encyclopaedia was 1990, when 120,000 sets were sold, but sales had dropped to 40,000 per annum by 1996. There were 12,000 sets of the 2010 edition printed, of which 8,000 had been sold by March 2012. By late April 2012, the remaining copies of the 2010 edition had sold out at Britannica's online store. , a replica of Britannica's 1768 first edition is available via the online store.

Related printed material

Britannica Junior was first published in 1934 as 12 volumes. It was expanded to 15 volumes in 1947, and renamed Britannica Junior Encyclopædia in 1963. It was taken off the market after the 1984 printing.

A British Children's Britannica edited by John Armitage was issued in London in 1960. Its contents were determined largely by the eleven-plus standardized tests given in Britain. Britannica introduced the Children's Britannica to the US market in 1988, aimed at ages seven to 14.

In 1961, a 16-volume Young Children's Encyclopaedia was issued for children just learning to read. My First Britannica is aimed at children ages six to 12, and the Britannica Discovery Library is for children aged three to six (issued 1974 to 1991). Compton's by Britannica, first published in 2007, incorporating the former Compton's Encyclopedia, is aimed at 10- to 17-year-olds and consists of 26 volumes and 11,000 pages.

There have been, and are, several abridged Britannica encyclopaedias. The single-volume Britannica Concise Encyclopædia has 28,000 short articles condensing the larger 32-volume Britannica; there are authorized translations in languages such as Chinese created by Encyclopedia of China Publishing House and Vietnamese.

Since 1938, Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. has also published an annual Book of the Year to 'update' the encyclopaedia proper: this covers the past year's events and presents a variety of updated statistics (eg as to national populations, Nobel Prize winners, and the like). A given edition of the Book of the Year is named in terms of the year of its publication, though the volume actually covers the events and statistics of the previous year.

The company also publishes several specialized reference works, such as Shakespeare: The Essential Guide to the Life and Works of the Bard (2006).

Optical disc, online, and mobile versions

The Britannica Ultimate Reference Suite 2012 DVD contains over 100,000 articles. This includes regular Britannica articles, as well as others drawn from the Britannica Student Encyclopædia, and the Britannica Elementary Encyclopædia. The package includes a range of supplementary content including maps, videos, sound clips, animations and web links. It also offers study tools and dictionary and thesaurus entries from Merriam-Webster.

Britannica Online is a website with more than 120,000 articles and is updated regularly. It has daily features, updates and links to news reports from The New York Times and the BBC. , roughly 60% of Encyclopædia Britannica's revenue came from online operations, of which around 15% came from subscriptions to the consumer version of the websites. , subscriptions were available on a yearly, monthly or weekly basis. Special subscription plans are offered to schools, colleges and libraries; such institutional subscribers constitute an important part of Britannica's business. Beginning in early 2007, the Britannica made articles freely available if they are hyperlinked from an external site. Non-subscribers are served pop-ups and advertising.

On 20 February 2007, Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. announced that it was working with mobile phone search company AskMeNow to launch a mobile encyclopaedia. Users would be able to send a question via text message, and AskMeNow would search Britannica 28,000-article concise encyclopaedia to return an answer to the query. Daily topical features sent directly to users' mobile phones were also planned.

On 3 June 2008, an initiative to facilitate collaboration between online expert and amateur scholarly contributors for Britannica's online content (in the spirit of a wiki), with editorial oversight from Britannica staff, was announced. Approved contributions would be credited, though contributing automatically grants Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. perpetual, irrevocable licence to those contributions.

On 22 January 2009, Britannica's president, Jorge Cauz, announced that the company would be accepting edits and additions to the online Britannica website from the public. The published edition of the encyclopaedia would not be affected by the changes. Individuals wishing to edit the Britannica website would have to register under their real name and address prior to editing or submitting their content. All edits submitted would be reviewed and checked and will have to be approved by the encyclopaedia's professional staff. Contributions from non-academic users would sit in a separate section from the expert-generated Britannica content, as would content submitted by non-Britannica scholars. Articles written by users, if vetted and approved, would also only be available in a special section of the website, separate from the professional articles. Official Britannica material would carry a "Britannica Checked" stamp, to distinguish it from the user-generated content.

On 14 September 2010, Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. announced a partnership with mobile phone development company Concentric Sky to launch a series of iPhone products aimed at the K–12 market. On 20 July 2011, Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. announced that Concentric Sky had ported the Britannica Kids product line to Intel's Intel Atom-based Netbooks and on 26 October 2011 that it had launched its encyclopaedia as an iPad app. In 2010, Britannica released Britannica ImageQuest, a database of images.

In March 2012, it was announced that the company would cease printing the encyclopaedia set, and that it would focus on its online version.

On 7 June 2018, Britannica released a Google Chrome extension, "Britannica Insights", which shows snippets of information from Britannica Online whenever the user performs a Google Search, in a box to the right of Google's results. Britannica Insights was also available as a Firefox extension but this was taken down due to a code review issue.

Personnel and management

Contributors

The print version of the Britannica has 4,411 contributors, many eminent in their fields, such as Nobel laureate economist Milton Friedman, astronomer Carl Sagan, and surgeon Michael DeBakey. Roughly a quarter of the contributors are deceased, some as long ago as 1947 (Alfred North Whitehead), while another quarter are retired or emeritus. Most (approximately 98%) contribute to only a single article; however, 64 contributed to three articles, 23 contributed to four articles, 10 contributed to five articles, and 8 contributed to more than five articles. An exceptionally prolific contributor is Christine Sutton of the University of Oxford, who contributed 24 articles on particle physics.

While Britannica authors have included writers such as Albert Einstein, Marie Curie, and Leon Trotsky, as well as notable independent encyclopaedists such as Isaac Asimov, some have been criticized for lack of expertise. In 1911, the historian George L. Burr wrote:

Staff

, in the 15th edition of Britannica, Dale Hoiberg, a sinologist, was listed as Britannica Senior Vice President and editor-in-chief. Among his predecessors as editors-in-chief were Hugh Chisholm (1902–1924), James Louis Garvin (1926–1932), Franklin Henry Hooper (1932–1938), Walter Yust (1938–1960), Harry Ashmore (1960–1963), Warren E. Preece (1964–1968, 1969–1975), Sir William Haley (1968–1969), Philip W. Goetz (1979–1991), and Robert McHenry (1992–1997).

Anita Wolff was listed as the Deputy Editor and Theodore Pappas as Executive Editor. Prior Executive Editors include John V. Dodge (1950–1964) and Philip W. Goetz.

Paul T. Armstrong remains the longest working employee of Encyclopædia Britannica. He began his career there in 1934, eventually earning the positions of treasurer, vice president, and chief financial officer in his 58 years with the company, before retiring in 1992.

The 2007 editorial staff of the Britannica included five Senior Editors and nine Associate Editors, supervised by Dale Hoiberg and four others. The editorial staff helped to write the articles of the Micropædia and some sections of the Macropædia.

Editorial advisors

As of 2012, Britannica had an editorial board of advisors, which included a number of distinguished figures, primarily scholars from a variety of disciplines.

The Propædia and its Outline of Knowledge were produced by dozens of editorial advisors under the direction of Mortimer J. Adler. Roughly half of these advisors have since died, including some of the Outline's chief architects – Rene Dubos (d. 1982), Loren Eiseley (d. 1977), Harold D. Lasswell (d. 1978), Mark Van Doren (d. 1972), Peter Ritchie Calder (d. 1982) and Mortimer J. Adler (d. 2001). The Propædia also lists just under 4,000 advisors who were consulted for the unsigned Micropædia articles.

Corporate structure

During much of the 20th century, the Britannica had a significant ownership stake from the University of Chicago, with many people associated with the university serving senior positions in the organization.331-332 During the mid-20th century, managers and executives at the Britannica company were lavishly rewarded due to the healthy profit encyclopaedia sales generated, with division managers at the top of the sales organization earning an average salary of $125,000 in 1958 (adjusting for inflation, some $ in current USD).329

From 1974, the company was controlled by the Benton Foundation, of which the University of Chicago was the sole beneficiary. In January 1996, the Britannica was purchased from the Benton Foundation by billionaire Swiss financier Jacqui Safra, who serves as its current chair of the board. In 1997, Don Yannias, a long-time associate and investment advisor of Safra, became CEO of Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc.

In 1999, a new subsidiary company, Britannica.com Incorporated, was created to develop digital versions of the Britannica; Yannias assumed the role of CEO in the new company, while his former position at the parent company remained vacant for two years. Yannias' tenure at Britannica.com Incorporated was marked by missteps, considerable lay-offs, and financial losses. In 2001, Yannias was replaced by Ilan Yeshua, who reunited the leadership of the two companies. Yannias later returned to investment management, but remains on Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc's Board of Directors.

In 2003, former management consultant Jorge Aguilar-Cauz was appointed President of Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc. Cauz is the senior executive and reports directly to the Britannica Board of Directors. Cauz has been pursuing alliances with other companies and extending the Britannica brand to new educational and reference products, continuing the strategy pioneered by former CEO Elkan Harrison Powell in the mid-1930s.

Sales and marketing

Although prior to 1920 the Britannica was primarily sold by mail-order, after that time the Britannica was almost exclusively sold by door-to-door salesmen, who often used high-pressure sales tactics or outright deception in order to secure purchases of the expensive work,317-330 from which they gained a significant commission. This commission in the United States in 1971 was $120–200 (around $-$ adjusted for inflation) per sale. These high-pressure sales tactics resulted in high levels of turnover among Britannica salesmen, with the company often exaggerating the ease of making a sale to employees, as well as engaging in deceptive job advertising in order to entice people to become salesmen.317-330 The Britannica was sued several times by the American Federal Trade Commission for deceptive practices.317-330 These practices were common among American encyclopaedia companies.317-330 The development of the significant sales force began in 1932, with most senior leadership of the company by the late 20th century coming from the sales division.

While early on the Britannica was marketed to adults and in particular during the 19th and early 20th centuries, to an elite educated audience,152-153 by the mid 20th century, the Britannica (as well as other American encyclopaedias) were primarily marketed to middle-class parents who wished to seek a good education for their children, despite the text not being aimed at a child's reading level.317-330 During the 20th century, the Britannica differentiated itself from other encyclopaedias by using its long pedigree to present itself as a premium brand. Once the encyclopaedia was purchased, it was typically only opened a few times a year by an average owner.

Competition

As the Britannica is a general encyclopaedia, it does not seek to compete with specialized encyclopaedias such as the Encyclopaedia of Mathematics or the Dictionary of the Middle Ages, which can devote much more space to their chosen topics. In its first years, the Britannica main competitor was the general encyclopaedia of Ephraim Chambers and, soon thereafter, Rees's Cyclopædia and Coleridge's Encyclopædia Metropolitana. In the 20th century, successful competitors included Collier's Encyclopedia, the Encyclopedia Americana, and the World Book Encyclopedia. Nevertheless, from the 9th edition onwards, the Britannica was widely considered to have the greatest authority of any general English-language encyclopaedia, especially because of its broad coverage and eminent authors. The print version of the Britannica was also thus significantly more expensive than its competitors.

Since the early 1990s, the Britannica has faced new challenges from digital information sources. The Internet, facilitated by the development of search engines, has grown into a common source of information for many people, and provides easy access to reliable original sources and expert opinions, thanks in part to initiatives such as Google Books, MIT's release of its educational materials and the open PubMed Central library of the National Library of Medicine.

The Internet tends to provide more current coverage than print media, due to the ease with which material on the Internet can be updated and then made available to users. In rapidly changing fields such as science, technology, politics, culture and modern history, the Britannica has struggled to stay up to date, a problem first analysed systematically by its former editor Walter Yust. Eventually, the Britannica turned to focus more on its online edition.

Print encyclopaedias

The Encyclopædia Britannica has been compared with other print encyclopaedias, both qualitatively and quantitatively. A well-known comparison is that of Kenneth Kister, who gave a qualitative and quantitative comparison of the 1993 Britannica with two comparable encyclopaedias, Collier's Encyclopedia and the Encyclopedia Americana. For the quantitative analysis, ten articles were selected at random—circumcision, Charles Drew, Galileo, Philip Glass, heart disease, IQ, panda bear, sexual harassment, Shroud of Turin and Uzbekistan—and letter grades of A–D or F were awarded in four categories: coverage, accuracy, clarity, and recency. In all four categories and for all three encyclopaedias, the four average grades fell between B− and B+, chiefly because none of the encyclopaedias had an article on sexual harassment in 1994. In the accuracy category, the Britannica received one "D" and seven "A"s, Encyclopedia Americana received eight "A"s, and Collier's received one "D" and seven "A"s; thus, Britannica received an average score of 92% for accuracy to Americana 95% and Collier's 92%. In the timeliness category, Britannica averaged an 86% to Americana 90% and Collier's 85%.

Digital encyclopaedias on optical media

The most notable competitor of the Britannica among CD/DVD-ROM digital encyclopaedias was Encarta, now discontinued, a modern multimedia encyclopaedia that incorporated three print encyclopaedias: Funk & Wagnalls, Collier's, and the New Merit Scholar's Encyclopedia. Encarta was the top-selling multimedia encyclopaedia, based on total US retail sales from January 2000 to February 2006. Both occupied the same price range, with the 2007 Encyclopædia Britannica Ultimate CD or DVD costing US$40–50 and the Microsoft Encarta Premium 2007 DVD costing US$45.

The Britannica disc contains 100,000 articles and Merriam-Webster's Dictionary and Thesaurus (US only) and offers primary and secondary school editions. Encarta contained 66,000 articles, a user-friendly Visual Browser, interactive maps, math, language, and homework tools, a US and UK dictionary, and a youth edition. Like Encarta, the digital Britannica has been criticized for being biased towards United States audiences; the United Kingdom-related articles are updated less often, maps of the United States are more detailed than those of other countries, and it lacks a UK dictionary. Like the Britannica, Encarta was available online by subscription, although some content could be accessed for free.

Wikipedia

Main article: Wikipedia

The main online alternative to Britannica is Wikipedia. The key differences between the two lie in accessibility; the model of participation they bring to an encyclopaedic project; their respective style sheets and editorial policies; relative ages; the number of subjects treated; the number of languages in which articles are written and made available; and their underlying economic models: unlike Britannica, Wikipedia is not-for-profit, does not carry advertising on its site, and is not connected with traditional profit- and contract-based publishing distribution networks.

Britannicas articles either have known authorship or a set of possible authors (the editorial staff). With the exception of the editorial staff, most Britannica contributors are experts in their field—some are Nobel laureates. By contrast, the articles on Wikipedia are written by people of unknown degrees of expertise; most do not claim any particular expertise, and of those who do, many are anonymous and have no verifiable credentials. It is for this lack of institutional vetting or certification that former Britannica editor-in-chief Robert McHenry noted his belief in 2004 that Wikipedia could not hope to rival the Britannica in accuracy.

In 2005, the journal Nature chose articles from both websites in a wide range of science topics and sent them to what it called "relevant" field experts for peer review. The experts then compared the competing articles—one from each site on a given topic—side by side, but were not told which article came from which site. Nature got back 42 usable reviews. The journal found just eight serious errors, such as general misunderstandings of vital concepts: four from each site. It also discovered many factual errors, omissions or misleading statements: 162 in Wikipedia and 123 in Britannica, an average of 3.86 mistakes per article for Wikipedia and 2.92 for Britannica.

Although *Britannica *was revealed as the more accurate encyclopaedia, with fewer errors, in its rebuttal, it called *Nature'''s study flawed and misleading and called for a "prompt" retraction. It noted that two of the articles in the study were taken from a Britannica yearbook and not the encyclopaedia, and another two were from Compton's Encyclopedia (called the *Britannica Student Encyclopedia'' on the company's website).

Nature defended its story and declined to retract, stating that, as it was comparing Wikipedia with the web version of Britannica, it used whatever relevant material was available on Britannica website.{{cite press release | access-date = 21 October 2006 | archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20060325124447/https://www.nature.com/press_releases/Britannica_response.pdf | archive-date = 25 March 2006 | url-status = dead

For the 15th anniversary of Wikipedia, the Telegraph published two opinion pieces which compared Wikipedia to Britannica and falsely claimed that Britannica had gone bankrupt in 1996. In a January 2016 press release, Britannica responded by calling Wikipedia "an impressive achievement" but argued that critics should avoid "false comparisons" to Britannica in terms of differing models and purposes.

Critical and popular assessments

Reputation

Since the 3rd edition, the Britannica has enjoyed a popular and critical reputation for general excellence, though this reputation has not been without its critics. The 3rd and 9th editions were pirated for sale in the United States, beginning with Dobson's Encyclopædia. On the release of the 14th edition, Time magazine dubbed the Britannica the "Patriarch of the Library". In a related advertisement, naturalist William Beebe was quoted as saying that the Britannica was "beyond comparison because there is no competitor". References to the Britannica can be found throughout English literature, most notably in one of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle favourite Sherlock Holmes stories, "The Red-Headed League". The tale was highlighted by the Lord Mayor of London, Gilbert Inglefield, at the bicentennial of the Britannica.

The Britannica has a reputation for summarizing knowledge. To further their education, some people have devoted themselves to reading the entire Britannica, taking anywhere from three to 22 years to do so. When Fat'h Ali became the Shah of Persia in 1797, he was given a set of the Britannica 3rd edition; after reading the complete set, he extended his royal title to include "Most Formidable Lord and Master of the Encyclopædia Britannica".

Writer George Bernard Shaw has claimed to have read the complete 9th edition, except for the science articles; Richard Evelyn Byrd took the Britannica as reading material for his five-month stay at the South Pole in 1934; and Philip Beaver read it during a sailing expedition. More recently, A. J. Jacobs, an editor at Esquire magazine, read the entire 2002 version of the 15th edition, describing his experiences in the well-received 2004 book The Know-It-All: One Man's Humble Quest to Become the Smartest Person in the World. Only two people are known to have read two independent editions: the author C. S. Forester and Amos Urban Shirk, an American businessman who read the 11th and 14th editions, devoting roughly three hours per night for four and a half years to read the 11th.

Awards

The CD/DVD-ROM version of the Britannica, Encyclopædia Britannica Ultimate Reference Suite, received the 2004 Distinguished Achievement Award from the Association of Educational Publishers. On 15 July 2009, Encyclopædia Britannica was awarded a spot as one of "Top Ten Superbrands in the UK" by a panel of more than 2,000 independent reviewers, as reported by the BBC.

Coverage of topics

Topics are chosen in part by reference to the Propædia "Outline of Knowledge". The bulk of the 15th edition of the Britannica is devoted to geography (26% of the Macropædia), biography (14%), biology and medicine (11%), literature (7%), physics and astronomy (6%), religion (5%), art (4%), Western philosophy (4%), and law (3%). A complementary study of the Micropædia found that geography accounted for 25% of articles, science 18%, social sciences 17%, biography 17%, and all other humanities 25%. Writing in 1992, one reviewer judged that the "range, depth, and catholicity of coverage [of the Britannica] are unsurpassed by any other general Encyclopaedia."

The Britannica does not cover topics in equal detail; for example, the whole of Buddhism and most other religions is covered in a single Macropædia article, whereas 14 articles are devoted to Christianity, comprising nearly half of all religion articles. The Britannica covers 50,479 biographies, 5,999 of them about women, with 11.87% being British citizens and 25.51% US citizens. However, the Britannica has been lauded as the least biased of general Encyclopaedias marketed to Western readers and praised for its biographies of important women of all eras.

Criticism of editorial decisions

Harvey Einbinder in the Myth of the Britannica criticized the 11th edition for the inaccessibility of the text for laymen, saying that many of its articles were too technical for people unfamiliar to the subject to understand.152-153 He made similar criticisms of many of the mathematics and science articles of the then-current 14th edition.236-250

On rare occasions, the Britannica has been criticized for its editorial choices. Given its roughly constant size, the encyclopaedia has needed to reduce or eliminate some topics to accommodate others, resulting in controversial decisions. The initial 15th edition (1974–1985) was faulted for having reduced or eliminated coverage of children's literature, military decorations, and the French poet Joachim du Bellay; editorial mistakes were also alleged, such as inconsistent sorting of Japanese biographies. Its elimination of the index was condemned, as was the apparently arbitrary division of articles into the Micropædia and Macropædia. Summing up, one critic called the initial 15th edition a "qualified failure ... [that] cares more for juggling its format than for preserving." More recently, reviewers from the American Library Association were surprised to find that most educational articles had been eliminated from the 1992 Macropædia, along with the article on psychology. Harvey Einbinder in The Myth of the Britannica criticized the practice of condensing entries in the 14th edition, which usually involved simply removing large amounts of the text rather than attempting to condense it by rewriting, resulting in what he considered to be considerable reduction in the quality of the articles.151-168

Some very few Britannica-appointed contributors are mistaken. A notorious instance from the Britannica early years is the rejection of Newtonian gravity by George Gleig, the chief editor of the 3rd edition (1788–1797), who wrote that gravity was caused by the classical element of fire. The Britannica has also staunchly defended a scientific approach to cultural topics, as it did with William Robertson Smith's articles on religion in the 9th edition, particularly his article stating that the Bible was not historically accurate (1875).

Other criticisms

The Britannica has received criticism, particularly as editions become outdated. It is expensive to produce a completely new edition of the Britannica, and its editors delay for as long as fiscally sensible (usually about 25 years).

For example, despite continuous revision, the 14th edition became outdated after 35 years (1929–1964). When American physicist Harvey Einbinder detailed its failings in his 1964 book, The Myth of the Britannica, the encyclopaedia was provoked to produce the 15th edition, which required 10 years of work. Editors have struggled at times to keep the Britannica current: one 1994 critic writes, "It is not difficult to find articles that are out-of-date or in need of revision", noting that the longer Macropædia articles are more likely to be outdated than the shorter Micropædia articles. Information in the Micropædia is sometimes inconsistent with the corresponding Macropædia article(s), mainly because of the failure to update one or the other. The bibliographies of the Macropædia articles have been criticized for being more out-of-date than the articles themselves.

In 2005, a 12-year-old schoolboy in Britain found several inaccuracies in the Britannica entries on Poland and wildlife in Eastern Europe. In 2010, an entry about the Irish Civil War, which incorrectly described it as having been fought between the north and south of Ireland, was discussed in the Irish press following a decision by the Department of Education and Science to pay for online access.

Writing about the 3rd edition (1788–1797), Britannica chief editor George Gleig observed that "perfection seems to be incompatible with the nature of works constructed on such a plan and embracing such a variety of subjects." In March 2006, the Britannica wrote, "we in no way mean to imply that Britannica is error-free; we have never made such a claim". However, the Britannica sales department had previously made a well-known claim in 1962 regarding the 14th edition that "[i]t is truth. It is unquestionable fact." The sentiment of the 2006 statement was also reflected in the introduction to the first edition of the Britannica, written by its original editor William Smellie:

Edition summary

Main article: History of the Encyclopædia Britannica

Notes

References

References

1. Jeff Loveland, "Why Encyclopedias Got Bigger ... and Smaller," ''Information and Culture'' 47 (2012): 244.
2. Paul Kruse, "The Story of the ''Encyclopaedia Britannica'', 1768-1943," PhD dissertation (University of Chicago, 1958), 389.
3. M. A. Khan, ''The Principles and Practice of Library Science'' (New Delhi: Sarup and Sons, 1996), 281.
4. Carmody, Tim. (14 March 2012). "Wikipedia Didn't Kill Britannica. Windows Did".
5. Cooke, Richard. (17 February 2020). "Wikipedia Is the Last Best Place on the Internet".
6. Bosman, Julie. (13 March 2012). "After 244 Years, Encyclopaedia Britannica Stops the Presses". [[The New York Times]].
7. McArdle, Megan. (15 March 2012). "Encyclopaedia Britannica Goes Out of Print, Won't Be Missed". [[The Atlantic]].
8. (4 Jan 1996). "Britannica sold by Benton Foundation". University of Chicago Chronicle.
9. Kearney, Christine. (14 March 2012). "Encyclopaedia Britannica: After 244 years in print, only digital copies sold".
10. (1954). "Encyclopaedia".
11. (2007). "Encyclopedias and Dictionaries". Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc..
12. Goetz, Philip W.. (2007). "The New Encyclopædia Britannica". Encyclopaedia Britannica Incorporated.
13. Richard Yeo, ''Encyclopaedic Visions: Scientific Dictionaries and Enlightenment Culture'' (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001), 176.
14. Kafker and Loveland, "William Smellie's Edition," 23-24.
15. Jeff Loveland, “Unifying Knowledge and Dividing Disciplines: The Development of Treatises in the ''Encyclopaedia Britannica'',” ''Book History'' 9 (2006): 73-74.
16. Herman, Arthur. (2002). "How the Scots Invented the Modern World". Three Rivers Press.
17. Richard B. Sher, ''The Enlightenment & the Book: Scottish Authors & their Publishers in Eighteenth-Century Britain, Ireland & America'' (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2006), 135-36.
18. Frank A. Kafker and Jeff Loveland, "William Smellie's Edition (1768-1771): A Modest Start," in ''The Early Britannica: The Growth of an Outstanding Encyclopedia'' (Oxford: Voltaire Foundation, 2009), 67.
19. Yeo, ''Encyclopaedic Visions'', 172-73.
20. Kathleen Hardesty Doig ''et al''., “Colin Macfarquhar, George Gleig, and Possibly James Tytler's Edition (1788-97): The Attainment of Recognition and Eminence,” in ''Early Britannica'', 249.
21. Kafker and Loveland, "William Smellie's Edition," 19-20.
22. Doig ''et al''., "Colin Macfarquhar, George Gleig, and possibly James Tytler's Edition," 169-71.
23. Yeo, ''Encyclopaedic Visions'', 251, 257.
24. Kogan, Herman. (1958). "The Great EB: The Story of the Encyclopædia Britannica". The [[University of Chicago Press]].
25. {{Cite SBDEL
26. {{Cite EB9
27. {{Cite EB9
28. ''Chicago Tribune'', 22 February 1945.
29. ''Chicago Tribune'', 28 January 1943.
30. Feder, Barnaby J.. (19 December 1995). "Deal Is Set for Encyclopaedia Britannica". [[The New York Times]].
31. Mortimer J. Adler, ''A Guidebook to Learning: for the lifelong pursuit of wisdom''. Macmillan Publishing Company, New York, 1986, p. 88.
32. "In the Matter of Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc. et al.".
33. Pepitone, Julianne. (13 March 2012). "Encyclopedia Britannica to stop printing books". [[CNN]].
34. "The new Children's Britannica: a fantastic voyage through the history of the world".
35. (19 November 2020). "Why printed encyclopedias for children are more important than ever".
36. (8 October 2020). "Britannica All New Children's Encyclopedia edited by Christopher Lloyd".
37. (1910). "Encyclopædia Britannica".
38. (1954). "Encyclopædia Britannica".
39. "Britannica Global Edition".
40. Goetz, Philip W.. (2007). "The New Encyclopædia Britannica". Encyclopaedia Britannica Incorporated.
41. [[American Library Association]]. (1992). "Purchasing an Encyclopedia: 12 Points to Consider". Booklist.
42. (2007). "Defense mechanism". Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc..
43. "Encyclopædia Britannica: School & Library Site, promotional materials for the 2007 ''Britannica''".
44. "Australian Encyclopædia Britannica, promotional materials for the 2007 ''Britannica''".
45. Goetz, Philip W.. (2007). "The New Encyclopædia Britannica". Encyclopaedia Britannica Incorporated.
46. (13 March 2012). "Change: It's OK. Really.".
47. (14 March 2012). "Encyclopaedia Britannica to end print editions". Fox News.
48. Bosman, Julie. (13 March 2012). "After 244 Years, Encyclopaedia Britannica Stops the Presses". The New York Times.
49. "1768 Encyclopaedia Britannica Replica Set".
50. Britannica Junior Encyclopædia, 1984.
51. ''Children's Britannica''. 1960. Encyclopædia Britannica Limited. London, England.
52. ''Encyclopædia Britannica'', 1988.
53. "Britannica Discovery Library (issued 1974–1991)". Encyclopædia Britannica (UK) Limited.
54. (July 2018). "2007 Compton's by Britannica". Encyclopædia Britannica (UK) Limited}}{{dead link.
55. "2003 Britannica Concise Encyclopedia". Encyclopædia Britannica (UK) Limited.
56. Quân, Phạm Hoàng. (25 July 2015). "Tên theo chủ: Qua vụ Google và vụ Britannica tiếng Việt".
57. (October 2020). "Imperial China: The Definitive Visual History". [[DK (publisher).
58. (13 January 2015). "Britannica Concise Encyclopedia rendered into Vietnamese". [[Tuổi Trẻ]] News.
59. Long, Nguyễn Việt. (9 July 2015). "Chuyện kể từ người tham gia làm Britannica tiếng Việt".
60. "Britannica 2012 Ultimate Reference DVD".
61. (2014). "Webmaster and Blogger Tools".
62. Charlton, Graham. (10 February 2009). "Q&A: Ian Grant of Encyclopædia Britannica UK [interview]". Econsultancy.
63. "Britannica Online Store—BT Click&Buy".
64. "Instructions for linking to the ''Britannica'' articles".
65. (21 February 2007). "Encyclopædia Britannica Selects AskMeNow to Launch Mobile Encyclopedia". [[AskMeNow]], Incorporated.
66. Cauz, Jorge. (3 June 2008). "Collaboration and the Voices of Experts".
67. Van Buskirk, Eliot. (9 June 2008). "Encyclopædia Britannica To Follow Modified Wikipedia Model".
68. Turton, Stuart. (9 June 2008). "Encyclopaedia Britannica dips toe in Wiki waters".
69. "Encyclopædia Britannica, Incorporated, Corporate Site".
70. Hunt, Samantha Rose. (23 January 2009). "Britannica looking to give Wikipedia a run for its money with online editing".
71. Akhtar, Naved. (25 January 2009). "Encyclopædia Britannica takes on Wikipedia".
72. Moore, Matthew. (23 January 2009). "Encyclopaedia Britannica fights back against Wikipedia". The Telegraph.
73. Sweeney, Claire. (22 January 2009). "Britannica 2.0 shows Wikipedia how it's done".
74. (24 January 2009). "Britannica reaches out to the web".
75. (14 September 2010). "New Britannica Kids Apps Make Learning Fun". Encyclopædia_Britannica, Incorporated.
76. (20 July 2011). "Encyclopædia Britannica to supply world-leading educational apps to Intel AppUp center". Encyclopædia_Britannica, Incorporated.
77. "About {{pipe}} Mobile, Web and Enterprise {{pipe}} Design and Development". Concentricsky.com.
78. (26 October 2011). "Encyclopaedia Britannica App Now Available for iPad".
79. (2015). "Britannica ImageQuest: One image database to rule them all {{!}} Reference Online".
80. (14 March 2012). "Encyclopaedia Britannica stops printing after more than 200 years". The Telegraph.
81. McCarthy, Tom. (13 March 2012). "Encyclopædia Britannica halts print publication after 244 years". [[The Guardian]].
82. (7 June 2018). "Encyclopædia Britannica's new Chrome extension is a simple fix to Google misinformation". The Verge.
83. "Britannica Insights Firefox extension missing · Issue #6081 · mozilla/addons-frontend".
84. Goetz, Philip W.. (2007). "The New Encyclopædia Britannica". Encyclopaedia Britannica Incorporated.
85. "Christine Sutton". Britannica Group.
86. Brenner, Michael. (1998). "The Renaissance of Jewish Culture in Weimar Germany". Yale University Press.
87. Keen, Andrew. (2007). "The Cult of the Amateur: How Blogs, MySpace, YouTube, and the Rest of Today's User-generated Media are Destroying Our Economy, Our Culture, and Our Values". Doubleday.
88. "Isaac Asimov".
89. Burr, George L.. (1911). "The Encyclopædia Britannica: A Dictionary of Arts, Sciences, Literature and General Information". American Historical Review.
90. Goetz, Philip W.. (2007). "The New Encyclopædia Britannica". Encyclopaedia Britannica Incorporated.
91. (26 August 1940). "Milestones, Aug. 26, 1940".
92. Kister, K. F.. (1994). "Kister's Best Encyclopedias: A Comparative Guide to General and Specialized Encyclopedias". Oryx Press.
93. (20 January 2001). "Armstrong". Chicago Tribune.
94. (2007). "Biochemical Components of Organisms". Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc.
95. Goetz, Philip W.. (2007). "The New Encyclopædia Britannica". Encyclopaedia Britannica Incorporated.
96. "Encyclopædia Britannica Board of Editors".
97. Goetz, Philip W.. (2007). "The New Encyclopædia Britannica". Encyclopaedia Britannica Incorporated.
98. Goetz, Philip W.. (2007). "The New Encyclopædia Britannica". Encyclopaedia Britannica Incorporated.
99. (4 January 1996). "Britannica sold by Benton Foundation". University of Chicago Chronicle.
100. (4 March 1997). "Encyclopædia Britannica Announces Appointment of Don Yannias As Chief Executive Officer". Encyclopædia Britannica, Incorporated.
101. Abramson, Ronna. (9 April 2001). "Look Under "M" for Mess—Company Business and Marketing".
102. (16 May 2001). "Ilan Yeshua Named Britannica CEO. Veteran Executive to Consolidate Operations of Encyclopædia Britannica and Britannica.com". Encyclopædia Britannica, Incorporated.
103. Goetz, Philip W.. (2007). "The New Encyclopædia Britannica". Encyclopaedia Britannica Incorporated.
104. Gilmore, Nicholas. (2017-08-30). "Death of a Sales Scheme: Encyclopedia Shysters of the Door-to-Door Age".
105. Barnett, Laura. (2012-03-14). "Death of a salesman: no more door-to-door Britannica". The Guardian.
106. Einbinder, Harvey ''[[iarchive:mythofthebritannica. The Myth of the Britannica]]''. New York: [[Grove Press]], 1964 (OCLC 152581687)/ London: MacGibbon & Kee, 1964 (OCLC 807782651) / New York: Johnson Reprint Corp., 1972. (OCLC 286856)
107. Lichtenstein, Grace. (1971-09-26). "Encyclopedia Sale Abuses Go On Despite New Laws". The New York Times.
108. (2006). "Crisis at Encyclopaedia Britannica". [[Kellogg School of Management]].
109. (1999). "Accessibility of information on the web". Nature.
110. (1999). "Searching the Web: general and scientific information access". IEEE Communications Magazine.
111. "Electronic publishing takes journals into a new realm". American Chemical Society.
112. (14 December 2012). "Britannica ends its print edition". [[BBC News]].
113. Kister, Kenneth F.. (1994). "Kister's best encyclopedias : a comparative guide to general and specialized encyclopedias". Oryx Press.
114. "Microsoft Encarta—Premium 2007: Overview". [[Microsoft]].
115. (27 March 2007). "Digital encyclopedia has wealth of information". [[The Washington Times]].
116. (May 2017). "The Britannica Store".
117. "Amazon.com: Microsoft Encarta Premium 2007: Software".
118. Seymour, Ursula. (9 November 2006). "Encyclopedia face-off: Encarta vs Britannica". IDG.
119. "Encarta's Encyclopedia Article Center".
120. Tancer, Bill. (1 May 2007). "Look Who's Using Wikipedia".
121. Tancer, Bill. (1 March 2007). "Wikipedia, Search and School Homework".
122. Woodson, Alex. (8 July 2007). "Wikipedia remains go-to site for online news". Reuters.
123. McHenry, Robert. (15 November 2004). "The Faith-Based Encyclopedia". TCS Daily.
124. Giles, J.. (2005). "Internet encyclopaedias go head to head: Jimmy Wales' Wikipedia comes close to Britannica in terms of the accuracy of its science entries". [[Nature (journal).
125. Terdiman, Daniel. "Study: Wikipedia as accurate as Britannica". CNET News.
126. (March 2006). "Fatally Flawed – Refuting the recent study on encyclopedic accuracy by the journal Nature". Encyclopædia Britannica, Incorporated.
127. (15 January 2016). "Wikipedia: an old-fashioned corner of truth on the internet".
128. (14 January 2016). "How Wikipedia changed the world".
129. (20 January 2016). "Our Letter to the Telegraph".
130. reviews by the Editorial Board of Reference Books Bulletin; revised introduction by Sandy Whiteley.. (1996). "Purchasing an Encyclopedia: 12 Points to Consider". Booklist Publications, American Library Association.
131. (1995). "Encyclopedias, Atlases, and Dictionaries". R. R. Bowker (A Reed Reference Publishing Company).
132. Arner, Robert D.. (1991). "Dobson's Encyclopaedia: The Publisher, Text, and Publication of America's First Britannica, 1789–1803". University of Pennsylvania Press.
133. (23 September 1929). "Patriarch Revised".
134. (16 September 1929). "A Completely New Encyclopaedia (''sic'') Britannica".
135. Thomas, Gillian. (1992). "A Position to Command Respect: Women and the Eleventh Britannica". [[Rowman & Littlefield.
136. (1968). "Banquet at Guildhall in the City of London, Tuesday 15 October 1968: Celebrating the 200th Anniversary of the ''Encyclopædia Britannica'' and the 25th Anniversary of the Honorable William Benton as its Chair and publisher". [[Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc..
137. (3 March 1934). "Reader".
138. (1 August 2003). "2004 Distinguished Achievement Awards Winners: Technology". [[Association of Educational Publishers]].
139. (14 July 2009). "Top Ten Superbrands 2009–2010". BBC.
140. Lang, J. P.. (1992). "Reference Sources for Small and Medium-Sized Libraries". American Library Association.
141. Goetz, Philip W.. (2007). "The New Encyclopædia Britannica". Encyclopaedia Britannica Incorporated.
142. (16 March 2023). "Nor da nor Lur Hiztegi Entziklopedikoan? Euskarazko lehenengo entziklopediaren demografia digital alderatua". Uztaro. Giza Eta Gizarte-zientzien Aldizkaria.
143. Prescott, Peter S.. (8 July 1974). "The Fifteenth Britannica".
144. (26 January 2005). "Schoolboy spots errors in Encyclopaedia Britannica".
145. Cunningham, Grainne. (3 February 2010). "Britannica errors spark unholy row". [[Irish Independent]].
146. Sheehy, Clodagh. (4 February 2010). "Are they taking the Mick? It's the encyclopedia that thinks the Civil War was between the north and south". [[The Herald (Ireland).
147. (1803). "Supplement to the Encyclopædia or Dictionary of Arts, Sciences and Miscellaneous Literature".
148. Stockwell, Foster. "A History of Information Storage and Retrieval".
149. William Smellie in the [[s: Preface to the 1st edition of the Encyclopædia Britannica. Preface]] to the 1st edition of the Encyclopædia Britannica
150. "Encyclopedia".
151. "Encyclopedia".
152. "Encyclopedia".
153. ''Encyclopædia Britannica'' (15th ed.). Chicago: Encyclopædia Britannica. 2007. interior flap.
154. Bosman, Julie. (13 March 2012). "After 244 Years, Encyclopædia Britannica Stops the Presses". The New York Times.
155. Day, Peter. (17 December 1997). "Encyclopaedia Britannica changes to survive". [[BBC News]].
156. "History of Encyclopædia Britannica and Britannica Online". Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc.
157. (2009). "The Early Britannica". Oxford University Press.