| 1 | Fiorello! | Jerry Bock | Sheldon Harnick | Jerome Weidman and George Abbott | 1959 | February 9–12, 1994 |
| 2 | Allegro | Richard Rodgers | Oscar Hammerstein II | 1947 | March 2–5, 1994 | Stephen Bogardus, Christine Ebersole, Celeste Holm, Karen Ziemba |
| 3 | Lady in the Dark | Kurt Weill | Ira Gershwin | Moss Hart | 1941 | May 4–7, 1994 |
| 4 | Call Me Madam | Irving Berlin | Howard Lindsay and Russell Crouse | 1950 | February 16–18, 1995 | Peter Bartlett, Walter Charles, Jane Connell, Tyne Daly, Christopher Durang, Melissa Errico, Ken Page |
| 5 | Out of This World | Cole Porter | Dwight Taylor and Reginald Lawrence | 1950 | March 30 – April 1, 1995 | LaChanze, Gregg Edelman, Andrea Martin, Marin Mazzie, Ken Page, Ernie Sabella, Peter Scolari |
| 6 | Pal Joey | Richard Rodgers | Lorenz Hart | John O'Hara | 1940 | May 4–6, 1995 |
| 7 | DuBarry Was a Lady | Cole Porter | Herbert Fields and Buddy DeSylva | 1939 | February 15–17, 1996 | Liz Larsen, Dick Latessa, Michael McGrath, Robert Morse, Burke Moses, Faith Prince, Donald Trump |
| 8 | One Touch of Venus | Kurt Weill | Ogden Nash | S. J. Perelman and Ogden Nash | 1943 | March 28–30, 1996 |
| 9 | Chicago | John Kander | Fred Ebb | Bob Fosse and Fred Ebb | 1975 | May 2–4, 1996 |
| 10 | Sweet Adeline | Jerome Kern | Oscar Hammerstein II | 1929 | February 13–16, 1997 | Gary Beach, Stephen Bogardus, Patti Cohenour, Dorothy Loudon, Hugh Panaro, Tony Randall |
| 11 | Promises, Promises | Burt Bacharach | Hal David | Neil Simon | 1968 | March 20–23, 1997 |
| 12 | The Boys from Syracuse | Richard Rodgers | Lorenz Hart | George Abbott | 1938 | May 1–4, 1997 |
| 13 | Strike up the Band | George Gershwin | Ira Gershwin | Morrie Ryskind | 1927 | February 12–15, 1998 |
| 14 | Li'l Abner | Gene De Paul | Johnny Mercer | Norman Panama and Melvin Frank | 1959 | March 26–30, 1998 |
| 15 | St. Louis Woman | Harold Arlen | Johnny Mercer | Arna Bontemps and Countee Cullen | 1946 | April 30 – May 3, 1998 |
| 16 | Babes in Arms | Richard Rodgers | Lorenz Hart | Richard Rodgers and Lorenz Hart | 1937 | February 11–14, 1999 |
| 17 | Ziegfeld Follies of 1936 | Vernon Duke | Ira Gershwin | Ira Gershwin and David Freedman | 1936 | March 25–29, 1999 |
| 18 | Do Re Mi | Jule Styne | Betty Comden and Adolph Green | Garson Kanin | 1960 | May 6–9, 1999 |
| 19 | On a Clear Day You Can See Forever | Burton Lane | Alan Jay Lerner | 1965 | February 10–13, 2000 | Brooks Ashmanskas, Brent Barrett, Roger Bart, Kristin Chenoweth, Peter Friedman, Nancy Opel, Louis Zorich |
| 20 | Tenderloin | Jerry Bock | Sheldon Harnick | George Abbott and Jerome Weidman | 1960 | March 23–27, 2000 |
| 21 | Wonderful Town | Leonard Bernstein | Betty Comden and Adolph Green | Joseph Fields and Jerome Chodorov | 1953 | May 3–7, 2000 |
| 22 | A Connecticut Yankee | Richard Rodgers | Lorenz Hart | Herbert Fields | 1927 | February 8–11, 2001 |
| 23 | Bloomer Girl | Harold Arlen | E.Y. Harburg | Sig Herzig and Fred Saidy | 1944 | March 22–25, 2001 |
| 24 | Hair | Galt MacDermot | Gerome Ragni and James Rado | 1967 | May 3–7, 2001 | Kevin Cahoon, Luther Creek, Gavin Creel, Jesse Tyler Ferguson, Brandi Chavonne Massey, Idina Menzel, Miriam Shor |
| 25 | Carnival! | Bob Merrill | Michael Stewart | 1961 | February 7–10, 2002 | Debbie Gravitte, Anne Hathaway, David Margulies, Brian Stokes Mitchell, Douglas Sills |
| 26 | Golden Boy | Charles Strouse | Lee Adams | Clifford Odets and William Gibson | 1964 | March 21–24, 2002 |
| 27 | The Pajama Game | Richard Adler and Jerry Ross | George Abbott and Richard Bissell | 1954 | May 2–6, 2002 | Mark Linn-Baker, Brent Barrett, Deidre Goodwin, Daniel Jenkins, Ken Page, Karen Ziemba |
| 28 | House of Flowers | Harold Arlen | Harold Arlen and Truman Capote | Truman Capote | 1954 | February 13–16, 2003 |
| 29 | The New Moon | Sigmund Romberg | Oscar Hammerstein II | Oscar Hammerstein II, Frank Mandel, and Laurence Schwab | 1928 | March 27–30, 2003 |
| 30 | No Strings | Richard Rodgers | Samuel A. Taylor | 1962 | May 8–11, 2003 | Len Cariou, Penny Fuller, Marc Kudisch, James Naughton, Emily Skinner |
| 31 | Can-Can | Cole Porter | Abe Burrows | 1953 | February 12–15, 2004 | Charlotte d'Amboise, Patti LuPone, Michael Nouri, Reg Rogers, Eli Wallach |
| 32 | Pardon My English | George Gershwin | Ira Gershwin | Herbert Fields and Morrie Ryskind | 1933 | March 25–28, 2004 |
| 33 | Bye Bye Birdie | Charles Strouse | Lee Adams | Michael Stewart | 1960 | May 6–9, 2004 |
| 34 | A Tree Grows in Brooklyn | Arthur Schwartz | Dorothy Fields | George Abbott and Betty Smith | 1951 | February 10–13, 2005 |
| 35 | Purlie | Gary Geld | Peter Udell | Ossie Davis, Philip Rose, and Peter Udell | 1970 | March 31 – April 3, 2005 |
| 36 | The Apple Tree | Jerry Bock | Sheldon Harnick | Jerry Bock, Sheldon Harnick, and Jerome Coopersmith | 1966 | May 12–16, 2005 |
| 37 | Kismet | Robert Wright and George Forrest, adapting themes by Alexander Borodin | Robert Wright and George Forrest | Charles Lederer and Luther Davis | 1953 | February 9–12, 2006 |
| 38 | 70, Girls, 70 | John Kander | Fred Ebb | Fred Ebb, Norman L. Martin, and Joe Masteroff | 1971 | March 30 – April 2, 2006 |
| 39 | Of Thee I Sing | George Gershwin | Ira Gershwin | George S. Kaufman and Morrie Ryskind | 1931 | May 11–15, 2006 |
| 40 | Follies | Stephen Sondheim | James Goldman | 1971 | February 8–11, 2007 | Christine Baranski, Philip Bosco, Victoria Clark, Yvonne Constant, Colin Donnell, Victor Garber, Mimi Hines, Michael McGrath, Donna Murphy, Jenny Powers, Jo Anne Worley |
| 41 | Face the Music | Irving Berlin | Moss Hart | 1932 | March 29 – April 1, 2007 | Walter Bobbie, Judy Kaye, Meredith Patterson, Lee Wilkof |
| 42 | Stairway to Paradise | Various | | May 10–14, 2007 | Kristin Chenoweth, Christopher Fitzgerald, Jennifer Gambatese, Michael Gruber, Ruthie Henshall, Capathia Jenkins | |
| 43 | Applause | Charles Strouse | Lee Adams | Betty Comden and Adolph Green | 1970 | February 7–10, 2008 |
| 44 | Juno | Marc Blitzstein | Joseph Stein | 1959 | March 27–30, 2008 | Michael Arden, Victoria Clark, Tyler Hanes, Celia Keenan-Bolger, Rosaleen Linehan |
| 45 | No, No, Nanette | Vincent Youmans | Irving Caesar and Otto Harbach | Otto Harbach and Frank Mandel, adapted by Burt Shevelove | 1925 (revised 1971) | May 8–12, 2008 |
| 46 | On the Town | Leonard Bernstein | Betty Comden and Adolph Green | 1945 | November 19–23, 2008 | Christian Borle, Jessica Lee Goldyn, Leslie Kritzer, Andrea Martin, Jennifer Laura Thompson, Tony Yazbeck |
| 47 | Music in the Air | Jerome Kern | Oscar Hammerstein II | 1932 | February 5–8, 2009 | Sierra Boggess, Walter Charles, Kristin Chenoweth, Dick Latessa, Marni Nixon, Douglas Sills |
| 48 | Finian's Rainbow | Burton Lane | E.Y. Harburg | E.Y. Harburg and Fred Saidy | 1947 | March 26–29, 2009 |
| 49 | Girl Crazy | George Gershwin | Ira Gershwin | Guy Bolton and John McGowan | 1930 | November 19–22, 2009 |
| 50 | Fanny | Harold Rome | S. N. Behrman and Joshua Logan | 1954 | February 4–7, 2010 | George Hearn, Priscilla Lopez, Elena Shaddow, James Snyder |
| 51 | Anyone Can Whistle | Stephen Sondheim | Arthur Laurents | 1964 | April 8–11, 2010 | Raúl Esparza, Sutton Foster, Edward Hibbert, Donna Murphy |
| 52 | Bells Are Ringing | Jule Styne | Betty Comden and Adolph Green | 1956 | November 18–21, 2010 | Bobby Cannavale, Will Chase, Judy Kaye, Kelli O'Hara, Brad Oscar, Danny Rutigliano |
| 53 | Lost in the Stars | Kurt Weill | Maxwell Anderson | 1949 | February 3–6, 2011 | Daniel Breaker, Chuck Cooper, Patina Miller |
| 54 | Where's Charley? | Frank Loesser | George Abbott | 1948 | March 17–20, 2011 | Sebastian Arcelus, Rebecca Luker, Rob McClure, Howard McGillin, Jill Paice, Lauren Worsham |
| 55 | Merrily We Roll Along | Stephen Sondheim | George Furth | 1981 | February 8–19, 2012 | Colin Donnell, Celia Keenan-Bolger, Lin-Manuel Miranda, Betsy Wolfe |
| 56 | Pipe Dream | Richard Rodgers | Oscar Hammerstein II | 1955 | March 28 – April 1, 2012 | Will Chase, Laura Osnes, Leslie Uggams, Stephen Wallem, Tom Wopat |
| 57 | Gentlemen Prefer Blondes | Jule Styne | Leo Robin | Joseph Fields and Anita Loos | 1949 | May 9–13, 2012 |
| 58 | Fiorello! | Jerry Bock | Sheldon Harnick | Jerome Weidman and George Abbott | 1959 | January 30 – February 3, 2013 |
| 59 | It's a Bird... It's a Plane... It's Superman | Charles Strouse | Lee Adams | Robert Benton and David Newman | 1966 | March 20–24, 2013 |
| 60 | On Your Toes | Richard Rodgers | Lorenz Hart | Richard Rodgers, Lorenz Hart, and George Abbott | 1936 | May 8–12, 2013 |
| 61 | Little Me | Cy Coleman | Carolyn Leigh | Neil Simon | 1962 | February 5–9, 2014 |
| 62 | The Most Happy Fella | Frank Loesser | 1956 | April 2–6, 2014 | Laura Benanti, Heidi Blickenstaff, Shuler Hensley, Cheyenne Jackson, Jay Armstrong Johnson, Jessica Molaskey | |
| 63 | Irma La Douce | Marguerite Monnot | Alexandre Breffort; English version by Julian More, David Heneker, and Monty Norman | 1956 (translated 1958) | May 7–11, 2014 | Malcolm Gets, Rob McClure |
| 64 | Lady, Be Good! | George Gershwin | Ira Gershwin | Guy Bolton and Fred Thompson | 1924 | February 4–8, 2015 |
| 65 | Paint Your Wagon | Frederick Loewe | Alan Jay Lerner | 1951 | March 18–22, 2015 | Keith Carradine, Justin Guarini, Alexandra Socha |
| 66 | Zorba! | John Kander | Fred Ebb | Joseph Stein | 1968 | May 6–10, 2015 |
| 67 | Cabin in the Sky | Vernon Duke | John Latouche | Lynn Root | 1940 | February 10–14, 2016 |
| 68 | 1776 | Sherman Edwards | Peter Stone | 1969 | March 30 – April 3, 2016 | John Behlmann, André De Shields, Santino Fontana, Alexander Gemignani, John Larroquette, Christiane Noll, Bryce Pinkham, Jubilant Sykes |
| 69 | Do I Hear a Waltz? | Richard Rodgers | Stephen Sondheim | Arthur Laurents | 1965 | May 11–15, 2016 |
| 70 | Big River | Roger Miller | William Hauptman | 1985 | February 8–12, 2017 | Annie Golden, Kyle Scatliffe, Christopher Sieber, Lauren Worsham |
| 71 | The New Yorkers | Cole Porter | Herbert Fields | 1930 | March 22–26, 2017 | Kevin Chamberlin, Scarlett Strallen |
| 72 | The Golden Apple | Jerome Moross | John Latouche | 1954 | May 10–14, 2017 | Ashley Brown, Lindsay Mendez |
| 73 | Hey, Look Me Over! | Various | | February 7–11, 2018 | Vanessa Williams, Carolee Carmello, Judy Kuhn, Marc Kudisch, Reed Birney, Bebe Neuwirth, Nancy Opel, Douglas Sills, Alexandra Socha | |
| 74 | Grand Hotel | Robert Wright, George Forrest, and Maury Yeston | Luther Davis | 1989 | March 21–25, 2018 | Brandon Uranowitz, Heléne Yorke, James Snyder, Irina Dvorovenko, John Dossett |
| 75 | Me and My Girl | Noel Gay | Douglas Furber and L. Arthur Rose | Douglas Furber and L. Arthur Rose, revised by Stephen Fry and Mike Ockrent | 1937 (revised 1984) | May 9–13, 2018 |
| 76 | Call Me Madam | Irving Berlin | Howard Lindsay and Russell Crouse | 1950 | February 6–10, 2019 | Carmen Cusack, Darrell Hammond, Carol Kane, Lauren Worsham |
| 77 | I Married an Angel | Richard Rodgers | Lorenz Hart | Richard Rodgers and Lorenz Hart | 1938 | March 20–24, 2019 |
| 78 | High Button Shoes | Jule Styne | Sammy Cahn | George Abbott and Stephen Longstreet | 1947 | May 8–12, 2019 |
| 79 | Mack and Mabel | Jerry Herman | Michael Stewart | 1974 | February 19–23, 2020 | Lilli Cooper, Douglas Sills, Alexandra Socha |
| 80 | The Tap Dance Kid | Henry Krieger | Robert Lorick | Charles Blackwell | 1983 | February 2–6, 2022 |
| 81 | The Life | Cy Coleman | Ira Gasman | David Newman, Cy Coleman, and Ira Gasman | 1997 | March 16–20, 2022 |
| 82 | Into the Woods | Stephen Sondheim | James Lapine | 1987 | May 4–15, 2022 | Sara Bareilles, Denée Benton, Gavin Creel, Jordan Donica, Annie Golden, Ann Harada, Neil Patrick Harris, Heather Headley, David Patrick Kelly, Julia Lester, Shereen Pimentel |
| 83 | Dear World | Jerry Herman | Jerome Lawrence and Robert E. Lee | 1969 | March 15–19, 2023 | Donna Murphy, Brooks Ashmanskas, Andréa Burns, Christopher Fitzgerald, Ann Harada, Kody Jauron, Phillip Johnson Richardson, Samantha Williams |
| 84 | Oliver! | Lionel Bart | 1960 | May 3–14, 2023 | Raúl Esparza, Lilli Cooper, Tam Mutu, Brad Oscar, Benjamin Pajak, Mary Testa, Julian Lerner, Michael Siberry | |
| 85 | The Light in the Piazza | Adam Guettel | Craig Lucas | 2005 | June 21–25, 2023 | Ruthie Ann Miles, Anna Zavelson, James D. Gish, Ivan Hernandez, Andréa Burns, Shereen Ahmed, Rodd Cyrus |
| 86 | Once Upon a Mattress | Mary Rodgers | Marshall Barer | Jay Thompson, Dean Fuller, and Marshall Barer | 1959 | January 21–28, 2024 |
| 87 | Jelly's Last Jam | Jelly Roll Morton and Luther Henderson | Susan Birkenhead | George C. Wolfe | 1992 | February 21–25, 2024 |
| 88 | Titanic | Maury Yeston | Peter Stone | 1997 | June 12–16, 2024 | Bonnie Milligan, Chuck Cooper, Eddie Cooper, Drew Gehling, Ramin Karimloo, Emilie Kouatchou, Judy Kuhn, Brandon Uranowitz, Samantha Williams, Chip Zien |
| 89 | Urinetown | Mark Hollmann | Mark Hollmann and Greg Kotis | Greg Kotis | 2001 | February 5–16, 2025 |
| 90 | Love Life | Kurt Weill | Alan Jay Lerner | 1948 | March 26—30, 2025 | Kate Baldwin, Brian Stokes Mitchell |
| 91 | Wonderful Town | Leonard Bernstein | Betty Comden and Adolph Green | Joseph Fields and Jerome Chodorov | 1953 | April 30–May 11, 2025 |
| 92 | High Spirits | Hugh Martin and Timothy Gray | 1964 | February 4–15, 2026 | Phillipa Soo, Steven Pasquale | |
| 93 | The Wild Party | Michael John LaChiusa | Michael John LaChiusa and George C. Wolfe | 2000 | March 18–29, 2026 | |
| 94 | La Cage aux Folles | Jerry Herman | Harvey Fierstein | 1983 | June 17–28, 2026 | Billy Porter |
| :: | | | | | | |